Companions in guilt is still wrong.
So, a while back I created a post relating to how the companions in guilt argument was invalid.
The responses that followed seemed to not understand how it's reliant on the principle of bivalence which can't be applied because of the vagueness baked into morality. We don't have a unit of love, we don't have a unit of justice and science has demonstrated that certain things like love and hate are linked. If we take these states where does love end and hate begin? That's an example of vagueness.
Belief is an abstract as is epistemology. This makes them vulnerable to vagueness as well for those reason.
So, if you'd like to challenge me on this, I'm going to be hanging out, on Destiny's discord and we can have a conversation about it because either people on this reddit suffer from illiteracy when it comes to understanding the argument I'm presenting and/or I'm just not communicating it effectively. I'm highly skeptical it's the latter though.
Edit: Waited for about an hour and something came up. In any event, standing offer to philosophybros.
Posted Mar 29, 2020, 10:20 PM UTC · edited
In case anyone is interested, here is a really good (and really long) video on the companions in guilt argument as well as various arguments against it: https://youtu.be/7HHBNU_gXP0