r/sysadmin•
ethCore7

On call rotation schedules

Hi r/sysadmin,

I'm looking for examples on what on-call rotation schedules everyone uses. We started out in 3 people rotating whole weeks, but being on call 7 days in a row was pretty taxing.

Some time later, we then gained one more admin and moved to "fixed days" schedule, where each of us has on-call one fixed day of a week (Mo-Th) with rotating weekends, which works pretty well.

However, now we're up to 5 people and can't decide on the schedule to use. We tried rotating the 5th guy over the fixed days, which works but isn't fair for him, as everyone else has a fixed day and his on-calls move through the week. We're also toying with leaving 1 person out of the schedule for 1 or 3 months at a time, but there's probably going to be some competition for not being on-call during the summer :)

So, I'm hoping I can get some more schedule examples from other orgs which we could evaluate. The rotation rules should not be too crazy, so it can be easily setup in OpsGenie, which we use for on-call scheduling.

Thanks for feedback!

Posted Mar 23, 2020, 10:07 AM UTC

811
ex800•

Although being on call for 7 days in a row does take it out of you, with five of people each one gets four weeks of no on call at all...

11
ethCore7OP•

Yeah, it seems like we should re-evaluate that. Thanks for the feedback.

1
sobrique•

If 7 days on call is taxing, that's the thing you need to fix, not the rotation. Look at why you're getting called out, and try and get that number down.

A 1 week in 6 is about optimal IMO, but 1 week in 5 isn't too horrible.

If it's being 'taxing' that means you're getting called a lot, and may need to accept a 2-person coverage system - e.g. two people on call at any one time, 1 primary one 'standby'.

And the primary is getting generous time-off-in-lieu e.g. if you're called out, don't come in the next day (or maybe just 'next afternoon') with the standby picking up any calls where they've just not had enough shift-break.

9
ethCore7OP•

I agree with the "fixing the taxing" part. We've since overhauled our monitoring stack and it's gotten better, but our team agreed that we prefer the new schedule more, so I'm mostly looking for ideas on how to tweak it to acomodate the extra person.

1
sobrique•

Well, can you spare 1 person each week to do 'just' on call? e.g. have them work from home ( I mean normally, not just during corona insanity) and cover 'light duties'?

1
ethCore7OP•

We're all remote, so most work from home already. In the context of our org, your suggestion would basically mean to move back to the weekly schedule. I guess we should try to re-evaluate that, as our previous not-so-good experience came from when we had only 3 people doing the rotation.

Thanks for the feedback.

2
SuperQueBit Plumber•

I've done 3x4 with small rotations like that.

  • Tuesday morning to Friday morning.
  • Friday morning to Tuesday morning.

The idea is that the Tuesday-Thursday days were our heavy oncall days and the Weekend, while annoying that you're oncall, is pretty quiet.

We also swapped secondary so that your oncall week would still be 7 days, but you were only primary for "half" of it.

3
ethCore7OP•

I like this, seems like a nice compromise between the whole week and our current rotation. Thanks for the suggestion!

1
gregbe•

We rotate a primary and secondary on call each week between 5 of us. Week 1, I'll be secondary, Week 2 I'm primary, Weeks 3-5 I'm off. If we're on-call a week that doesn't work (ie. planned vacation), we're responsible for switching weeks with someone else in the department.

I think your structure/schedule will depend on your setup - response times, the number and type of calls, etc.

2
pockypimp•

We have 3 people doing the weekly rotation, Tues-Tues. So you start Tuesday night and have it until Tuesday morning.

2
[deleted]•

3 of us, we do Friday 0800 to Friday 0800, get the weekend out of the way first. It was just two of us and was every other week on call. I don't feel being on call for 7 days is too taxing mostly because we don't typically have a lot of calls, and if we do 90% of it is remotely done. I did have to travel to work 3 times this weekend, which in my memory is the first time that's every happened. We also get a baseline pay for being on call plus 1 hour minimum from home, 2 hour minimum if you have to travel to the office or fire stations.

2