You have no policy solution - Debate with Vaush

Posted Mar 22, 2020, 1:35 PM UTC

9097
Zach_Zach•

At 13:05 in this video Vaush literally says he has no policy proposals in the current system or even if the senate flips after accusing Destiny of having no policy discussion geared towards climate change.

Vaush lurkers please explain how I’m an idiot.

88
aski3252•

accusing Destiny of having no policy discussion geared towards climate change.

He is accusing Destiny of having "no solution" to tackle climate change. Vaush isn't talking about policy specifically, but "solutions" in general.

My guess is that Vaush doesn't think that there are any policy changes that would solve climate change on their own. He believes that the whole system has to change.

30
myselfoverwhelmed•

And then Destiny’s argument is that Vaush’s “solution” isn’t possible either, so we’re back to square one.

I get the arguments that each person is trying to make, but with how humanity tends to handle global problems the reality is that we’re probably just going to be fucked inevitably (I know, we probably already are).

By the time we find the “solution” everyone can get behind it’ll be too late.

12
Al-Horesmi•

But if destiny was pushing for a solution everyone would get behind it faster. He is a big streamer, can convince a lot of people.

3
WillsBlackWilly•

Even if Vaush’s revolution happened, and it turned out to be a perfect solution for climate change. You would still have to deal with the fact that the US isn’t the largest polluter, and that we would still be in such a fucked situation when it comes to climate change.

-2†
Al-Horesmi•

US is one of the largest pollutants per capita. We can meme a lot about China but they have been doing much more than US to combat co2 emissions. China will always pollute more than US as they have four times the population.

So no, fixing domestic co2 emissions in US would go a long way.

And, US holds an enormous amount of economic and military power, they could influence policy in other countries to a large degree.

7
jozeyjoe•

He’s saying that any policies substantial enough to actually deter the inevitable impacts on climate change are not possible even if we flip the senate. He does support the same policies as Destiny in the short term, but acknowledges that the drastic policies climate change necessitates wouldn’t be viable even if we flipped the house.

28
Zach_Zach•

So if they support the same short term goals and both acknowledge a socialist revolution will not happen in our lifetimes what exactly separates Vaush from the “white moderate” MLK was talking about? His YouTube channel is woker than Destiny’s?

Is literally anybody not building guillotines actively destroying the planet?

If I want my kid to be able to breathe in air in 25 years it’s not going to be because I sat in a socialist echo chamber screeching about “white moderates.” It is, unfortunately, RIDIN WITH MOTHERFUCKING BIDEN and pushing for what we can get through viable political channels.

14†
jozeyjoe•

The point Vaush was making is that you can’t just dismiss conversation outside of what’s politically viable, that broader conversations are necessary. You “Ride with Biden” and simultaneously have conversation about broader theoretical subjects. And vaush does both of these, he isn’t Bernie or Bust.

29
ABitKnobbis•

Sure, but Vaush was acting in bad faith. You can’t criticize somebody for having solutions that you don’t think will be sufficient, while simultaneously complaining that your solutions aren’t being taken seriously by Destiny.

This whole conversation just feels like the Spider-Man pointing meme.

32
Justsomedudelmao•

Honestly you kind of can dismiss those conversations, at least as not being more practical relative to conversations over more feasible policies or actions.

Socialist revolutions have their place in discourse, but not Destiny would probably be more interested in putting them on the back burner.

-1
MuffugginAssGoblinDGGisapyramidscheme•

He isn’t Bernie or bust but is he ridin’, though?

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
aski3252•

what exactly separates Vaush from the “white moderate” MLK was talking about? His YouTube channel is woker than Destiny’s?

Destiny argues that enacting policy within the current system alone, in contrast to activism and other methods that work outside of the system, is best to bring change.

This is basically what MLK was talking about when "white moderats" were telling him that he shouldn't use the "militant" methods he used and instead focus on working within the system, even though moderats agreed with the goals of the civil rights movement.

14
Zach_Zach•

But moderates do not agree with socialism, they agreed with desegregation, just not MLKs method.

Also comparing Vaushs tactics to “militant” is actually fucking delusional, comrade.

