aedes•

I think there are two main points mentioned there which I really haven't heard emphasized enough to date.

  1. The role of increased education, increased expectations, and disenfranchisement.

If you look at successful revolutions in the past, they have almost always formed around a core of individuals with higher education than average. Increase the average education of the population (as has been happening in Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt... etc.) and the concentration of educated individuals increases... potentially towards that critical point where the ideas of revolution can crystallize out of solution.

But only if enough people are dissatisfied. And education has a role in this as well. Pursuing a degree increases your expectations of what you should get out of life. And also teaches you how to get things out of life. Deprive these individuals this, once they have been shown it is possible, and they will be pissed off. Again, high unemployment and costs among other things in a lot of Middle East countries provided this foundation

  1. The role of the internet and instant, relatively limitless, electronic communication.

The printing press, the industrial revolution, electricity and the train/car, and now the internet/communications technology... all redefined what people expected out of their life, how they communicated, etc. And allowed people to circumvent traditional barriers to social and intellectual improvement which had been imposed on them by those who had held power prior to the revolutions associated with those inventions.

9
Robathome•

I agree with your points, and I add another:

The age disparity between the "bulging" younger demographic, and their representatives.

Even in Canada, this age gap is ridiculous. The politicians that have been guiding the economies, industries, educations systems and work forces for decades now have no experience with the technology or problems that today's young adults face. As a result, our governments are ill-prepared for the speed at which today's society can change direction.

In poorer nations, it is rare to see a politician who isn't considered upper-class. In the more developed nations, the stereotypical politician us almost ubiquitously middle-aged, perhaps even elderly, with little interpersonal connection to their electorate.

According to this article, the stereotypical leader of these protests is a youthful, inspired, and an amazing public speaker. The former may represent a "larger" vote, but the former is tenacious and inexperienced compared to the other, but is committed to reform and outspoken. I feel that today's politicians are too lethargic, too encumbered by the system, unmotivated and complacent to the status quo.

Most of these politicians are "grandfathered" in (for lack of a better term), and the status quo makes it difficult for young(-er) representatives to break in to the key positions required to institute reform. Furthermore, I'm sure the the ever-roiling disgust that today's youth harbors for politicians, lobbyists, and policy-makers would steer many away from a career in politics, which further exasperates the problem.

I feel that the solution is complicated and laborious. Since the birth of the Internet age, politics seems to benefit more and more from transparency. Since the "internet bubble" collapsed, there has been a steadily-growing gap between the technologies used by the public and the technologies used by the people. Today's youth can't even begin to comprehend how a politician doesn't know how to podcast, or blog, or even run a forum. Remember when Obama wanted to do a daily blog? Remember how unique and exciting that was?

My belief is that the youth, the technology, and the politics need to merged. Somehow. I'm tired of going to a government office and seeing a DOS interface on someone's screen. I'm tired of new curriculum taking years to propagate throughout the system. I'm tired of money being dumped into useless, eye-catching projects while our infrastructure collapses into disrepair. We need energy plans. We need better foreign policy (ie keeping our nose out of other people's business) and more focus in intra-national issues like homelessness and poverty.

Perhaps, similar to the "equal opportunity" laws that promoted diversity (racially, sexually, and physically), should also be in place in our government. From Wikipedia's "Affirmative Action" post:

The Canadian Employment Equity Act requires employers in federally-regulated industries to give preferential treatment to four designated groups: Women, people with disabilities, aboriginal people, and visible minorities.

The "preferential" treatment only goes so far as to say you must have a minimum (I think it's like 10%) of your board of directors must fall into one of those categories. Perhaps the same theory should apply to the House of Commons and Senate, and should be adjusted to oppose ageism. Normally, I'm a fence-sitter on affirmative action, sometimes it does more bad than good. However, a good government should always represent its people proportionately, and I feel that any policy that improves demographic comparison between a nation and it's government is always a good idea.

TL;DR: The old farts have to go. At least in Canada, anyways.

Now, in the hopes of promoting further discussion, what would the ramifications be for this policy? What would happen if Canada took a census and then forcefully adjusted the demographics of Parliament to be rigidly representative? Sure, you'd have some inexperienced and maybe undereducated people in higher positions than they might normally be, but aren't they more prone to groupthink without them? Isn't diversity and communication absolutely essential to the creative process?

All criticisms are welcome, just be nice about it.

8
[deleted]•

To put it into a simpler form, intellectuals as a class have always been dissatisfied that they don't get the power they think they would deserve, therefore they tend to have revolutionary leanings, trying to persuade the masses to topple those in power, with the hope that it would catapult themselves in the role of the new powerful, either visibly, as politicians (Roberspierre, Lenin, Obama etc. were/are all intellectuals), or invisibly, as advisors, influential intellectual leaders etc.

1
voilavoila•

The election of an African American man, Barack Obama as the 44th President of the United States of America.

Just 40 years after the murder of Martin Luther King.

I would argue the images from that cold January day in 2009 on the steps of the Lincoln memorial inspired more people than any technology or increase in education and banged the drum to the realisation that democracy is rightful and deserved by all humans.

1
Enginerd•

Therefore truth moves faster than lies, and propaganda becomes flammable.

If only this were true. Information moves a lot faster regardless of the source. It's pretty easy for the commoners to spread their own info to counter government info. But lies still spread, as EasyDNS can attest (re: wikileaks).

1
aeck•

A little off topic, but it's sad that "meme" has lost it's original meaning and been corrupted to mean "internet joke".

1