r/banjo•
UtMed

Really don't like finger picks...

Hey all, just starting my banjo trip. Really not liking finger picks. Would I miss out on much if I just played without? Any styles or sounds essential to the banjo I'd lose access to?

Posted Mar 14, 2020, 11:17 PM UTC

15
foundartguitars•

You may find difficulties producing clear crisp sounds. The pad of the finger naturally muted the string a little bit. That being said you could go the classical guitarist route and just grow out your nails if you want.

However I have never heard a single person say “I loved my finger picks the moment I put them on.” I’ve heard probably about a thousand say “you just gotta get used to them.”

Or you could play claw hammer and not worry about it lol.

7
UtMedOP•

I figured it was probably like that. And I will probably get some claw hammer songs down. Quite enjoyable. But my job means no long fingernails.

2
BanjosAndBoredomScruggs Style•

You won't get a bluegrass sound without finger picks, that's just how it is. If you don't care about that, you do you. It takes a while to get used to them, but you need them if you want to play bluegrass. Maybe try old-time if that's really a major issue.

4
Renzeon•

Not only do I hate fingerpicks, but I also hate being dependent on them to play my instrument. After trying all different kinds, I finally decided that I just wasn't interested in playing bluegrass or any other style that really required them. I don't usually grow my finger nails out, but I've still learned to get a pretty good sound out of my banjo despite all that.

But I still recognize that there's an advantage to learning to play with fingerpicks, and you do yourself a disservice by avoiding them.

At the end of the day, just play the way that brings you joy. There aren't any real rules anyway.

3
Powbob•

Play clawhammer.

2