Dann-Oh•

Hopefully they have used this expansion to fix a lot of the issues with base game and the book of monsters expansions. Hopefully this expansion is not just more of the same as well. I'll be waiting a while before buying this expansion if I do but it.

26
EDaniels21•

Yeah, they really seem to have had some major consistency issues with the expansion that I hope they fix. I see they've got sleeves they're going to sell, but it's frustrating that the expansion has slightly different printing on the card backs...

6
rick707•

I agree 100%. The base game was very fun but the expansion didn't do much for me really. They need new game mechanics, a board expansion etc to keep it fresh. If its just new stuff to beat with a few new cards it will be boring.

5
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

From the description:

Continue to defend Hogwarts in Harry Potter: Hogwarts Battle – The Charms and Potions Expansion! This much anticipated second expansion to Hogwarts Battle increases the player count to five Heroes including the newest playable character, Ginny Weasley! Enhance your experience with Charm abilities to aid you as you battle new Villains and Encounter even more challenges. Trouble is brewing, only by working together will you be able to protect the Wizarding World from He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named.

14
Bughferd•

I really found this game terrible. We played through the base game and by the time you are on book 5 every game is a slog. Occasionally you might get a couple villians together who make the game difficult but for the most part the game is just long.

In additon the huge card pool made it so drafting any kind of synergy was nearly impossible. Instead you just drafted the best cards no matter if they were a spell, or what. Do the expansions fix these problems? This was the first board game I've ever wanted to sell as I cant imagine wanting to replay the base game.

12
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

Different strokes maybe? This game is the game that pushed my wife and I deeper into board games, beyond Catan/Ticket to Ride. Loved the concept, and while some games can be a slog, I've found it to be really fun with a group of 2-4. I disagree about synergy - the best we have done is when each person plays their roll.

The expansion gives you a free play rule where you do 12 villians randomly, with some exceptions such as specific ones based on encounter cards and always Voldemort.

18
Brodogmillionaire1•

I don't know. I have to agree that it's a poor design.

In a field of excellent deckbuilders and games which use their IPs exceptionally well, it was frustrating to play as both a longtime Harry Potter fan and a fan of the mechanic. It felt like they learned nothing from all of the innovations which have come since Dominion (and didn't even learn from Dominion). You can't trash cards, so your deck gets bloated. You can't do anything to move along the offer organically without buying cards nobody wants. The game arc is inconsistent at best and at worst consistently fell into a rut. The cards themselves rarely felt thematic to me - Hero Realms, which is an even lighter game than this, does a much better job at translating its theme on each card. I was using every flavored beans while fighting dementors and couldn't wrap my head around the thematic gymnastics. The HP videogames managed to keep anything like that from getting too bizarre despite beans also being significant. I get that the game is about a battle at Hogwarts, but why am I snatching up fizzing whizbees while the school is getting attacked by Malfoy and Voldemort? This confluence is about as well thought out as an Entertainment Weekly article explaining the main characters to its readers after the writer checked a brief plot synopsis and watched the trailer. The addition of the die didn't really add anything and felt incidental - the whole draw of the deckbuilding mechanic is streamlined input randomness, so adding output randomness was an odd choice. The very simple resource economy was fine, and not all that different from stuff like the realms games, but I still found it even simpler than it needed to be. Quest for El Dorado is just as easy to learn and yet does much more with a simple symbol economy. The structure of combating the villains was also a little dry and unthematic. I liked the pressure it put on the players, but it rarely made for an interesting decision space even given that it's a light game. And possibly the oddest choice of all - major villains can come back in books in which they don't appear, but you don't save your deck between books! I've heard some of the thematic arguments for both of these, and I'm still dissatisfied. One of the great advantages you have with this IP is easily molding the deck management to fit Harry's journey. They failed to really leverage that mechanically. It is an overall lazy design taking the most basic and (possibly) underdeveloped approach to deckbuilding as well as a lazy approach to the IP. Even the choice of film stills was disappointing, after playing with the fun art on the old CCG and the old board games.

With the recent appearance of such excellent light licensed games (e.g. Villainous, Jaws, Jurassic Park), it's a shame that this one missed the mark. It works fine as a gateway game, and nothing against anyone who gets something out of it. But I think there's a ton of room for improvement.

12
CustomerSentaraiArkham Horror•

It’s co op, that’s a huge plus to some.

1
Brodogmillionaire1•

There are plenty of great co-op deckbuilders, some of which are just as accessible. And plenty of great co-ops in general. I think what draws people to this one is the IP.

