Seigfred Job+

Discussion

PSA: He is still not very strong for his rate of availability.

http://imgur.com/a/MeZDWaA

His PATK was only improved by around 60. His HP was not not Improved noticeably, either. I was hoping they would increase his base HP enough where his hat would be enough to give him decent HP, but unfortunately no.

I was disappointed to see his damage against the dark enemies in his very own multiplay stage. Even units without Elemental advantage do more damage than him. To drive this point home I used Balt, and compared the basic, unbuffed attacks of Sig and Balt against the boss of this stage (Zhen Yi).

Balt outperformed Seigfred even against a dark unit like Zhen-Yi, which is quite disappointing, since Seigfred also has an elemental advantage here. I tried light-element units with less investment than my Seigfred (Moa, Blair) and they both out-performed him in consistent enemy-handling.

(NOTE1: My Seigfred is 95 5/3/3/4/3) (NOTE2: the memento gives him 13% slash damage)

Discuss!

Posted Mar 26, 2020, 12:52 PM UTC · edited

2447
Saber193•

Gumi, stop making your GLEX units bad. I know you're scared of Roxy, but this is ridiculous. These units have such fun designs and feel like they have a lot more thought put into them than the units we just import from JP, but you have to stop making them too weak for us to use! Their power level is not at all in line with their difficulty in building.

38
sinkal•

So I'm not Crazy at all that Seighfired Job+ is bad. Just invest on Seiba insted

10
Tigerwarrior55•

Assuming the game outlives its JP counterpart or they both keep going for a long time, it definitely is a good idea especially in light of her J+ which brings some improvements. Also remember when siegfried was better than sieba?

2
sinkal•

well now our last hope is on Roxy Job+, If Gumi even listen to this.

4
silerius•

Called it, not surprised at all

4
Skyconic•

I was really excited for his J+ and it was such a letdown. Was really hoping they would somehow change his G2 and G5 to include his J+. Like make the upgraded passive finesse for G2. And if they made his snowball infinitely stackable instead of just 10x (also if it was crit damage instead of the crit stat).

4
Cobalt_721•

I’m personally interested in seeing what the exact modifiers are for his passives once the database updates.

Regardless, his Job+ is at least easy to farm.

3
Skyconic•

Or you can literally just skip the stages all together and use gold job tokens and omnicrystal diagrams because it’s coded weird.

4
Cobalt_721•

I saw that but decided against it. I’m assuming they forgot to add the bit of code that prevents universal materials from being used for Job+s.

2
maraku0893•

Easy to farm because it's easy lol. I auto it with Neun, Meliodas, Kudan and Levi.

2
maymagicOP•

Indeed

2
ArrowVl•

Fun fact, apparently you don't run his snowball but the Slash damage passive, as it seems to be stronger (not number values, but it gives overall more damage compared to running the snowball), and your numbers are so low compared to mine (and I also lack the memento) that I actually question if you even gave him gears/have him enlightened at all (and considering from the PAtk your Sieg has, the answer is blatantly negative).

Here is a small album I did with 4 images of Siegfried and his base damage (1 LS, Zain's, and Slash passive + G2): https://ibb.co/album/g2hL6F
If you wanna talk crap of a unit, at least make sure you can use a real one and not a fake one.

3†
maymagicOP•
  1. That is not his basic attack, this throws out all of your screenshots. Re-do them with the basic attack.
  2. Gears are in my screenshot (Gram/Balmung, Hat, Wonder Chronos Accessory) so you didn't look. You're also wasting a mark of Envy on him just to make your damage look more decent, dude.
  3. I ran this with NO leader-skill buff, intentionally. You ran it with one that gives him a major handicap to make him look better.
  4. My Seigfred is 5/3/3/4/3, so you're assuming incorrectly. You're obviously using his Gate2 passive, which I do not have.

If you want to compare your findings to mine, you need to use the same controls as me, by not using a leaderskill that buffs his damage (or the comparison unit, e.g. Balt/Seiba/Yauras/Other dual-wield-evade characters) and not using a skill-attack (as those have different mods between the characters you are trying to side-by-side).

1
ArrowVl•

And how is a basic attack enough proof to say a unit is a disappointment, exactly?
Also, no. I'm not wasting an Envy Mark on him, cause that's actually the setup I'm using him now. I could run Levi's teacup, and the result would pretty much be the same. I just don't wanna lose the Crit Rate from the Legion God, and Envy mark gives me both Hp and PAtk.

To me sounds like you searched for his lowest potential damage just to show reddit "He's bad just like how everyone say".

Yes, Sadness (I deleted my comment by mistake, ffs), my Sieg is 5/5/3/5/3. Missing memento.

4
maymagicOP•

Splitting hairs there on Yauras, you know? I was ballparking off memory. She is still better than him in most important ways. I use the mark of Envy on Yauras along with the snow globe and her diary. Her CRIT is better than Sig's without the Legion.

Yes, he's bad, You had to master Gate 1, 2, and 4, and put a cash shop gear on him just to get him 800 ATK, you know?

2
ArrowVl•

Except you can get the same result with any PAtk gear and Levi's teacup.

If you want I can easily show you the damage he can do, but you'd still argue he's bad cause reasons.

Just realize a unit does not have to be broken, in order to be good. He got a snowball (albeit, it seems like the Slash passive is better overall after the testing I've done), high agility and move, a lot of evade (even if I am not really anymore a fan of it), and dark Resist.

