[Discussion] Question about quarantine policies
Preface: This isn't a question with a hidden political motive. This isn't a dig at the CDC. Frankly, I don't even believe in the premise of this question, it's something a friend brought up, and I kind of want to see what professionals think about the underlying assumptions.
Since the elderly are most at risk, why don't we implement draconian quarantine (i'm talking, get the national guard involved) for those over 60 and let the rest of the public continue working/gathering. What are the major impediments to doing something like this?
How viable are strong quarantines just on the elderly? Do epidemiological models exist for that kind of thing? Given the highly variable housing density of elderly (nursing homes, assisted living, rent-controlled apartments, etc) what do infection rates look like for the current models, and how much can these be modified by quarantine? Is it possible through use of strong govt measures to get this number down to near zero for this subgroup?
Some background motivation: The government shutting down businesses will have an impact on the US economy that could cause a lot of harm. The stock market isn't the economy, I know that, but shutting down bars and restaurants is real. It hits working class people's paychecks. A lot of retail worker Americans are paycheck to paycheck families. Eviction and bankruptcy is a cycle that keeps people in grinding poverty, and lots of Americans are on a razor thin edge of falling in. I know there are numbers out there that x% gdp drop results in y# of deaths of despair (I don't know them exactly, but they exist).
Thanks for taking the time to read and answer.
Posted Mar 17, 2020, 8:56 AM UTC