NS Covid-19 cases vs the 10 most affected countries.

NS Covid-19 cases vs the 10 most affected countries.

Posted Mar 27, 2020, 3:31 PM UTC

2134
kenmacdOP•

The majority of replies have taken issue with the scale used here. The scale is the log() of the cases, which is a common way to visualize exponential growth.

This graph is not meant give you a good view of the number of cases in one location version another. It's meant to show the rate of growth between locations.

My goal is not to say "we have a lot of cases", my goal is to convince you that we're currently on the same track as places that have a lot of cases. My goal is for you to understand that the limited number of cases is a good thing, but with exponential growth means growth happens quickly.

We're lucky to be 20-ish days behind other countries, but we can't squander it. There's a delay in the measure we took, so hopefully the slope of this line decreases going forward, but if people don't take things seriously then there's no reason to believe that NS will be spared just because we have fewer cases today.

17
[deleted]•

I don't mind the scale, why not start all the trends from "first recorded infection" though? You could visualize trajectories much easier that way.

7
kenmacdOP•

Part of the reason was that I wanted to show how lucky we are that we have a 20-30 day head start. I was hopeful to convince people that if we take things seriously now that we can start to bend the line and avoid following their same path.

If it helps, here's a chart of the top 10 plus Canada. It's also useful to see that we're on the same trajectory. Even better might be the Our World In Data graph that shows Canada since the 100th case.

5
StrangeForces•

This scale is very misleading. I don’t thing this graph is very useful for visualizing the actual numbers

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
kenmacdOP•

The point is that our growth rate has followed these countries with a lot of deaths. Looking at it as 'we only have X cases', which I'm hearing too often, is scary. On March 1st the US only had our current X cases. Now they have over 80,000 cases and 1,200 deaths.

7
atb678•

I feel like it might be easier to visualize if the horizontal axis started at x number of cases and showed # days from x so we can see the growth from the same start point.

2
kenmacdOP•

That's a good idea. The only graphs I could find that do that align by the 100th case. Here's the graph of the top-10 plus Canada.

Part of what I was trying to convey in the initial chart was how lucky we are that we get to see what happened other places and try to make changes.

You can play with creating your own at this site

3
x_eleven_x•

It's like comparing a city burning with a village burning, they're still both on fire except it's your village. The curve they're trying to flatten here is following the rest of the world. There's no comparison there's only scientific evidence.

4
kenmacdOP•

The scale is the log of the cases. This is the easiest way to view something that spreads exponentially like this. Graphing this linearly isn't useful. That's what people are looking at too often. "There's only X cases here". Looking at it like that is the problem.

On March 1st the US had the same number of cases as NS has today. Today they have over 83,000 cases.

I'm sorry, but your comment is exactly why I'm posting this graph. I implore you to do some research in to exponential growth and why using a logarithmic scale makes sense.

3
StrangeForces•

I understand what your trying to do but it’s kind of apples to oranges. Different areas with large differences in population and government response

3
kenmacdOP•

Different areas with large differences in population and government response

Sure, they started earlier so the response was delayed. We're 20-30 days behind. We have the chance to flatten our curve now.

Maybe it's just me, but I've personally heard far too many people talk about the low number of cases as if we're doing well. The data so far does not reflect that. Yes there's a time-delay on actions taken, so perhaps it will in the coming weeks, but so far our growth rate has been following their growth rate.

People don't see to be taking things seriously. I posted this chart to show where we'll end up if we ignore the rules, if we have people that should be self-isolating going out in communities.

The replies on this thread complaining about the scale is exactly the problem. Human's are not good at exponential growth.

0†
StrangeForces•

I understand your concern but I don’t think the US is a very apt comparison in this case

4
cjbmcdon•

How about graphing it per capita? And if possible, in “days since first (or 10th or 50th) case”, rather than date?

You mention doing it to show the shape of the curve, rather than the magnitude. Fair enough, perhaps using the above suggestions may alleviate the people’s concerns with the log scale (which I share).

2
kenmacdOP•

How about graphing it per capita?

It wouldn't really accomplish what I was trying to convey. I'm not trying to say anything about how many cases we have here. People looking at the number of cases is what I consider the issue. Some people are looking at the number of cases and going 'we don't have many' (in total, per capita, it doesn't matter), this is all overblown and I'm going to keep doing what I'm doing.

The number of cases doesn't matter, the growth rate does. We don't have to find a state or country with a similar population and land-mass to NS for a comparison to be useful, all we have to do is say 'are we growing at the same rate'.

