Help trimming 10 cards for Klothys 'Loam Assault' deck.
I'm not much of a Green player, so I tried to challenge myself and look at commanders with that color in them, and [[Klothys]] caught my eye since I like BR. Most people were building her slug, which again piqued my interest because I was looking for a midrange, but I also ran into people playing [[Tectonic Reformation]] and what I would later find out is a "Loam Assault" package; things like [[Borborygmos Enraged]], [[Seismic Assault]], [[Life from the Loam]], [[Wrenn and Six]], [[Creeping Rennaisance]]...
Power Level terms...I was confident in the terms and now I am not, so I'll state what decks are in my group: Player A has Windgrace Lands and Kozilek Artifacts, Player B has Bantchantress Gods, Player C has Nicol Bolas Supervillains/Tribal/Zombies, Player D has Aurelia Angels, and Player E has Olivia Vampires/Goodstuff. Several players want more decks, and Player E has been looking at refining their deck to better compete with Player A. Some players are new, or just back into the game, so they find infinites a bit salty. If I had to guess power levels, in our group it ranges from 4-7, with the 4 (E) tuning up to a 5 or 6, and the 7 (A) recently added tutors, which might've made them closer to 7.5, so I'd like to sit somewhere in the 6-7 'focused' range, since it has a clear goal, some redundancy and consistency, and the wincon seems 'fair'.
Also try not to mind the massive Maybeboard; I'd had a pile of ~250 cards ranging from slug, ramp, tokens, etc, then back up again after finding out that 'loam assault' is a deck and what they run, and just now got it to 110 after removing the [[Impact Tremors]] package for the bears from [[Ayula's Influence]], and wasn't sure it'd be worth it alone. Sideboard are my strong considerations to put back in.
Posted Mar 17, 2020, 6:14 PM UTC
I tried Tectonic Reformation out in my Windgrace deck and it felt pretty underwhelming. I'd cut aggressive mining as well. I tried it out a few times but it can put you into really tough situations also.
Brawn, Krosan Tusker, and Shefnet Monitor all seem like you could be running something better in those slots. Terastodon also seems like it's a little bit out of left field in this deck, even if it is a good card in general.
I've always found [[Elixir of Immortality]] a bit underwhelming as it's really card disadvantage for 5 life. Shuffling in is rarely relevant. I'd consider cutting Leyline of Combustion as well, as 2 damage is really not that much, but I haven't played with it personally. I'd replace it with [[Heroic Intervention]] or [[Veil of Summer]].
Cavalier of Thorns has been a huge overperformer for me in every deck I've run it in. Highly recommend considering it. [[Titania]] seems great here as well, she's a bit expensive but your budget seems decent so I figured I'd suggest her.
Actually, My Windgrace deck used to be an Assault / Borb deck but I've changed it up a bit, but there's still a ton of overlap IMO. I'll link my deck here. Other recommendations are [[Nissa, Vastwood Seer]] and [[Greater Good]].
There's [[Land's Edge]] and [[Lightning Storm]] as well if you find yourself wanting more of your discard effects, otherwise you could just run [[Regrowth]] and [[Noxious Revival]] to get them back when they're blown up.
#####
######
####
Elixir of Immortality - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Heroic Intervention - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Veil of Summer - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Titania - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Nissa, Vastwood Seer/Nissa, Sage Animist - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Greater Good - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Land's Edge - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Lightning Storm - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Regrowth - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Noxious Revival - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
Tectonic Reformation was to help dig through land sections if I didnt have a key piece yet, or instant draw if loam was going to be targeted, but I agree with aggressive mining, it was a "win more" to play the turn before I go off for 8 draws and 4 lands in the yard. I'd had Zuran Orb in for that effect but maybe neither are needed.
Krosan Tusker and Shefnet Monitor were leftovers from the cycling package, so that's understandable to remove. Brawn does help a couple big creatures, but removing Tusker and Monitor does drop that number to a cuttable amount.
Elixir does seem ham fisted. I have to reshuffle in my whole yard, and sure it's repeatable, but there's not a ton of grave hate, and I do it myself sometimes. I'll look at the options given if I need the spot filled.
Cavalier was in initially, so this a bit funny. I'll check the wording on how close it is to a Mulch, but exiling on death for a bonus means I can't Genesis back. Titania is better for saclands and such though, and as few as possible of mine hit the table.
I appreciate the link and recommendations, and I'll check them out.
Keep in mind Cavalier of Thorns' death trigger is a "may" ability, so you don't have to do it if you want to get it back with Genesis.
Part of me suggesting Titania was if you bring in Zuran Orb and Greater Good that Titania works really well with both of those. Both the G and R cavaliers also work really well with GG. I'd suggest [[Squandered Resources]] but you're not in Black.
Also I forgot to mention him but [[Tireless Tracker]] has also almost always been solid for me.
I updated the list, and that was enough of a push to get 5 more cards out, so I have the 100 if you want to check out the changes. It goldfishes okay, I might add back in dredge or more wheels so I can dig for the goodies faster.
Looks solid! I like dredge and wheel cards as well, but you can always tune as you play as well.
The only couple of cards I'm not sure on are Squee (unless there's a combo I'm missing with him), the Leyline, and I've tried Countryside Crusher to pretty underwhelming results.
Have you considered including Purphoros for reduncancy with Impact Tremors? Not sure how hard you want to go down that line but in my experience a deck probably wants to run either both or neither of those two.
You mentioned the group being around 4-7 so overall I'd say really you could probably build it as-is and tune it from there. I'd also keep my eye on Centaur Vinecrasher, and you could consider swapping Path of Discovery for [[Guardian Project]]. PoD working with tokens is a definite upside, though. You could also run both.
Squandered Resources - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Tireless Tracker - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call
That's very fair. Plus the big body with reach is always welcome.
Greater Good was an idea at first. Then I had so many 1/1 tokens for Impact Tremors it was almost useless, but I'll look at my average power and how many draw sources I end up with. Titania sounds like she'd need the whole package though, and the idea is to cull. I get it, I hit the adding stage a couple times.
Tireless Tracker is tempting for me, but mainly with Zuran/Mining.