r/youtubers•
Dog_Bit

[Review Video] Playing an existential horror game -- Start survey

Review Video

Hello Hello, I'm a small time gaming youtuber looking for any and all who game or like watching gaming videos to let me know if at any point during this video it started to drag on. Did the action take too long to get to, and was it worth the payoff? What did you think about the ending of the game. I ask because I wasn't sure if I was even going to edit this one but decided to give it a chance.

self review: I think my commentary has gotten a lot better over the years but I wonder if just editing this video was a bad call, if the raw footage is good or not. I really like how I added in music to extenuate certain moments but wonder If I could have done more. I think I did good but not great.

Video Link: https://youtu.be/vtzcSOdWqZY

Review 1

Review 2

Posted Mar 17, 2020, 6:46 PM UTC

310
SaucySenseiYT•

As a gaming YouTuber, your job is to make the video funny, no matter how shitty the game is (not saying this was a bad game.)

It's sad but the fact is that you need to innovate and do your own thing as a small gamer to get people interested.

Without a facecam means, you need to go all out on editing with memes, green screens, and audio but not overdoing it.

The video got great commentary, nice lil edits. But it's all about short videos so cut the footage down quite a bit. (if I made a video on this game then the video length would be about 3mins.)

​

Again... because we don't have large audiences. You can only play new games, and by new I mean NEW. The game is considered "old" for us small YouTubers if it's 3 days old. You gotta be the first to make a video and post it on the game's page so when people search for it... You'll get the headlines.

​

This game you played... *everybody* played it. When they search for it, your video would be at the bottom of the list and your effort would be wasted.

​

It's a harsh reality. It doesn't matter if the video is good... if you ain't the first then just leave it.

2
Dog_BitOPEpic Gamer•

Uhhh thank you for that viewpoint. I'll try to keep that in mind.

2
BreadZeppelinYT•

I really enjoyed this video, the game was strange but your commentary kept it engaging and the lil edits were a nice touch! You have a great voice for commentary which helps you stand out against other youtubers, you sound like a radio show host and that is dope.

The fact that you have a name for your audience is really good especially since it is a clever one that relates to your channel name!

I personally would have done more edits just because these days people prefer "quality" over quantity?

Not that this video isn't quality it's just that people love stuff that has a lot of edits these days. At least I think!

Great video overall!

Keep up the great work!

2
Dog_BitOPEpic Gamer•

I really appreciate the feedback. Thanks and good luck out there!

1
RazorINCMODThe 'Simon Cowell' of the Mods [mod]•

A target audience must be specified in [Review Video] threads when asking subjective questions. A subjective question is one where there's no right or wrong answer, just a matter of personal taste. Subjective questions like "Am I funny?" will always get contradictory answers: Some will say 'yes' and some will say 'no'. To attract an audience you need to appeal to a certain kind of viewer who has a certain kind of interest. This is a target audience.

See the example of a well written review request.

1
Dog_BitOPEpic Gamer•

"Hello Hello, I'm a small time gaming youtuber looking for any and all who game or like watching gaming videos to let me know if at any point during this video it started to drag on. Did the action take too long to get to, and was it worth the payoff? What did you think about the ending of the game."

I've identified my audience as people who game or those who like watching gaming videos

I asked if at any point during the video it started to drag on, if they thought the action took too long to get too, and what they thought about the ending.

I do not understand why my post was removed

1
RazorINCThe 'Simon Cowell' of the Mods [mod]•

You're correct, I overlooked it. The post has been restored.

2
Dog_BitOPEpic Gamer•

Thank you for the quick reply.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
TheTrueTeknoOdin•

Okay good video but two things I feel you can definitely improve upon

1st is energy.. might be just that video maybeyou didn't know if the game was scary or not but if felt like you were holding back incase there was someone you either could have woken up or disturbed (trust me I do it too on occasions) , loosen up and be more expressive try some vocal exercises like they do In drama classes

2nd is let the atmosphere build a few moments you are talking more than you actually need to(another common trait early on and another I get caught out on alot) I know it's like the feeling of not saying something will audience engagement but alot of the time less is more

1