Is XFX Thicc III Ultra and Gigabyte Aorus 5700 XT competitive cards againts Sapphire Nitro+ and Red Devil

As the title says.

Haven't seen many reviews of XFX and Gigabytes cards because they came late compared to other cards. So far I've seen Guru 3d's reviews of these both cards and what comes to thermals and noise, they both seem to be pretty good. I am asking this because Thicc III card is 40-50€ cheaper than the others and Aorus is just new. Thanks for advance