Been lurking for a while, but I made my first loaf of bread today! It’s pretty dense. Any tips?

Posted Mar 23, 2020, 4:47 PM UTC

Posted Mar 23, 2020, 4:47 PM UTC
How did you make it? Recipe pls.
I just put the recipe in a comment! Thanks!
It looks whole wheat. Maybe need vital wheat gluten to rise.
I just put the recipe in a comment! I want to use whole wheat eventually, but I know it often makes for a denser loaf so I’m trying to stay with “regular” flours first.
Recipe:
-3c AP flour (I was surprised that it didn’t call for bread flour? But it said AP so I used AP)
-1/4t instant yeast
-1/2T salt
-1.5-1.75c room temperature water (I used 1.75)
Combine flour, yeast, and salt in a bowl. Add water until dough is a sticky, shaggy ball. Cover loosely with plastic and prove at room temperature for 12-18 hours (I did 18).
Scrape out of bowl and into greased loaf pan (mine is glass). Shape as needed. Let sit for 30 mins.
Put straight into cold oven and set temperature to 450. Cook for 30 min.
Are you sure you used instant yeast instead of active dry yeast? When I first started backing I thought those two are the same thing lol
Also, you might have degassed is a bit too much after proving.
It says “fast rise yeast: works for bread machines”? 😬
I tried to be gentle when I scraped from the bowl to the loaf pan, but it definitely looked much poofier in the bowl so I wouldn’t be surprised if it just popped too much. I’m wondering if I over-proved it which made it too poofy and therefore deflate?
It might have been. Another thing that could be, that maybe you didn't let the dough to prove one more time or to rest after you put it in the form.
Yeah, it didn’t seem to rise any more when I let it rest for 30 mins? I assume it was supposed to?
Put it in a taller pan. there are pans specifically for bread if you have that it would help it rise.