11
carlcalrington26•

At risk of getting banned please explain to me how this is any different than a royalist saying "I know you want Democratic representation but what are the solutions you can achieve under the monarchy? See you in a hundred years when you're no closer to democracy lol" Vaush's whole argument is that big sociatle change is a necessary to get us in a position to actually make these massive changes. It's a completely fair criticism to argue that anything less than sociatle change isn't going to be enough. One could also say "well it's also fair to say your ideas are to radical to actually happen" but this point you're just on a doomer lock down where both sides acknowledge that there's a massive issue we need to fix but are stuck arguing that there's really nothing you can do about it

9
Zach_Zach•

Okay, I will explain the difference.

Me and you are both rich enough and educated enough to have this conversation over the internet on smartphones. This happened under capitalism.

Under Monarchies, the population was nearly entirely enslaved, leading to no education and slow moving progress. Under communism, entire populations were decimated, races nearly wiped out from this planet due to starvation and death camps, comrade.

The serfs arguing against fiefdom were literal slaves with no rights.

I am not on doomer lock down, there is a path forward to combating climate change but because it is difficult, and complicated it’s easier to say:

DAE EVER GUILLOTINE LMAOOOOO, which is what his subreddit is btw.

The way to fix the massive issue is through the system that enabled us to have this conversation, not some utopian fantasy.

1
Wannabe_Sadboi•

How do we get there? I’m not sure what Vaush’s plan is. I just feel like it’s pretty easy to sit and go “Well, of course I don’t have a legislative solution, I don’t need one, I advocate for ACTIVISM, CLASS AGITATION, and MASSIVE SOCIETAL CHANGE.” I want to know what the specific actions Vaush wants to have taken are, and specifically how he thinks they’re going to solve those problems. It seems to me like he enjoys sitting in a gray area where he’s “building a movement” and a lot of things that are more broad ambiguous terms than specific actions.

1
pkfighter343•

I mean, it helps to have someone yelling about socialism if you think that is either the end goal or even if it’s further left of your end goal. Either you’re airing something that you want to work towards through incremental change, or you’re showing something that you can use to say what you want is a compromise.

2
Zach_Zach•

100% but don’t turn around and shit on anybody not yelling with you. Which is what Vaush is doing to Destiny.

1
Al-Horesmi•

Is literally anybody not building guillotines actively destroying the planet

YES.

Loud, obnoxious screeching about white moderates on the streets is how most political change happened in this country. And in most other countries.

1

The Dems already have the House.

-2
faacade•

Well, policy proposals that are viable to do 'enough' to properly combat climate change, is what i think he means.

4
ElusoryThunderSpoilerGate Survivor•

It's what he means and almost verbatim what he says

4
SketsOOOO•

Striker debate still not uploaded LUL

37
ezranos•

Editor wrote that its a youtube issue.

14
Praesto_Omnibus•

it’s up now

9

DREW

2
codylramey•

This debate exposes a key dividing point in the left and the moderate wing of the democratic party. The left want to talk about the things that need to get done in order to solve the issues and the moderates are saying it is impossible to get done within our system. If the lefties are right, that these radical changes are what is necessary to fix these big problems we are having, and the moderates are right, that the current system will not allow for these radical changes, then wouldn't the system itself be the problem that needs to be changed?

18
RoboticWaterM🌐🌐T•

The left want to talk about the things that need to get done in order to solve the issues and the moderates are saying it is impossible to get done within our system.

This is the most unfair characterization of the problem. Both the left and the moderates want to solve climate change. The left wants to "change the system" without proposing any politically feasible means of doing so, moderates want to solve climate change by passing whatever they can. Cap and trade, carbon taxes, fazing out fossil fuel production without causing a shock to the economy.

A socialist revolution isn't happening, and the Green New Deal isn't passing. Lefties can claim to want to "change the system" all they want, but that really just amounts to virtue signalling. To acquire political power and actually make a difference requires compromise.

then wouldn't the system itself be the problem that needs to be changed?

The problem is always the system; the question is how ought the system be changed? Should we toss it out and replace it with a system that only works on paper? Or should we be more careful about what changes we make? Even anarcho-communist Noam Chomsky urges the latter.

20
codylramey•

I want to start by saying that I was not just talking in terms of climate change. This can be applied to many of the issues the left and center differ on.