1
foreigneternityDescent 1E Forever!•

You're absolutely right. Whether or not this game pulled people into board gaming, it's total crap.

-7
BadBoar•

I know, I’m reading the comments wondering if my wife and I are the only ones that love this game and it’s current expansion. We’ve played this game dozens on dozens of times since it came out. Always a go-to

11
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

You aren't! I can't count how many times we have played it, with many different groups!

7
Othis•

My wife and I love it too, but it can definitely be a slog and we’ve had a couple of games where a bad initial villain draw has made the game near-impossible. It’s our most house-ruled game by far.

6
hermyx•

It's so nice to read nice comments too :) I love this game, especially with some home made rule to perfect it :)

2
Canadageo4•

One of my favorite games! Many many hours have been spent playing it.

1
FlamezOfGamez•

The expansion does not really fix this. The card pool is even bigger, but it provides scenarios that are shorter where you only go up against a certain number of Villains and Creatures, and 3 challenges similar to the Game 7 Horocruxes. There’s still massive variability in that opening set of Villains/Creatures, where you can get slaughtered by Bellatrix-Fenrir-Dementor or have a total cakewalk while you build up your deck against Crabbe & Goyle-Death Eater-Death Eater.

Speaking of Death Eaters, I swear those are half of what ruin the game. They’re easily the least threatening villains, and any time one comes out I leave it out all the way until Voldemort. A fight against every single Villain and Creature is probably easier than a fight against everyone except the two Death Eaters.

9
Bughferd•

Yeah our games would at some point devolve to us just sitting on a death eater or two as we build our decks and then slowly killing every other villain one by one over 45 minutes. My partner and I really enjoy co op games and deck builders but we found this game lacking. We recently bought Aoens End though and found it to be a much better experience.

5
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

You could always...kill the Death Eaters then? You don't HAVE to leave them around. We kill em when we need to clear a skull.

-5
FlamezOfGamez•

I get what you mean, but if I do that then I’m actively working against my own interests as my goal is to win the game. The game shouldn’t put me in this position where the game is more engaging if I intentionally play against my own interests, I much would have preferred if the whole engine just worked in the first place, an engine which isn’t exactly easily fixable despite some of the minor tweaks some people have suggested.

9
Notfaye•

The mechanics it does well are the learning games, Ramping complexity, and neat unlocked campaign boxes. They do that better than any deck building game on the market.

The game itself though is a solid C-.

3
RadicalDogMillennium Encounter•

I put together a pretty substantial variant to address this kind of nonsense. A big problem is that you can basically indefinitely postpone the game's "timer", progressing through locations, so it dramatically cuts the options for that. With this we usually hit the final location before the end of the villain deck, so it can be tense whether we win or lose.

2
Kempeth•

GF and I also found that the game has only two settings. Impossibly hard and piece of cake. We always played Neville going for heals plus Hermione focusing on card draws which worked well and felt like something of a strategy.

1
gamergump•

Can I be excited for the official card sleves? One pack for $16 to core game and both expansions. I wish more games offered these at a great price.

9
Sanslos•

I guess they kinda had to make this product happen given how bad they matched the printing and cutting between the core game and expansion. So yeah, I'm gonna buy them. :)

6
bestmarty•

It says you're going to need 2 packs at $16 a piece.

The base set has 142 hogwarts cards and the first expansion has 68. Since each sleeve pack comes with 160 cards you'll need 2 but that should be enough for all the hogwarts cards.

3
Giggles122•

My fiancée and I love this game and really thought it was done so this is great news. Hopefully they put out a big box to store it all at some point.

The boxes are oddly shaped and tricky to fit in a Kallax without dead space.

8
HackWeightBadger•

It already easily fits in the base game box, so I'm a bit confused by this comment. You don't need to keep the game boxes since everything already has dividers then you have that whole big center section for more stuff.

2
Giggles122•

I meant I don't think this expansion will fit in the base box anymore. So I'd like a bigger box to store those. And room for the duel version would be nice too.

2
Dice_and_DragonsDescent•

Looking forward to this hopefully they have some rules to solve the issue of the gigantic Hogwarts deck!

7
cheepsheepSaboteur•

Well, that's nice that they are releasing official sleeves, but what about for those oddly sized cards?

5
bestmarty•

Im guessing that since those dont need to get shuffled as much you shouldn't need custom sleeves for them.

2
cheepsheepSaboteur•

True, but that doesn't satiate a sleever like myself XD

1
Yamanikan•

Which card back will it match? Or a new third option?

