How do you activate tokens in root?

Just picked this game up but the instructions are unclear - since you activate tokens do you flip them? tap them? remove them?

Thanks

EDIT: Thanks for the responses

Posted Mar 13, 2020, 12:34 PM UTC · edited

620
wallysmith127Pax Renaissance•

House rule: point at the token you're activating and say "I ACTIVATE THAT ONE"

You really internalize the rule after doing that a couple times

9
MaddenMan73OP•

lol ok thx

1
MrGurbic•

Just remember. You only ever use a few.

7
Brodogmillionaire1•

You want to think of your crafting pieces as generating a pool of crafting at the beginning of every one of your turns. You then have that pool as points of a resource to spend. So, if I am the Marquise, and I have a workshop in a fox clearing and 1 workshop each in two bunny clearings, I have 1 fox craft point and 2 bunny craft points when my turn starts. I can then spend as many of those points crafting as I want when crafting is allowed on my turn.

Does that make sense? You don't actually, physically activate anything. I think the terms are misnomers and that the rule is poorly conveyed. I wish that they'd called it something other than "crafting" as for every player I teach to, they either assume you need to spend something, or they are just completely lost. Crafting just means playing a card. It's how you play cards that aren't Ambush or Dominance cards. The End.

7
MaddenMan73OP•

Thanks for the breakdown!

2
eggson•

This question just occurred to me: say I have tokens in three clearings, 1, mouse, 1 bunny and 1 fox, that would allow me to craft. And then I have two cards that I can craft, one that requires Mouse + Bunny, and one that requires Mouse + Fox. Could I craft both cards at the same time, using just the three clearings? In other words, can I re-use the Mouse clearing during the same craft phase?

2
RexLongbone•

No.

3
Brodogmillionaire1•

Good question. No. Otherwise, it would be said that you have a crafting threshold, like elements used for innate powers in Spirit Island. Instead, you generate 1 bunny crafting point, 1 mouse, and 1 fox to use on your turn. As if you get them as resource income and must spend them on that turn lest they go away unspent. You can never spend a resource twice, and you can never spend the same crafting point twice in a turn. If it helps, you may want to use colored cubes to remember.

2
eggson•

Thanks for the clarification; this has never come up in our games, but I'm pretty sure if it did I'd be able to reference the rules to clarify, I just don't have them in front of me right now.

It's also never been a problem keeping track of what clearing token a player has used in any given turn, but you never know.

2
Brodogmillionaire1•

The rule is simple enough that only one major edge case ever comes up. I just don't think the rules are good at conveying the nature of the mechanism. But that's mostly on the terminology. That said, the new Law of Root is updated and much better.

Right, because you never have that many crafting pieces or cards to craft in a given turn anyway.

1
mimhoff_•

ooh, how about using the clearing markers to keep track of what's in your crafting pool?

Assuming you don't need them to mark clearings.

1
Brodogmillionaire1•

Great idea! Good for learning games.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
asmallercat•

Since crafting is a single action for every faction (except vagabond, and flipping hammers makes it abundantly clear), just count your tokens, figure out what you can/want to craft, and craft it all at once. Once the craft phase is done, it doesn't matter if tokens are activated anymore.

2
MaddenMan73OP•

Ok cool thanks - I didn't know if the expansion let you craft more that one item per turn?

1
asmallercat•

Every faction can craft more than one item a turn assuming they can meet the requirements for everything and have enough tokens to activate - I just meant that it's one phase in a turn so you can do everything at once without needing to later track which tokens were activated.

2
GodotIsWaiting4UDune•

You can craft as much as you can afford. This will often be one, but not always.

2
WeAreScientists•

Usually, crafting in games is associated with spending a resource back to a token pool. You usually lose the thing you're required to use/spend.

With Root, "crafting" doesn't involve losing any of your resources - instead, you tap the resource your faction requires for crafting to do the special effect on the card you're trying to use (or "craft").

2
sunny_6killerKeyflower•

This is the most janky rule in this game. If you want to be litigious about it, you could grab a set of small cubes or something similar and place them on it as people are crafting and then remove them at the end of their crafting phase. I am usually just very careful when new players get to their crafting phase and try to help everyone through it because it's not initially clear on how you activate things so it has been the most confusing part of the teach for me.

I understand it was probably clunky to have people flipping for crafting and then flipping back, but some kind of visual indicator would help.

2
gnarwhale471Concordia•

I have a separate question about this. I know the crafting requirements are listed in the bottom left of a card, but do you also have to be ruling a clearing that matches the suit of the card?

1
[deleted]•

I don’t believe so the rules say flip an appropriate token you haven in a matching clearing

1