The left wants to "change the system" without proposing any politically feasible means of doing so

What are the politically feasibly ways of solving something like Climate change?

moderates want to solve climate change by passing whatever they can. Cap and trade, carbon taxes, fazing out fossil fuel production without causing a shock to the economy.

Will cap and trad, carbon taxes, and fazing out fossil fuel production in a politically feasible manner solve climate change?

A socialist revolution isn't happening, and the Green New Deal isn't passing. Lefties can claim to want to "change the system" all they want, but that really just amounts to virtue signalling.

I am not a socialist so idk why you are bringing this point up. I support the green new deal though I am ignorant of the details so I guess I just support the idea of radical climate regulations.

The people who are "virtue signaling", do you think that they do not legitimately believe that in order to truly solve climate change something radical like the green new deal needs to pass?

The problem is always the system; the question is how ought the system be changed? Should we toss it out and replace it with a system that only works on paper?

Which system do you think I support? I only made descriptive claims in my first post, nothing prescriptive. I only pointed out that the system itself is a problem.

Or should we be more careful about what changes we make?

Ofc we should be careful about what changes we make. But I do not believe that we should be so careful that we perpetuate the system that is going to cause something like climate change fuck us all in the future. And that is kind of what we are doing in electing people who are not for the radical changes that needs to be made in order to stop it.

1
RoboticWaterM🌐🌐T•

Will cap and trad, carbon taxes, and fazing out fossil fuel production in a politically feasible manner solve climate change?

More feasible than anything I've heard from Vaush in this video.

I am not a socialist so idk why you are bringing this point up.

Because you said "the left" as opposed to moderates in a post about Vaush. If by "the left" you meant center left, then carbon taxes and cap and trade are center left policies, so the dichotomy you drew in your post is contrived.

I support the green new deal though I am ignorant of the details so I guess I just support the idea of radical climate regulations.

So do I, but no one is gonna get on board with those policies until people start dying. Supporting radical change means nothing if that change doesn't have political will.

Which system do you think I support?

I don't care about what you think. I care about what the left thinks, because that's what your post was about.

I only pointed out that the system itself is a problem.

I agree, and I said the system is always the problem/

But I do not believe that we should be so careful that we perpetuate the system that is going to cause something like climate change fuck us all in the future.

What system do you mean? If we're talking about policy, you can't keep focusing on some nebulous "system" as the object of your critique. "The system is unjust" is a a trite platitude that offers no path towards actually rectifying that system.

Do you mean capitalism? You said you're not a socialist, so I assume that's not the "system" you're talking about. Do you mean republican democracy? A benevolent dictator could swiftly curtail out contribution to climate change, but I assume that's also not what you're thinking.

So what do you mean by the "system," and how is the left actually addressing what we need to do about it?

And that is kind of what we are doing in electing people who are not for the radical changes that needs to be made in order to stop it.

Who is "we"? Because we're votes among millions. Saying "we can't keep voting in people who aren't in favor of radical change" is just meaningless virtue signaling. Yes, of course we need more radical policy, but the way you get any policy enacted is to form a coalition around it.

6
codylramey•

I am going to ignore some of the stuff here because it is kind of off topic and i feel would just derail the conversation. If I ignore something you feel should be addressed lmk and ill edit it in.

More feasible than anything I've heard from Vaush in this video.

That was not the question i asked. Ill ask it again, Will cap and trade, carbon taxes, and fazing out fossil fuel production in a politically feasible manner solve climate change?

So do I, but no one is gonna get on board with those policies until people start dying. Supporting radical change means nothing if that change doesn't have political will.

Electing people who support the radical change is how you get the political will. Instead of boasting "itll never happen" people should be talking about how it needs to happen so that people will elect people who will make it happen. If instead of talking about how radical the green new deal is, how the senate will never pass it, the MSM should have been talking about how these measures are needed in order to mitigate the negative effects of climate change.

What system do you mean? If we're talking about policy, you can't keep focusing on some nebulous "system" as the object of your critique. "The system is unjust" is a a trite platitude that offers no path towards actually rectifying that system.

Well we can start with the government. We have a system that perpetuates only 2 political parties viable for public office. So things like first past the post winner take all, gerry mandering, not having ranked choice voting. Idk to what extent these things would help but they are the things that I have heard we need in order to be more represented.