4
Bohrdumb•

Wonderful news. My wife and I have little to no trouble doing the Epic scenario as it is, so new challenges will be greatly appreciated. Also the 5th player will be nice when family visits.

3
FordEngineerman•

The game is a lot harder with more players. 2 player should generally be pretty easy. 4-player is quite a challenge. 5 might be insane.

2
Bohrdumb•

We have played with 5 several times. It can be hard. We sometimes hand out Hogwarts A History to everyone. But there's probably a better choice like Reparo or Tergeo.

1
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

Same here! We've done Epic twice, usually takes a while. Did it once where we had Voldemort come out each quarter of the deck randomly, that was a fun variant on it. Epic mode once you hit a certain strength is almost impossible to lose though, you become over powered.

1
Bohrdumb•

Did it once where we had Voldemort come out each quarter of the deck randomly, that was a fun variant on it.

Did you handle him like a normal villain at that point?

1
21DayHelpOPGloomhaven•

No, he would be face up so when a third villain flipped, he would be seen and you'd have to kill all three then attack him, at which point he would "retreat" and three new villains would come out. Kept playing through with him showing up and making it 4 on 1 four different times. We also played two heros each rather than each of us having one hero.

1
Broseppy•

As a Potter fan, I've come close to pulling the trigger on the base game, but ultimately the art has kept me away. I really wish original art was used for this. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy the movies for the most part, but I wish there wasn't so much Harry Potter stuff that just pulled from the movies. It seems lazy and doesn't look as good as original art.

3
LoccloTotally Not an Unrevealed Cylon•

I'd like to say the gameplay makes up for the art, but...eh. It's neat, but it's a very simple deckbuilding game. For some reason (possibly to keep it marketable towards non-gamers) it lacks mechanics like trashing that even the original deckbuilder, Dominion, had. Most games just leave you with a massive deck and hoping for the best every turn, which isn't all that fun.

3
darkflikk•

That's so true.
The art is absolutely terrible and lazy.
Using a similar artwork to what is on the book covers would have been so much better.

I thought about getting it because it seems to be so well received.
But when i look at it i have doubts that i would really enjoy it as much as everyone else says they do.

1
demonpiggiesLords Of Waterdeep•

I'm guessing you haven't played a non-Marvel Legendary game. The art in HP is just stills from the movie and in their defense there isn't enough HP art to do all the cards. At least the spell cards have the actual wand movements they used in the movie.

2
darkflikk•

No i haven't played and legendary game.
But i see they do the same.

I know a artist costs money.
But those images that are cut from movies are the worst i think.

This is something that would keep me from buying a game even when the gameplay is good

1
demonpiggiesLords Of Waterdeep•

I mean the art is the worst I've ever encountered. Look up Legendary Firefly. The did not even license the comic art so the art is someone, I think, painting over stills but with colored pencils... It's awful. I'm personally fine with movie stills but not totally OK with bad artwork.

1
Kempeth•

Meanwhile I'd probably be disappointed if they had not used the movie assets as I've never read the books.

-1
yggdrasilsYeoman•

Finally. FINALLY. Lavender Brown. The game was literally unplayable before now.

2
pandajedi•

Curious to learn more! Hogwarts Battle has been gathering dust on the shelf, but I'll always keep it in my collection because of the fond memories I have for it. It's certainly flawed in a lot of ways, but it's still an excellent gateway game- highly approachable IP, simple take on the Deck Building genre that ramps up complexity through a campaign, etc. It's the game that taught me I can play a game for a campaign and then be kind of done with it and not have to play it over and over again to get my money's worth, and that opened the door to a lot of great experiences

2
graffanino•

I’m so glad I found this subreddit. This is awesome news! My kids LOVE this game!

2
QggOne•

Nice!

We've got through the first 6 books on the original game and haven't yet tried the sequel.

Hopefully this expansion doesn't have extremely long games.

1
Kempeth•

Yay for sleeves! Because the card quality is shyte. You know how afte every game you need to sort out the basic cards of each player's deck? Yeah, after the third game or so you can do that on the reverse based on the chafing of the card edges...

GF and I finished the campaign yesterday. Fun enough game. Huge range of difficulty based on what combo of villains comes up when. Glad we got to rent it from the toy library and didn't have to buy it.

1
GuillermoRubio•

Hands down my favorite game. I and soo excited and relieved to hear it’s getting an expansion! I’m so glad that my something I’ve been longing for is finally happening this year.

1
underscoredoh•

Cool, terf shit

0
Thewiseguy14•

Do people like this game? What makes it different from all the other mini combat games?

-5
wildestnacatl•

It isn’t a mini combat game.

5