And if possible, in “days since first (or 10th or 50th) case”, rather than date?

That's useful to see, but what I was hoping to show was the we're very lucky in that we have that time between our line and their line. That's time we can use to flatten things out.

Our World in Data has that chart for all of Canada.

concerns with the log scale (which I share)

Please share your concerns about why you don't like the log scale. I'm comfortable with it and didn't realize so many people would take issue.

Would you be willing to watch at least the first 4 minutes of this video and tell me if you still have the same concerns?

2
cjbmcdon•

Thanks for the above links, and to the tool you used to create the chart ( https://mackuba.eu/corona/) you mentioned elsewhere. I did watch the video you linked, and noticed that presenter doesn't use log scales in their charts, but I digress. That probably wasn't your point.

I understand that using log scale is better for visualizing this exponential growth, but when your audience doesn't understand it (or get it at a quick glance, which is all many of us have time for these days), you're not really accomplishing what you're trying to do. From your response to other folks, I have a feeling we would agree on most things to do with this outbreak, and probably on the best way to deal with it. However, presenting a graph, initially with no explanation of the scale or what you were trying to accomplish, probably isn't the best way to go to warn people: it may be low now, but if we don't continue to be vigilant, it can easily run out of control, overwhelming our healthcare system.

Stay safe!

2
kenmacdOP•

but when your audience doesn't understand it (or get it at a quick glance, which is all many of us have time for these days), you're not really accomplishing what you're trying to do.

I agree. I've been looking at log graphs so often lately I didn't realize that other people might not have. I also did a shit job with the title because I mentioned cases where I wanted to discuss growth rate. (At least I got the right 'affected')

I also probably should have done a text post with a explanation and the graph linked inside that.

Oh well, you live you learn. I'm just hopeful a few people read the comments and took away at least part of what I was hoping to convey.

Stay safe!

You too! Thanks for the feedback.

2
cjbmcdon•

No problem at all, and thanks! And thanks again for the link to the tool you used, lots of insights to be seen there. Hoping we're more like Norway than the US in how things play out!

2
SunMcLob•

Would be nice for there to be a graph comparing all provinces and territories to one-another from when they've recorded their first official case. Would also be nice to have a chronological list of preventative measures stated by the Feds or Province, so we can graphically represent if the new measures actually work. I might try to create one...gotta do something in my house to pass the time lol

​

Thanks for the post. I love graphs

2
kenmacdOP•

I'd be really interested to see anything you create.

Here's one of every province. I've found some that align things by the 100th case, but not by the first.

The main thing I was trying to convince people was not to look at is as "well, it's not like we're Quebec", because as the growth rate currently stands we would get there soon enough.

(Of course here's hoping the enacted measures help going forward)

1
yaksbeard•

i hate this

1
rockpilemike•

US has steepest line at the moment eh

1
kenmacdOP•

Of the big-10. I think, for example, Turkey has a steeper line, but they're only at 4k cases atm. Then there's also the problem of less testing means less confirmed cases so there could be other 'less concerned' or poorer nations that are actually growing faster.

The US is at least still okay for now on a per-capita basis (sort this by cases per 1m pop). They're not doing well on a testing per-capita basis though, or at least weren't as of a week ago.

Here's hoping that their measures start working and they can bend that soon.

1
CallmeCli3nt•

This is a single province compared to a country. This comparison is not helpful, atleast to me.

1
kenmacdOP•

It shouldn't matter because it's not a comparison of absolute cases, it's a comparison of growth rate. Look at it as being a fractal, it looks the same zoomed in as zoomed out.

1
[deleted]•

These charts are good and all, but they should only be taken with a grain of salt. The number of tests done per capita is a good normalizer but it then needs to be adjusted by the r0 rate locally. Nova Scotia will obviously have a lower r0 than some of the places with a lot of deaths because we implemented the stay at home measures way earlier.

The thing is, the virus can take up to 14 days to start showing symptoms and you're contagious the whole time (we think at least) so the cases we are seeing now are cases that almost all would have been transmitted before the stay at home measures went into affect.

We'll start seeing those results in the coming weeks.

The moment we let up the stay at home restrictions, boom, the cases blow up again until a certain percentage of our population has already had it, and the virus can't find enough suitable hosts and the r0 locally goes down.

I'm not super educated in this and don't claim to be but this is what I've been able to gather.

