r/hockey•
GDT_Bot

Post Game Thread: Carolina Hurricanes at New York Islanders - 07 Mar 2020

[PGT]

NHL.com Boxscore

Teams1st2nd3rdOTTotal
CAR10113
NYI01102
TeamShotsHitsBlockedFO WinsGiveawaysTakeawaysPower Plays
CAR28331753.2%1571/5
NYI26341346.8%1960/3
PeriodTimeTeamStrengthDescription
1st13:22CAREvenJustin Williams (5) Deflected, assists: Haydn Fleury (8)
2nd05:15NYIEvenRyan Pulock (10) Wrist Shot, assists: Anders Lee (22)
3rd06:16CAREvenJoel Edmundson (7) Wrist Shot, assists: Teuvo Teravainen (46), Andrei Svechnikov (35)
3rd15:02NYIEvenJosh Bailey (14) Wrist Shot, assists: Noah Dobson (5), Andy Greene (12)
OT01:36CARPower PlaySebastian Aho (37) Wrist Shot, assists: none
PeriodTimeTeamTypeMinDescription
1st16:58NYIMinor4Leo Komarov Hi stick - double minor against Brady Skjei
2nd02:57NYIBench Minor2Too many men/ice served by Jordan Eberle
2nd11:09CARMinor2Ryan Dzingel Roughing against Anthony Beauvillier served by Martin Necas
2nd11:09CARMajor5against Anthony Beauvillier
2nd11:09NYIMajor5against Ryan Dzingel
2nd11:09NYIMajor5Anthony Beauvillier Fighting against Ryan Dzingel
2nd11:09CARMajor5Ryan Dzingel Fighting against Anthony Beauvillier
2nd17:54CARMinor2Andrei Svechnikov Delaying Game - Puck over glass
3rd19:08CARMinor2Brady Skjei Tripping against Mathew Barzal
3rd19:36NYIMinor4Mathew Barzal Hi stick - double minor against Jordan Staal

Posted Mar 7, 2020, 8:46 PM UTC

34172
iiPixel•

https://imgur.com/a/7k2eDyu

Good view here. After seeing this, I think the refs actually got this right, considering rule is now on the shoulders (for a non-goal) and not the crossbar.

44
cobalt26:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

Until i saw this angle, I thought we got away with one. But this is right at shoulder level (the puck made contact on the heel). At worst, it's questionable; at best, it's a good goal.

15
fredizdman•

I'd go as far as the other side of this coin. At best, its realllly freaking close-not conclusive. At worst, it's high. Luckily for us, the call on the ice gives us the benefit of the doubt.

4
cobalt26:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

Nah, the rule reads "normal height" of the shoulders and Svech is leaning, meaning they're below normal height. I get that we both have our biases, but with this angle it's pretty cut and dry for me.

I was heavy-leaning no goal until I saw this.

5
fredizdman•

I looked at the rule and missed the normal height part. That makes a huge difference.

Also, what a TERRIBLE rule. Wtf is normal? Normal is standing completely upright? Ok, but with skates on? I mean that seems obvious, but is it "normal"? They really should find some constant to use. I think the players shoulders at the time of contact would be better and easier for the player to judge too.

5
cmokelley213:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

Yep people who don’t know the shoulder/crossbar rule are the ones bitching

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2†
fredizdman•

True, but the line is drawn on the midpoint of the shoulders. Is that the rule, or should it be drawn from the top of the pads? While this view may make it appear the contact is lower than reality, the other angle may make it appear to be higher than reality. When you have to get down to this level of if/but to argue a call, that is when you stick with the call on the ice.

Yes, I am a hurricanes fan so believe me or dont. I think it was almost certainly a high stick. Almost. But that's enough doubt to not overturn.

2
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

I'd at the very least call this inconclusive, i just have a strong issue with low angles when if he's holding the stick above and in front of you it can appear to be lower from behind and below

2
ILookLikeDrewGulak:NHL-NJD1: NJD - NHL•

That seemed like a pretty clear high stick. That’s pretty ridiculous.

40
Nugget203:NHL-CAR3:CAR - NHL•
8†
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

One frame, blurry, low angle, literally a useless image

-16
canesnosebleeds•

What good would a high angle shot do?

