Best value restaurants around Indy?

I want to preface this by saying that I am not looking for gargantuan portion sizes like at Rathskeller, though I do love Rathskeller. I am just trying to find a reasonable meal that I can sit down and eat for $15-25. Bluebeard has lost its allure.

Posted Mar 8, 2020, 12:11 AM UTC

325
6295•

We do yats when we way something affordable and quick. What type of meal are you looking for?

11
notthegoatseguyCarmel •

Yats is also a great option. 54/College is the best one as the food is still made fresh on site. If I had to choose one downtown, I'd choose Mass Ave as Joe's wife runs it.

7
luthurianAvon•

You can really tell the difference with the suburban locations. The trucked in food is....okay I guess. But seems like about half the portion. Not ideal for the price.

1
notthegoatseguyCarmel •

My understanding is the trucked in food is all locations except for the 54/College. I know the Mass Ave used to get their food delivered daily by the College location when they were at their original location, and I assume they switched over to keep prices down.

Joe has hinted, but not quite said clearly, that the 54/College locations is probably not profitable but he just loves the neighborhood and loves making food every day.

8
lil_CSUButler-Tarkington•

Do you like Ethiopian food?

Because it’s one of the best bang for your buck amazing tasting food options out there

Axum Is my favorite restaurant in the city :)

$12 and you can barely walk to your car...

6
6295•

This is a great suggestion. Axum is my favorite by far and the owner is so kind!

3
koavf•

This is a great answer but I personally prefer Major. Can't go wrong either way.

0
Melsbells00•

There are a lot of great, inexpensive restaurants in the International food area (38th/Lafayette) Put in $ on Yelp and search by rating, lots of 4 star options.

4
notthegoatseguyCarmel •

Shalimar is my favorite Indian, Sichuan or Asian Snack are my favorite Chinese. Any Indian place will do as will any of the authentic Chinese places will do. Shalimar you will leave stuffed but not overly stuffed. Sichuan Chinese in Carmel, you gotta be real careful because these are family size portions but no where do they tell you that. It is just how it is. If you order an appetizer, that is enough for 2-3 people. Entree will be similar. If you're solo, expect to have left overs.

Sichuan and Shalimar also have lunch buffets. Worth noting Sichuan's weekend buffet is not Americanized but authentic Chinese food.

2
offballDgang•

Next time you go to Sichuan ask for the other menu. Real deal chinese food.

1
notthegoatseguyCarmel •

I was not aware they had a separate menu. Everything I've seen shows it all on the same menu, though split into different sections. Traditional and...American or something like that.

1
offballDgang•

Its in Korean but can be decifered on your phone. SPICY

1
daymanxxCarmel •

To add on to your carmel suggestions. Pad thai is great. $7.99 lunch gets you an entree soup salad and egg roll

1

I get outta Broad Ripple Brewpub for $15-$25 after a beer and a meal all the time. Idk if that's the type of food you're looking for. Twenty Tap and Sinking Ship, too. I like pub food. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

2
DukeOfIndiana•

Thai Town Cuisine. There’s two locations now.

2
Mexicat55•

Nobody has posted it yet but Brothers bar and grill has an amazing deal on Tuesday. It’s 2 dollar cheeseburgers (no limit) and a dollar for awesome fries. Burgers come with the works and your choice of cheese. I was weary about the quality but was happily surprised. They also sell domestic bottles for 3 bucks the same day.

2
PingPongProfessorSouthside •

Chinese: Yen Ching on East Washington St

Indian: Tandoori Flame in Southern Plaza; India Palace on Lafayette Rd

Mexican: La Hacienda on West 38th; El Jalapeno on S. US 31 between I-465 and Thompson Rd

Breakfast: FlapJacks on Madison Ave just north of Thompson Rd

1
ScuzzBucket317•

Yen ching on east Washington is the best Chinese I've ever had... Like all Chinese is just varying degrees of the same thing. Not yen ching, it's delicious!

1
hastur777•

Yats is the cheapest best food in Indy. Donut Shop is super cheap too.

1
tinatsarina•

Liter Haus is a more reasonable portioned German option, $14 got me 2 meals out of my order and it was damn tasty!

1
Fluffyknickers•

I agree with Yatz, they're delicious.

Bub's Burgers in Carmel is good. I like George's on 71st and Binford. There's Mario's on 54th and Mama Carrolla's in Broad Ripple. And Fat Dan's, also in BR. For sushi there's Forty Five Degrees downtown. And I love Iozzo's on S. Meridian.

If you like bar food GG's near 71st and Binford serves some really delicious food. Try their mobster pizza, wicked Thai wraps, or seafood platter. Their steak is really damn good for the price too.

1
FrankieFastHands17•

Yats

1
clifmarsHoly Cross•

Lots of buffets. I work at IUPUI, so I have both a killed Indian joint and a good Asian joint (yeah yeah, Indian is Asian, but we tend to pretend it is a different thing in the states!) right in the 'food triangle'...for less than $10, you get great food and if you are paying attention to what you get, you can get something pretty healthy.

Or bad and fatty and filling.

If you want 'value' buffets are the way to go. I'm giving buffets about another month before the Corona scares me off from them because if there is one thing Americans love more than getting sick, it's getting sick and going to a buffet.

0
classyass184•

City Barbeque for chain food. For local not really anything in Indy comes to mind.

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8
bhorgicon•

stick to mcdonald’s & taco bell

-15