Post Game Thread: Carolina Hurricanes at New York Islanders - 07 Mar 2020
[PGT]
NHL.com Boxscore
| Teams | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | OT | Total |
|---|
| CAR | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 3 |
| NYI | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| Team | Shots | Hits | Blocked | FO Wins | Giveaways | Takeaways | Power Plays |
|---|
| CAR | 28 | 33 | 17 | 53.2% | 15 | 7 | 1/5 |
| NYI | 26 | 34 | 13 | 46.8% | 19 | 6 | 0/3 |
| Period | Time | Team | Type | Min | Description |
|---|
| 1st | 16:58 | NYI | Minor | 4 | Leo Komarov Hi stick - double minor against Brady Skjei |
| 2nd | 02:57 | NYI | Bench Minor | 2 | Too many men/ice served by Jordan Eberle |
| 2nd | 11:09 | CAR | Minor | 2 | Ryan Dzingel Roughing against Anthony Beauvillier served by Martin Necas |
| 2nd | 11:09 | CAR | Major | 5 | against Anthony Beauvillier |
| 2nd | 11:09 | NYI | Major | 5 | against Ryan Dzingel |
| 2nd | 11:09 | NYI | Major | 5 | Anthony Beauvillier Fighting against Ryan Dzingel |
| 2nd | 11:09 | CAR | Major | 5 | Ryan Dzingel Fighting against Anthony Beauvillier |
| 2nd | 17:54 | CAR | Minor | 2 | Andrei Svechnikov Delaying Game - Puck over glass |
| 3rd | 19:08 | CAR | Minor | 2 | Brady Skjei Tripping against Mathew Barzal |
| 3rd | 19:36 | NYI | Minor | 4 | Mathew Barzal Hi stick - double minor against Jordan Staal |
Posted Mar 7, 2020, 8:46 PM UTC
https://imgur.com/a/7k2eDyu
Good view here. After seeing this, I think the refs actually got this right, considering rule is now on the shoulders (for a non-goal) and not the crossbar.
Until i saw this angle, I thought we got away with one. But this is right at shoulder level (the puck made contact on the heel). At worst, it's questionable; at best, it's a good goal.
I'd go as far as the other side of this coin. At best, its realllly freaking close-not conclusive. At worst, it's high. Luckily for us, the call on the ice gives us the benefit of the doubt.
Nah, the rule reads "normal height" of the shoulders and Svech is leaning, meaning they're below normal height. I get that we both have our biases, but with this angle it's pretty cut and dry for me.
I was heavy-leaning no goal until I saw this.
I looked at the rule and missed the normal height part. That makes a huge difference.
Also, what a TERRIBLE rule. Wtf is normal? Normal is standing completely upright? Ok, but with skates on? I mean that seems obvious, but is it "normal"? They really should find some constant to use. I think the players shoulders at the time of contact would be better and easier for the player to judge too.
Yep people who don’t know the shoulder/crossbar rule are the ones bitching
[removed]
True, but the line is drawn on the midpoint of the shoulders. Is that the rule, or should it be drawn from the top of the pads? While this view may make it appear the contact is lower than reality, the other angle may make it appear to be higher than reality. When you have to get down to this level of if/but to argue a call, that is when you stick with the call on the ice.
Yes, I am a hurricanes fan so believe me or dont. I think it was almost certainly a high stick. Almost. But that's enough doubt to not overturn.
I'd at the very least call this inconclusive, i just have a strong issue with low angles when if he's holding the stick above and in front of you it can appear to be lower from behind and below