A Request for Feedback
I am wondering if I could hear from current Biden supporters who would otherwise support Bernie if not for the electability concerns they have. I certainly comment a lot on here as I don't feel the need to post since topics are usually covered well. However, I'm not sure this will.
In the fall, we need to win battle ground states in the Rustbelt and southwest. Throughout the coarse of the campaign so far, as shown in polling and voting, Bernie does very well with the latinx community, with independent voters, and with working class/union voters (both Rustbelt and elsewhere like Nevada) and we know these are crucial for wins in those areas. We also know that even on Super Tuesday Bernie's policies like Medicare4All were very popular, its just that most people voted on electability instead policy preference. And if I may, the youth turnout was actually up (about 10% in Texas compared to 2016; i haven't checked the other states but I can if people don't think this trend holds), just not nearly as much as the older turnout and therefore as a percentage declined.
Another thing that many will agree is that for a successful campaign in the general you want to have an energetic and devoted voting base, I think of all things people can say about Bernie supporters being unenergetic/undevoted is certainly not one of them. The main message of the campaign is predicated on the idea that we are willing to fight for people we don't know or even disagree with. This is because beneath all the division and angst is empathy.
We (and much of America) believe healthcare is a human right, does that mean we won't compromise if need be? No. Does that mean we aren't going to point out why we think a public options has flaws where single payer doesn't? Also no. At the end of the day the fight always seems impossible until it's done. Many told Obama that the ACA would never get passed, its a pie in the sky dream, you should just give up now. But he didn't. He fought hard for what he believed in and got it done. It's the same way now with Medicare4All. We need to fight for what we believe in, giving up because it'll be hard just isn't option for many people. Mentioning the ACA, I think its also helpful to point out that Bernie voted for it. Many often say that Bernie is "all or nothing" or "my way or the highway" but if that was true, why would he vote for the ACA? He knew that it was important step in the right direction regardless of if he disagreed with some of it.
Now let's talk about polls. in those key swing states I mentioned earlier Bernie polls well against Trump. In Michigan he is up by 5%, in PA by 3%, NM has very little polling but seems very good (up by 18%), VA 2.7%, Ohio not alot of data but looks good (2.5%), MN not alot of polls but looks good (9%), etc. These fights are winnable.
It's not all good. I'll be the one to admit it. Florida is probably not an option for Sanders but might be for Biden. Right now RCP has both up by about 1.5% over Trump but I suspect that might fall. If we have the mobility necessary I say we can fight for it but it would probably be easier with Biden. I also think a Bernie run looks very different than a Biden run. The two campaigns are fundamentally differently. Biden's campaign is right out of the Democratic Strategy playbook and has worked in the past (and also failed). Bernie's campaign is different, its not McGovern's, its not Dukakis', its Bernie's. The thing that gives me hope is that the elements he needs and relies on, are happening. We are seeing an unprecedented turnout of young people, people of color, and working class people. They certainly do not all vote for him in the primary but this is the coalition he believes he can inspire and lead to a victory in a general election. I also strongly believe the people who are currently supporting Biden will vote blue no matter who.
So that's my case for why Bernie is electable. I'm curious what y'all think. Is this convincing? Is it ridiculous? Do you think I should just give up and go home? Again this is geared towards people who would otherwise support Sanders if not for electability, if you don't believe in Bernie's plans then maybe we could explore that another time.
Posted Mar 8, 2020, 9:44 PM UTC