Tl;Dr

The cases you see now are all from before the stay at home order. We 100% have community spread and we're not testing those people yet so the numbers are going to jump every now and then because they don't fit our data set. Once we expand testing this is irrelevant. Our situation is orders of magnitude better than other places but if we don't keep it up we'll lose that. Watch numbers for the next few weeks.

It'll be a shitty summer, with no public camping, beaches or trips, but we won't be Madrid.

1
kenmacdOP•

The number of tests done per capita is a good normalizer

I see lots of people talking about tests per capita, but I don't understand why anyone cares. If you suddenly test twice as many negative people I can't see how it affects anything.

Like I get that it's a good metric to understand how places are doing in their work to combat it. Or to understand if there might be unknown cases due to under-testing, but above that I don't see the point.

Nova Scotia will obviously have a lower r0 than some of the places with a lot of deaths because we implemented the stay at home measures way earlier.

Maybe. I mean I certainly hope so, but lots of people still aren't taking things seriously. China allowed 1 member of a household to leave every 3 days to get food. We're still allowing 100 people in an average grocery store.

I hope you're right, but if too many people think that's true then it won't happen. As of now we're not on a better path, we're on the same path.

can take up to 14 days

Around 5 days is much more common. The issue with the current cases is that it's hard to distinguish spread from imported cases.

The moment we let up the stay at home restrictions, boom, the cases blow up again until a certain percentage of our population has already had it, and the virus can't find enough suitable hosts and the r0 locally goes down.

That's no the only way out of this. Provided we keep the growth rate to 1 or below then the number of infected people won't grow. We don't know exactly now much we have to do to get there. It's possible that we could end up removing stay-at-home but massively expand testing and get a better result.

1
bromacplays•

This scale is misleading

0†
kenmacdOP•

No it's not. This is a logarithmic scale. This is exactly how to best view things that grow exponentially.

The idea that things are okay because on a linear scale we are low is exactly the issue I'm trying to address.

3
StandingTheGaff•

You're certainly right to show the data with the log scale and you're using it to make an important point. However, from people's responses, it looks like they'd benefit from stronger labelling on the vertical axis - maybe a big "log scale", each order of magnitude bolded, etc. Whatever would be helpful to avoid the distraction they experienced here.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
LordGarak•

About the only thing that it shows that we are on the same bell curve.

You pretty much get that curve no matter what with this kind of thing.

Cases per-captia, death count and clear evidence of local spread is much more relevant.

The real data is in the death count but even that data can be deceptive. Most places are not testing the dead to confirm that COVID was the cause/factor. Some are labeling nearly all deaths as COVID while others(the US) are not counting the deaths of people with other known illness like cancer.

The real impact will only come out when annual death stats come out showing an increase in all forms of death aligning with the COVID outbreak.

I'm still optimistic that the measures we have in place were early enough and enough people are following them to snuff COVID out in NS.

0
kenmacdOP•

About the only thing that it shows that we are on the same bell curve.

It shows that we're following the same growth rate. You don't actually get that curve no matter what. Look at the difference between South Korea and the US in this graph.

It shows how important it is that we take the measures we're taking, even though our per-capita or absolute cases are low.

Cases per-captia, death count and clear evidence of local spread is much more relevant.

I completely disagree. If you pay attention to those numbers then they're low, low, low, extreme. That's the issue. Some people are paying attention to the death count and deciding the response doesn't make sense.

If we were to continue along the path we've been on then there will only be 1500 cases in 10 days, but there would be 30k cases in 20 days, and 600k in 30 days.

I'm still optimistic that the measures we have in place were early enough and enough people are following them to snuff COVID out in NS.

I am too, and that's why I posted this chart. We are extremely lucky in that room between the start of the other lines, and the start of our line.

You and I are taking the measures seriously, but I'm hearing from far too many people that aren't. I'm hopeful we see this growth-rate graph flatten over the coming weeks, but I'm worried that people looking only at the per-capita numbers will prevent this from happening.

1
coffeecoffeenownow•

POS chart.. Fear monger or just an idiot

-3
kenmacdOP•

No, it's a very good chart. It shows our growth rate isn't lower than other locations. It shows how our "only X cases" is the path seen by other countries just a short period ago.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
kenmacdOP•

well then hopefully they read the comments, learn about exponential growth, and then understand the chart.

If you have a better chart that will be understood and help show the insignificance of our 'small number of cases' then I hope you'll post that too.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0