My best work yet, I think. Feedback wanted!

Video Critique | 12:08 | :youtube: Dogbit

Posted Mar 21, 2020, 7:47 PM UTC

17
SmallYTChannelBotMOD[🏆 ∞λ] 🤖•

Thank you for submitting to r/SmallYTChannel. You have spent 3λ to submit here, making your current balance 0λ. u/Dog_Bit, please comment !givelambda to the most helpful advice you are given. You will be rewarded 1λ if you do so. For more information, read the FAQ.

##Video data:

FieldData
TitleVOICE ACTORS PLAY VR CHAT! (VRCHAT FUNNY MOMENTS #5)
ThumbnailLink
Views30
Length12:08
Likes/Dislikes5/0
Comments6
DescriptionTWITTER : https://twitter.com/Dogbit3⤶DISCORD: https://discord.gg/qgNUSXY⤶REDDIT : https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogbit/⤶⤶Well this was such a fun video to make. I had a great time running around VRchat and met some super cool people along the way. I cannot believe how good these voice actors are in this game, honestly. The Glados and Gman voice were awesome. #gaming #VRchat #funny

##Channel Data:

FieldData
NameDogbit
ThumbnailLink
Subscribers321
Videos55
Views26932

^/u/SmallYTChannelBot ^made ^by ^/u/jwnskanzkwk. ^PM ^for ^bug ^reports. ^For ^more ^information, ^read ^the ^FAQ.

1
anglo_xp[1λ] •

Really funny, I really liked it

1
Dimblfully[2λ] •

I am a bit confused. What I saw is more like a video where you are having fun with your friends. I couldn't be engaged to watch more and I straggled watching 50% of it. If it weren't for me trying to find constructive feedback I would have left after 10 sec.

So what was the aim of that video? If you have a follower base then I can understand how they could be interested in that video. But for a non-follower, maybe you could add the best joke/funny moment in the intro (as a token of what to expect)?
Does this make sense?

0
Dog_BitOP[1λ] •

Were you actively trying to take a dump on my chest? If so you did a great job. Thanks for 'straggling' through 50%. If you don't outright like or have any knowledge about the sector a vid is in (video gaming) You really shouldn't be giving it a review. That advice is free

!givelambda

0
SmallYTChannelBotMOD[🏆 ∞λ] 🤖•

You have given u/Dimblfully 1λ. u/Dimblfully now has 5λ

^/u/SmallYTChannelBot ^made ^by ^/u/jwnskanzkwk. ^PM ^for ^bug ^reports. ^For ^more ^information, ^read ^the ^FAQ.

1
Dimblfully[2λ] •

Lol you misjudged my comment completely. I am not a native english speaker so if my language gave the wrong impression I apologise.

But the fact is that indeed I struggled. Yes I am a gamer and funny enough I work part time as a VR specialist. So unless you are ready to ask yourself "why a person took time to write to me that he didn't enjoy the video", maybe you should reconsider your approach on YouTube.

When growing you should be focusing on why somebody left your video mid way, or why they saw an impression and didn't click. No point in focusing on the things you already do well.

In my comment there is constructive criticism. I told you what I would like to see in the beginning (a recomendation) and what was my impression (personal opinion, which is not very important since you don't know me, but you are the one asking feedback from random people on reddit). You took it personally and proven to be weak in receiving criticism. You'll get there, but still there is way to go.

Don't use this subreddit if you only want positive comment, here we want to grow and learn from our mistakes.

Stay creative and safe.

0
Dog_BitOP[1λ] •

If you don't like any of the video, and it's supposed to be a funny video, then either I'm really unfunny or you don't like my brand of humor. I gave your comment Lambda because I genuinely believe that you gave me a piece of advice but you believed in. I trusted you even though what you said was pretty much irrelevant. Because I had already done what you said. I had put what I thought was the funniest clip at the start of the video. Which links back to my earlier statement that you either don't think I'm funny, or don't understand the humor.

And yes, I'm going to take something personal when it's not just my work you're criticizing, it's my personality. I don't want just positive feedback in this sub Reddit. Unfortunately for viewers like you I can't fix being unfunny. So I suppose my channel is doomed to swirl around 300 subs for all eternity.

0