This can also go into how primaries are held and such. The whole "I dont have to control who you choose if I can control who you get to choose from" thing.

The disproportionate power corporate lobbyist have when compared to lobbyist that represent regular people is a problem, I do not know the solution to.

The mainstream media perpetuating corporate talking points such as "Medicare for all is impossible, too expensive, etc etc." Sometimes it is to a point where they are giving actual misinformation. They dont usually lie but, in the way the deliver the information, they are misinforming people in order to get them to think a certain way.

Its not really just one system, its a series of systems that work together to keep people believing that changing the system, which we both agree needs to happen, is impossible.

Who is "we"? Because we're votes among millions. The American people, the democratic party as a whole, there are many "we"s who are voting to perpetuate the system.

Saying "we can't keep voting in people who aren't in favor of radical change" is just meaningless virtue signaling.

Its not tho, its a descriptive claim that we both agree is true. Ill break it down. We need radical change, we both agree on that. The way to get what we want is voting, I would assume we both agree on that, so the only way to get what we want/need (radical change) then we cant keep voting people who are not for the radical change we need. You call it virtue signaling, I call it the truth.

Yes, of course we need more radical policy, but the way you get any policy enacted is to form a coalition around it.

Except we havent been able to do that. So this system doesnt work. We both agree with that. Do you think that if the left and the moderates worked together to pass a moderate agenda everything would be good? Furthermore do you think that if the moderates were to pass something like cap and trade for example the lefties would deny it because its not good enough. Of course we will take what we can get but we will continue screaming that its not good enough.

Edit: We might have to start focusing this conversation on less points. The wall texts are going to get ridiculous xD

1
Burrarabbit•

Changing the system IS the solution that the left is proposing and the moderates argue that this isn't realisitic. Take climate change for example. Vaush said that he doesn't think ANY policy would be sufficient enough even if Dems swept the senate. His overall solution is revolution and socialism which he admits won't happen in his lifetime. The most generous estimates, to my knowledge, are that we have until 2050 to do something before it becomes irreversible and catastrophic. We are on a timer. If you brush aside all of the policy positions proposed as being "insufficient" and believe that the only solution is radically changing the system which you also believe won't happen in your lifetime, it's not really surprising that people like Destiny don't really take your position seriously.

3
codylramey•

Lefties dont brush them off as insufficient, we simply point out that its insufficient. If someone passed cap and trade, or a public option we would still be talking about how insufficient those programs are because we would still need more in order to tackle our problems. But its not like we would outright reject the progress.

3
Hannig4n•

The moderates would disagree with the premise that “these radical changes are necessary to fix these big problems.”

The moderates don’t just think their plans are more politically viable, they think their plans are just better anyway.

1
codylramey•

Is that what you believe?

3
Hannig4n•

I would probably consider myself a social democrat, so I generally think it’s better to work within the system of capitalism.

From how I see it, most leftists are great at pointing out the flaws of the current system, but stop short of explaining how the new system would be better after the revolution. This is why they sometimes struggle with bringing liberals over: you can’t just explain why capitalism sucks, you gotta prove that socialism is better. Liberals already know that capitalism has issues, their entire political ideology revolves around using govt to address the shortcomings of capitalism.

1
codylramey•

The revolution most lefties spoke of wasnt really a capitalism vs socialism, at least not the one that Bernie was trying to lead. Maybe twitter lefties were? Idk, I dont live in that world. The only person I listen to, on occasion, who is in that world is Vaush because I believe most of the time he argues in good faith so I am able to get a perspective that is left of mine without bad faith arguments. Similar reason I spend time here, Destiny has a perspective that is probably to the right of mine but he generally argues in good faith. Im somewhere in between the two (probably closer to Destiny). Anyway back to the "revolution". The one that Sanders was trying to lead wasnt about capitalism vs socialism, it was one of making the government work for the people. If the government truly worked for the people then the radical changes that is needed would be able to get done. But alas, it failed. Odds are it was going to fail anyway, whether it fell apart once he got into office because people stopped paying attention or it fell apart in the general (unlikely) the odds were always against him because he was trying to change a system in which every cog in the system has an interest in not changing.

