Philip Pullman's "The Secret Commonwealth" is immensely disappointing for a lot of reasons. This is representative of one of them.
Posted Mar 22, 2020, 1:26 PM UTC
Posted Mar 22, 2020, 1:26 PM UTC
What the hell does that mean
Ok... but why does she want them to be disconcerted? Why does she do it with sexuality and not, say, threats of violence or gross out toilet humor? What's the corniest joke she finds amusing? What's the most ridiculous thing she has a phobia of? Does she have any pets? Who was her favorite teacher growing up and why? What's her favorite season? What "feel good" food does she crave when she has a cold? Who is a popular celebrity she can't stand? Does she make a list when she goes grocery shopping or does she wing it?
People are such complex and fascinating little creatures, and it's so frustrating to see women reduced to "She was ugly but somehow sexy and also a tease because I, the author, think that's what all sexually forward woman act like."
The Book of Dust trilogy is just awful so far. Things like this plus the rape that happened in the first book for no reason (with no actual follow up).... I’m done with it. As a lifelong fan of HDM, I’m so disappointed.
Fuck. That's a bummer. I haven't gotten around to reading it yet, but HDM are forever my favourite books.
I agree, even just from reading the first one. What a lame departure from the epic and intricate style of the first trilogy.
What’s HDM?
His Dark Materials
I liked the book well enough as a whole (not as good as the others though), but this confused me too.
Malcolm KNEW how she used her intense sexuality despite her subpar looks. Malcolm is one smug bastard.
Notice how the male authors project themselves onto the male protagonists, with their uncanny ability to fathom the depths of women’s sexuality?
as gross as this is i feel like it would describe me pretty well
Maybe from a gross dude’s POV.
Any normal human would see you as you are which is prolly awesome.
Ugly is in the eye of the beholder
This is high on the Bill O’Reilly scale of describing female sexual response.
[deleted]
I imagine she wears a trench coat and flashes people with her “intense sexuality”. Yah know, just to disconcert them.
Weirdness. How do people not check themselves when they write stuff like this.
I think that on the next page he explains that what he meant was that she whipped them in the face with a dildo.
Smh my head. How dare OP not provide such context to this passage