13
iiPixel•

Yeah if anything a low angle makes it look worse than it actually is...

13
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

What good does a low angle shot do from behind?

I literally just took a video of myself to check, but at a lower angle I can hold my stick forward and up (like happened in the play) and from the angle it looks like its level with my shoulder even when its not

-4
tmoss726:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

Clearly not enough to overturn the goal called on the ice

3
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

Its an image that shows it was level with shoulder aka not against the rules, are you lost?

3
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•
3
i_wannatalktosamson:NHL-NYI2: NYI - NHL•

Msg showed an angle where it looked clear as day it was a high stick

38
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•
6
KunuBro:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

There was also an angle where it looked to be right at his shoulders (the bar isn’t in play here), so it’s inconclusive. Call on the ice was a goal, so it stands.

-5†
7denile7:NHL-WSH1: WSH - NHL•

MSG showed a freeze frame right when he touched the puck, it looked definitely above the shoulder. Coming from someone who has no horse in this race.

14
ericdavidmorris:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Bro it was way above his shoulders I understand you’re a Canes fan but take your blinders off and watch the angle I posted below

-8†
KunuBro:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Take yours off and go to the post right after this one with the replay. Tough call but definitely inconclusive, so the call on the ice stands.

16
Buddynorris:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Please show us the angle where it was inconclusive. Because every angle showed it was blatantly high. Yes over his shoulders.

-9
Nugget203:NHL-CAR3:CAR - NHL•
9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mc_hambone:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Please show me a better angle than looking directly across the ice when he contacts the puck level or below his shoulders.

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-11
I_Myke_I•

Your joking right?

11
imdrinkingteaatwork:NHL-NYI3: NYI - NHL•

NHL reviewed it.

9
4Darco:NHL-PHI1: PHI - NHL•

That's a fucking horrible call. Isles got robbed.

37
tmoss726:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•
6†
summer6teen:NHL-NYI5: NYI - NHL•
-8†
tmoss726:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

Salty lol

4
_tangus_:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Lmao dude you should take a perspective class, that angle is so unfair

4
mbx220:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

again

2†
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•
2
4Darco:NHL-PHI1: PHI - NHL•

I'll admit it's closer on review than I initially thought it was, but I still think it's a high stick. I really hate the isles and I was rooting for you guys the whole game (I'm not holding the call against the canes), but I still think they got screwed.

2†
NeverForget06:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Uhhhh that was a high stick...

31
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

It only appeared to be because Svech wasn't standing up straight at the time of contact with the puck.

4
mc_hambone:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Nope.

3†
cosmic-melodies:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Hi welcome to the NYI, where it’s impossible NOT to be a ref conspiracy theorist. This shit pretty much happens every game.

1
NontransferableApe:NHL-CBJ1: CBJ - NHL•

That’s a bad call

30
ericdavidmorris:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•
14
tanu24:NHL-NYI2: NYI - NHL•

This is getting fucking annoying. We’re on another level of reffing this year

13
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

We can relate IslesBros

3†
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

It is not the height of the shoulders when the player makes contact. It is height of the shoulders if the player is standing up.

5
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•
4
NontransferableApe:NHL-CBJ1: CBJ - NHL•

No it doesn’t. It actually proves the point even more. Having those photos cropped together shows his stick blade would be resting on his shoulder if they were lineup up in a straight line. It’s still not below

2†
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

The stick is at, not above the shoulder. Beyond that, Svech is not standing up straight in the second image.

1
NontransferableApe:NHL-CBJ1: CBJ - NHL•

It’s literally above his shoulder. Also you can’t crop together photos that took place at different areas on the ice. The camera doesn’t move so its not an accurate depiction

1
xjared45:NHL-NYI3: NYI - NHL•

It was a high stick bro. you guys got away with one

-1†
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

Lmao refs absolutely botched that review, what the fuck do they pay these clowns?

e: refs, league? Doesn't matter they have clear angles of his stick far above his shoulders, how do they take that long and make the wrong call?

26
LordDelibird:WCH-NorthAmerica: North America - WCH•

This was technically an NHL review. Toronto is the one who called that a goal.