2
Kornillious•

And you guys mass downvoted me twice for saying Vaush was two-faced PepeLaugh

15

The TL;DR of this conversation is:

Vaush said Destiny has no policy positions. Destiny confronts Vaush on this premise. They trade personal criticisms of each other's uncharitable reductions of the other's viewpoints.

Vaush eventually admits that Destiny does have policy positions. Vaush moves the goal post a little saying they aren't sufficient.

That ignores however that "You don't have policy positions" and "You don't have sufficient policy positions" are two entirely different beasts with two entirely different connotations. The first being that you are either speaking from a place of disinterest or ignorance. The second being that you are either not proposing effective policy or are two bogged down by caution/drawbacks of more aggressive policy.

Anger aside, calling Destiny bad faith here and ignoring the above is ultimately either bad faith or just very inconsiderate.

14
aski3252•

Vaush said Destiny has no policy positions

This is a misunderstanding. Vaush said destiny has "no (sufficient) solution to climate change". Vaush doesn't seem to mean this as a personal criticism of destiny's lack of solutions, but more of a general criticism of destiny's focus on parlamentary politics, which he believes is misguided and uneffective.

I think the "bad faith" accusations come from destiny assuming that Vaush was talking about policy when he claimed "destiny has no solutions" (implying that all viable solutions have to be done within the framework of parlamentary politics). This dismissive attitude towards "activism" and other methods that work outside of the current system, which Vaush believes to be at least just as important as the parlamentary politics part, are dismissed as boring, irrelevant and utopian.

I don't think it's bad faith, probably more of a misunderstanding of the excact position that Vaush has.

0†

I feel like you didn't read my post.

1
aski3252•

Why would I not read your comment when I reply to it? Do you mean I misunderstood something? If yes, why don't you say so and explain what I got wrong instead of leaving a passive aggressive comment that doesn't help?

This is how I understood it:

Your first claim is that "Vaush said Destiny has no policy positions.", which I think is a misunderstanding of Vaush's statement. Vaush was never talking about policy.

3

First, Vaush did not originally say sufficient. That wasn't the context outside the quote either.

Second, I gave a sequence of events of what Vaush said and the difference between what Vaush retconned it into and the ramifications of both.

Your post goes into explaining what Vaush said and meant without acknowledging anything about the contents of my post.

Akin to someone saying: "Sally and Tim broke up. Looks like Sally caught him cheating."

and someone else responding with "You see Tim was cheating, and that was why Sally broke up with him."

1

What started this debate?

Also, Steven please keep talking to / being --maybe-- friends with Vaush. If you're the last great sjw, He's the last great Leftist.

6
naverenoh•

Vaush felt like taking pot shots when he wasn't looking and someone sent him the clip.

15

Can you show me the clip?

2
naverenoh•

No, I assume it was posted sometime in dgg chat yesterday. Just go to the vod from before the rajj royale yesterday and subtract the time this debate took from the end and voila, you probably will see him watching the clip. That's the best I can do for ya.

0

Thank you!

2
BlazeOrangeDeer•

Vaush's chat linked him a clip of Destiny talking about their in-person debate, 2:29:38 here. Basically Destiny repeated his usual criticisms of the left and Vaush thought he should have brought those up in the debate, and it goes on from there.

3
JesterTheEnt•

I haven't liked Irishladdie since the whole sexual predator debacle, hoping it ends here so he can fuck off forever.

2†
Shermen8tor•

I really hope this is the last chat with Vaush. Its a worthless conversation. CRP has move to say.

2
PascalLerouxOP•

Dayum, that's harsh. I don't know about that hehe, and I really don't like Vaush.

2
Eccmecc•

Vaush had absolute zero arguments.

1†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AssFasting•

This was incredibly annoying. I watched the build-up parries, I watched the live, I watched the first part of this on Vaushes and then watched this one from the start.

I think I'll give a miss to any content from these two together now. As I listen to both I found Steve to be biting at the bit and not keeping it tracking and Vaush incredibly slippery. He knew exactly what Steve wanted to talk about but wouldn't engage.

The introduction in this one compared to Vaushes certainly adds a bit more context. Vaush I'm disappointed.

Do you think this is a planned collab arc to generate content by these pair?

0†
PascalLerouxOP•

After watching this discussion, I gave a detailed response in relation to socialism being a viable, grounded political theory (it isn't, not even close).

-11