@ElonMusk @Tesla How not to miss out on the Dutch EV rebate

Feature Request

In the Netherlands, as of 1 July there will be a 4k rebate for EVs for regular people (in contrast to BIK which is not available to them). To be eligible for the rebate, the maximum price of the EV is E45, which is lower than the SR plus.

AFAIK, in Canada Tesla has faced a similar situation, and Tesla sold EVs with a restricted range which could be unlocked with a post-purchase fee.

This approach could be used in the Netherlands. To make the SR+ BASIC offer more enticing, the limited range (e.g. 175 or 200 km) could be a guaranteed range (at a max speed of 105 km/h), that is irrespective of the temperature. Thus, people driving this locked down version would not have to suffer from range anxiety (even if only doing highway driving or in cold), unlike other eligible EVs which while having longer advertised ranges, wouldn't be able to meet them by far because they are WLTP ranges. The underused capacity of the Model 3 battery would guarantee this range. This would be a unique selling point, apart from the fact that you can upgrade the car later on to get an even longer range whereas with the competition you're stuck with the (WLTIP) range you buy.

ADDED: The range could be advertised as still guaranteed in 10 years (meeting the worry some people have about battery degradation). This would make the BASIC version more competitive with EVs from other brands.

To make the upgrade package to regular SR+ more enticing, the BASIC version could have the following limitations:

​

- the top speed could be reduced to 140 km/h (enough safety margin if one has to overtake another car).

- The 0-60 could be 2.5 seconds slower (so still relatively speedy as the BASIC version still has to be competitive if not upgraded).

- Pay 50% more at the supercharger (still cheaper than Ionity, a leading company for roadside charging).

Posted Mar 15, 2020, 3:10 PM UTC · edited

320
The1TwoThree•

False. In Canada the cheap base version’s range cannot be uncapped after purchase. The government refused to accept this type of fraud.

12
ReddBertOP•

I’m sorry for not representing the Canadian situation totally correct, but I don’t think it takes away much from the point. It is not uncommon that the battery has more capacity than the manufacturer advertises with because of reasons.

The idea is that the BASIC version would be a decent and perfectly useable car that would not be crippled to such an extent that it wouldn’t be able run its life to the satisfaction of an owner without the upgrade. I think the guaranteed range makes that so. It could even take any battery degradation into account, another issue people may be wary about.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
thisisreadonly:I:/ :O:•

Your example of Canada is not applicable as the incentive is structured differently and the Canadian compliance trim cars cannot be unlocked. The point was never to sell the compliance trim, it was to make the higher SR+ trim eligible for the incentive.

Here’s how this works: in Canada, the federal incentive is available for cars priced blow CAD 45k, or just below what the SR+ costs. However, there is a loophole: if there is a base trim of the same car that sells for less than CAD 45k, then the incentive is available for other trims that sell at up to CAD 55k. So, in order for SR+ to qualify for the incentive, Tesla made a software locked compliance trim that is sold for CAD 44.5k. They intentionally made the range very low, just 150km, so that they don’t end up selling many of these (I remember reading that a Toronto showroom sold one since it was launched). The Canadian government allows them to get around the restrictions in this manner, but it requires that the compliance trim cannot be unlocked post-purchase.

More details: https://electrek.co/2019/05/02/tesla-model-3-range-upgrade-canada/

7
ReddBertOP•

There is a difference then indeed, as the idea here is to sell many of them. The BASIC model would have two selling points of its own (no battery degradation and a guaranteed range irrespective of the outside temperature), meeting two worries that EV buyers may have. And yes, the option is there to upgrade it but the objective of the BASIC offer is that it is a decent and attractive car all by itself.

ADDED: Such a BASIC version could also be offered in other countries, as it could be compelling there as well. This would also help to eliminate the fraud accusation, which I don’t think is warranted here anyway because the circumstances are so much different (not a compliance car).

0
thisisreadonly:I:/ :O:•

Based on Tesla’s strategy so far, the SR+ is the lowest trim that they can sustain positive margins on right now. Anything cheaper would require finding a way to reduce costs without increasing manufacturing complexity. They’ve already decontended 2020 cars to pad the margins, not sure how much else they’d be able to do without a cheaper battery.

2
ReddBertOP•

There are no hardware differences, just software, so logistics are not really different. Tesla would be able to sell vehicles which sales would otherwise go to the competition.

By way of example, if 50% opt for the upgrade (making the car suitable for holidays and for full day trips without roadside charging), that would reduce the average selling price by 2k. By the way, the rebate happens to be equal to 4K which the SR+ would need to be cheaper, so basically they would get the SR+ with rebate even though it currently doesn’t qualify. So, the percentage could be higher, but any percentage is speculation at this point.

As an aside, the resale value would also go up, more so than in case of the recent acceleration upgrade, where the buyer of such an accelerated car might well not be interested in that feature as Tesla’s are already quite zippy. But everybody likes range.

2
thisisreadonly:I:/ :O:•

I get the idea, but you’re basing the whole thing on the speculation that the increased sales would cover for decreased margins. This is, of course, completely contingent on there being a positive margin in the first place, and we simply don’t have the numbers to support or refute the idea that that’s possible.

2
cryptoanarchy:I: Investor•

Close. Tesla is the one not wanting to unlock the cars. There is no law stating as such. Tesla does not want to sell a car for $44k, so they make it available, but discourage its purchase.

0
thisisreadonly:I:/ :O:•

Tesla’s statement directly quotes no unlocks as an eligibility criterion:

“In order to be eligible for the incentive in Canada and provide our customers with this benefit, we are unable to offer a range upgrade on Model 3 Standard Range cars.”

And the terms of the incentive contain the following line:

“Eligibility, including the continuation of eligibility, remains at the Minister of Transport's discretion.”

So I’d say it’s pretty clear that the government told them they can’t game the incentive by shifting a large chunk of the price to post-purchase.

2
jpbeansModel :3: LR RWD, Model :y: AWD•

This seems like the sort of lower-margin business a company would pursue if they were having problems finding other more profitable customers.

1
HenryLoenwind•

Probably easier to sell cars without rear seats.

(only half joking...)

1
M3FanOZ:m_sans::o_sans::d_sans::e_sans::l_sans: :3:•

Tesla just has to work to reduce the price of the cars when they can.

At least in the US I'm hoping they can get the regular SR back on the menu, and perhaps in Europe an SR or even SR- down the track.

That might be software locking the pack, or perhaps using fewer cells in the pack.

They may be able to find other areas of savings, for example finding lower cost part, or making lower cost seats.

Finding savings is hard, it is a slow on-going process.

Of course software locking features which can be unlocked later is easier, but you can never insist that the customer upgrades and the government rules may prevent that.

I don't think that they can go beyond software locking just for the Netherlands, but cost savings and a genuine option for a lower priced car would be great in all markets..

Perhaps they can use a mix of the 2 approaches.

1
vommavanna•

this is just a convoluted way to commit tax fraud. If you can pay for a >45k car you don't need a government handout. Rot op.

0
ReddBertOP•

Whereas if you can pay 44 you do. It is that simple.

1
vommavanna•

you don't either but at least ur not committing obvious fraud

1
ReddBertOP•

I most certainly can’t afford a Tesla. I drive a 2012 car for years to come. But the rebate arrangement has been designed to not benefit Tesla, and I don’t think that is fair because the EV landscape would be much different if they didn’t put the bar so high. They are pushing the envelope, not the traditional car makers. With respect to combatting climate change caused by traffic, we (will) one Tesla a lot.

1
vommavanna•

well i guess a bunch of dead factory workers from the coronavirus will be good for climate change. Thanks Elon!

1