Just deal with the fact he's not Sieba and not a Raid/Box unit, but more of a PvP one. He's not bad, you just want him to be. His memento gives him a lot of Dark res, Slash and damage against humans, and alongside the VCR makes him pretty much invulnerable to most dangerous statuses in PvP, giving him also a personal Tezla Grenade as Vision Ability. Jewel Regen, +1 Skill count from his Memento, Jewel destroy...

He isnt supposed to be what you people were expecting him to be. He's a PvP oriented unit that can do some pretty good damage with Basic Fist, and that's good enough.

4
EggyT0ast•

Are you comparing him to other units that are also fully enlightened? Seems weird to complain that someone had to master his gates to make him stronger.

3
Sadness_00•

whats your enlightenment? do you have G4 maxed?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
maymagicOP•

5/3/3/4/3

1
MoogleK•

Damn, that's so sad... I'm happy that we have our global units. But why does Gumi only motivate us to bench most of them?

3
Rostice•

Its astonishing how they 'fixed' Mikasa to be a relatively good unit by just adding extra % PAttk. Why is it so hard to do a similar thing to Siegfried? Unless I am unaware of something, his J+ didn't change to much.

3
EggyT0ast•

I don't know how you've set up your Sieg but that doesn't match my numbers at all. My normal attack on a wind enemy was doing 1750+... with no leaderskill.

2
maymagicOP•

My gear/passives are in the screenshots. Feel free to post your setup and damage vs the same enemy (Zheng Yi).

3
EggyT0ast•

I'm posting up a video shortly.

2
maraku0893•

Press F for Siegfried J+, Gumi is just really bad with designing Job+ for their Magni Historia units.

Don't even have Siegfried so I'm just gonna wait patiently for Sieba J+

2
maymagicOP•

I am BAFFLED why they aren't just templating the final stats based on successful units of a similar play style, eg. Seiba J+, Yauras J+, Balt, etc. Every single one of those units has 1k+ PATK and still has slash+% mod. So why they thought 600 PATK would be OK for Seigfred.. well, it just makes my head HURT.

Its also like they do zero focus grouping or playtesting. I swear.

7
maraku0893•

Maybe Gumi just doesn't want Siegfried to be OP so they just gave him a regular kit on his J+ but it really is a huge disappointment, especially for those who spent on Siegfried and his shards.

5
Cobalt_721•

Yauras only reaches ~900 PAtk with her Job+ at 5/5/5/5/5 Enlightenment with her Memento and the Veda ring (highest PAtk a gear can give at +50) equipped before Leader Skills.

Looking at a pre-Job+ Siegfried at 5/5/3/5/5 Enlightenment with the Veda ring and his Memento, he reaches ~700 PAtk. With his Job+ I’d bet he can reach ~800 PAtk, and then he gets some Slash damage from upgraded Finesse on top of that. I think you might actually be underselling Siegfried here. He’s certainly not at the top of the Light roster, but it looks like he’s fairly high up in the ranks, though I’ll need to wait for the database to update before I can give a final stats assessment.

EDIT: It’s official, Job+ Siegfried reaches 817 PAtk at 5/5/3/5/5 Enlightenment with the Veda ring (790 with Gram & Balmung) with +20% Slash damage (+35% with a MLB copy of his Memento). Not as good as I think a lot of people were hoping for, but certainly not terrible. I think he’s a solid A-tier at the absolute worst.

1†
Monte924•

I feel like ever since the whole Roxanne debacle, Gumi has been afraid to make MH units too powerful and accidentally make them game breaking. This however has led to the opposite problem where they end up being too underpowered. Granted, i wouldn't actually mind this IF their shards were a lot easier to get... They are treated as rare as Genesis units, but they usage is like on the lower end of the Sacred Stones units (Roxanne's the only one who still gets my love)...

Frankly i feel like they should had the same usage and rarity as Babel units. Pretty good to great units that are well worth taking the time to raise, which are farmable, but hard to pull

4
maymagicOP•

You're forgetting Zheng Yi, whio is a well-made unit! Its weird too, cause Zheng Yi is post-Roxxy nerf.

7
Monte924•

I do not have Zheng Yi, so I can not judge

1
maymagicOP•

He's quite good. Great damage, stack-able PATK self-buffs while attacking, lots of teleport mobility, various damage types (magic & slashing) and lots of dark-damage resistance reduction for enemies. I abuse the hell out of him in Raids.

2
drift_summary•

f

1
johnathanle1108•

No surprising about his J+, Gumi is still Gumi. They are still afraid, and that is a reason why TAC revenue is falling down times to times. They don't know how to increase player's interests. We don't want to pay a exclusive skin for a char who never used, 29.99$ for skin + 25 shards. They totally make this game to go to the destination . GLEX now is expensive and trash at all (include Zheng Yi and Blair because cost to make them full G5 can't be compared with up-coming chars, collab in term of P/P).

2
taintilized•

i wanted to level him up cuz he looks so cool, but now seeing this :(, btw where did you get that item that looks like a watch on the third slot

2
maymagicOP•

It is called "Wonder Chronos" and is from the gear summon banners.

1
pdmt243Play+pull for waifus!•

no surprise there, Gimu is clearly scared of another original Rox lol

the sad thing is, Rox is barely able to hold herself in EX+ stages these days...

2
Mitch_Twd•

I feel like they should just remove his new Crescendo Ability and add into his G2 ability

2
maymagicOP•

I sorta thought the same

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1