Is everything the same after Balance?

Discussion

I've been binging this for a bit now and am reaching the end of the Balance arc. But I'm not really... exited to the listen to the rest of the podcast after this. From what I've seen, Balance seems to be the main bulk of the podcast. Its everyone's favourite. But do Amnesty and Graduaton ever really recapture that feeling or magic that Balance had? Or from that point onward does the podcast just live in the shadow of its former achievements?

Posted Mar 26, 2020, 8:13 PM UTC

413
[deleted]•

Not really, but thats because they're totally different stories with very different vibes. I didn't like amnesty at first, but stick through It it gets really good. Not as comical as balance, but still really engaging. The verdict is still out on graduation for me, but I haven't given up yet.

16
bringinthewoody•

Just try them and see if you like them! Everyone has their different opinions. Personally I loved Amnesty and thought it was a great follow-up. Its not traditional d&d, as they try a new game that's more roleplay focused, but I still encourage people to try it. And their mini-arcs are fun to listen to, if you have the time. I'd say wait for more episodes of Graduation to come out before diving in. It's getting a lot of mixed reactions right now. With the amount of episodes out you'll burn through them very quickly.

8
Crumbles_•

My opinion, you pretty much said it. I love balance but I've listened through Amnesty and barely even remember it. And as far as graduation. I barely finished the first before I decided it wasnt for me. But again, just my opinion.

2
MrTheGoose•

I think they've very intentionally tried to not replicate what balance was because they knew that they wouldn't be able to. I think that works to the benefit of the newer arcs though, because they feel like their own things instead of inferior copies of Balance. Amnesty took a bit to get used to but ended up being really good. Graduation was definitely a bit harder to get into (I would guess because it was a different DM than I was used to) but I think it's begun to pick up steam. P.S. As far as the mini-arcs go, I'd say Dust is worth a listen. I wasn't really the biggest fan of Commitment, though that's just my own opinion.

2
LobsterRobsterAU•

I thoroughly enjoyed Amnesty, I think Clint particularly had a much easier time Roleplaying in Amnesty than he did in Balance and he does some fantastic character work in it. I don't think Amnesty ever reaches the same high points that Balance did though, the tone is also very different from Balance even when it is being incredible. Graduation had a... rough start... but it seems like it's beginning to improve. Even if Graduation ends up great it will still be something very different to Balance. Things are not the same after Balance. Once you're done essentially grieving for the end of Balance though and are ready to move on, I do recommend you try their new stuff even though it's not the same you might find something new that you like.

I say this to everyone who makes a thread like this, even if you do not enjoy the mainline content check out the live shows. The older live shows are all based in the Balance world which you as a Balance listener should enjoy. The new live shows are just one shot stories imbued with pure chaotic energy and they are probably the best TAZ content aside from Balance. Also I would strongly recommend checking out Dimension 20's Tiny Heist, it is the best TTRPG content featuring the McElroys since Balance. You can watch the first episode of Tiny Heist for free here and then decide if you want to pay money to get behind the paywall and watch the rest.

2
space-pilot3000•

Heresy I know, but I actually liked Amnesty more than Balance, and so far I'm liking Graduation more, too.

That being said, if you didn't like Stolen Century, you probably won't like anything after Balance. That's okay too!

2
Raspberry_MilkshakeOP•

I've been quite enjoying the more emotional parts of Balance so far, but honestly I think that's because of the craziness. I feel like I've seen these characters and this story grow from a bunch of incoherent gags and silly accents to this epic tear jerking saga. It feels earned and reminds me of sitting around a DND table with friends. I'll probably quite enjoy the other arcs honestly from what I've heard. But Balance is one of the only pieces of DND media I feel truly captures that unique energy the game has, and I don't want it to end!

2
apresmodes•

The only way you’ll know is by trying it out. I’d listen to the one offs after Balance. See if you like them. If not maybe take a break and listen to something else. Spout Lore is my favorite recommendation. It’s fun and magical and creative and all four of them are just amazing at coming up with amazing story elements on the fly. Sounds like you’re experiencing the world with the players.

2
Raspberry_MilkshakeOP•

I actually listened to the first ep of Graduation when I was doing some art today, and it was pretty fun. While I do think it missed the joy of invention that made Balance stand out from other TTRPG podcasts, I would be happy to listen to more of it.

2
Celtic_laboratory•

They don’t recapture what balance was, but they are worth listening to at least amnesty is, graduation had a bad start but it slowing getting better

1
camomilafil•

I'd say Graduation and Amnesty are very different from Balance in tone, genre and humor. I hold Balance in my top 10 favorite pieces of media of all time, thought Amnesty was an okayish TTRPG podcast, and dropped Graduation about 6 episodes in. I'd say my different thoughts on the three chalks up to the way the McElroys approached storytelling in the three: Balance was an epic adventure with strong comedy and a focus on the PCs playing off of each other (both in and out of character) that gradually introduced more serious and emotional elements into the narrative. I think Amnesty and Graduation both have them play their characters more "seriously" from the beginning and have many more scenes where the PCs are separated from each other (I remember Amnesty specifically having many individual flashback sequences, and at one point, an actual semi-scripted episode), and I think there were less combat encounters in the latter two as well.

I think whether or not the rest is worth listening for you depends on how much those elements are important to you; for example, a lot of what made me grow attached to Balance's characters was the goofs and the relationships the characters had with each other, and the later introduction of serious elements hit harder because they started settling in after I already found the characters charming in virtue of their humor. As such, Amnesty and Graduation both fell flat for me, with the constant scenes of PCs apart from each other resulting in (IMO) less quality banter and the characters not being charming enough without the focus on comedy to bring me to care about them as much as I did Balance's. To answer your question directly: I personally think that the arcs after Balance live in its shadow, with Balance having the best balance (pun un-intended) between comedy, plot and roleplay. I can see you finding joy in the other arcs, though, depending on what you liked the most about TAZ in the first place.

1
Raspberry_MilkshakeOP•

Honestly that's kinda what I was scared of. I saw the more story focused narrative the other seasons seemed to have and just went "Oh... No." I'm a listener who wants goofs. The growth from Gerblins to the finale feels natural, it's the DND effect. You start off with Monty Python and end with Lord of the Rings.

4
AslandusTheLaster•

I'd still encourage at least giving Amnesty a try, it has a fair amount of goofs sprinkled in even if it's not as front-loaded as Balance. They don't stand out quite as much since the jokes tend to be in-character silliness rather than literal jokes that get picked up as plot points later, but I don't think there's anything the McElroys make that doesn't have at least some humor in it.

That said, Graduation is still pretty early in its run, so it isn't to the point of having big moments like the Crystal Kingdom or Arms Outstretched yet. If you're on the fence then that one's definitely worth sitting on for now.

2