15
I_Myke_I•

Man they hate us for what we did to Tavares....

9
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

Lmao Tavares did it to himself

5
I_Myke_I•

Oh Ik lol

3
redbeards:NHL-WSH2: WSH - NHL•

Refs should have called it on the ice.

1†
sade3437:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

they did, they called it a goal.

2
brunoamandrill:NHL-NYI5: NYI - NHL•

NHL reviewed it but yes

4
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•
3
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

It doesn’t matter because the league claims that it hitting the crossbar makes it legal to play again. Unfortunately all the arguing about if it was or wasn’t a high stick doesn’t matter either way and we all wasted our time

But upvotes for doing some dirty work to try to make sense of things

7
sade3437:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

it's funny how you say it's clear as day then try to argue how angles in a video/screenshot can't tell the whole story.

0†
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

Did you actually read the argument I was making or are you just strawmanning me for the sake of being a cunt?

3
sade3437:NHL-CAR2: CAR - NHL•

In this age of the internet it should be obvious as all day that angles can be misleading

Clearly stating shit is misleading.

Doesn't matter they have clear angles of his stick far above his shoulders, how do they take that long and make the wrong call?

Claims there are not just one but multiple clear angles proving your view.

Where are these clear views you talk of? Or are you just being a cunt?

-1
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

It’s not misleading? How is saying that using a specific angle can be misleading untrue?

Also I only had access to the MSG angle at the time of the comment.

You’re just here to be a combative cunt. Fuck off, I’ve clearly explained myself, I don’t need to watch you selective choose random pieces of my comments to try to act like I’m making some dishonest claim

3
pacefalmd:ECHL-RaleighIceCaps: Raleigh Ice Caps - ECHL•

That definitely looked high. Pretty terrible review imo

23
Merisiel:NHL-CBJ1: CBJ - NHL•

Yikes. Bad call.

21
w41twh4t:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

There are many in every game but this time they had it correct. Not a high stick.

2
tozpoz:NHL-NJD1: NJD - NHL•

Looked like a clear high stick to me but I’m also a pleeb

20
bpmorris92:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Barry better go all Torts here

20
summer6teen:NHL-NYI5: NYI - NHL•

I hope he comes out blasting, what's a 10k fine for him?

8
DentedOnImpact:NHL-WSH6: WSH - NHL•

Barry about to catch a 10k NHL fine

4
ItIsSpelledBarzal:NHL-NYI6: NYI - NHL•

I just don’t fucking understand anymore

18
Calhalen:NHL-OTT4: OTT - NHL•

Brutal call. Seems clear as day on the msg feed it’s high. How do they mess that up

18
lhkemperor•

Found the ruling in the rule book that says if the puck makes contact with the crossbar/post but does not cross the line, a high stick will be negated in that situation.

Just kidding, the Isles got fucked again there by the referees. Clear high stick IMO

18
AnthonyCostantini:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Horrible

17
wolfpackrider:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Don’t let a very questionable review on a game winning goal distract from the fact that Barzal took a terrible double minor while on a power play that could have carried into overtime.

17
deathops:NHL-NYI2: NYI - NHL•

No I will let it distract me from that?

7
Roboturner913•

20 seconds after taking the dive of the year

6
wolfpackrider:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

I am not even upset about that one. Brady has to know you don’t put the refs into a position to dick you over, especially on the road where the crowd can help influence a call. Brady can’t have his stick in his feet because that’s going to get called a trip instead of an embellishment 9 times out of 10.

4†
Roboturner913•

No argument, I'm just saying, puck don't lie

1†
IslesBeBack:NHL-NYI3: NYI - NHL•

What a fucking joke.

16
Buddynorris:NHL-NYI1: NYI - NHL•

Refs find another way to bury isles. You honestly cannot make it up.

15
I_Myke_I•

Refs have hated the isles recently

14
ColdRevenge76:NHL-CBJ1: CBJ - NHL•

It's not just the Isles. They have been horrible for months. The one Torts called out was just a drop in the bucket of the problems. He just happened to have been pissed off enough to mention that one.

4
I_Myke_I•

It’s ridiculous man

4
White_Label:NHL-CAR1: CAR - NHL•

Looked like a pretty clear high stick...

14