Concerning amatuer short story collections

Would it be bad to write a collection of short stories without having any previous novels or stories published? I'm not very familiar with the publication process and it would be amazing if I completed the whole thing, let alone start submitting it to agents in the future.

That being said, I wasn't sure if it would be ill embraced by publishers because I have no renown and a short story collection might require that to be successful. I just didn't know if anyone would have some wisdom on the subject, thanks.

Posted Mar 30, 2020, 7:12 PM UTC

26
justgoodenough•

You can establish your writing career with short stories, but you publish them individually in literary journals and magazines first. You don't get a traditionally published collection before you have had success with individual stories.

4
EwokPiss•

Short stories are often a gateway to writing more/full time. However, they are an art in their own right different from novels. Generally speaking, what you want to do is write several short stories (10, perhaps) and begin sending then to the 100+ literary magazines out there. Then, when those have been published, you can begin approaching agents or publishers to get a collection published. Ultimately its very difficult to make any money at writing short stories n even for masters. But they can help prepare you for a life of writing.

3
ThatWolfWriterPublished Author•

Short story collections by unknown authors are a notoriously hard sell. Even short story collections by well-known authors don't do as well as their novels. This is just a fact of the market.

Write your shorts, if that's where your heart lies. I'm a short story writer; they picked me, not the other way around. I've had forty-something of them published in various places. It nets me (mostly) beer money. But I would not have what career I've managed to scramble out for myself without them.

Look for markets on the Submission Grinder. Start at the top-paying and work your way down. That collection can happen, but you have to do a lot of groundwork first.

2
neotropic9•

Write short stories because they are good practice. Then create a collection after you have sold a few.

Short stories are a really good way to practice basic narrative structure. And you will also develop other writing skills. In fact you will pick up basically all the skills you need to write novels from practicing in the short story medium (with a couple exceptions, like pacing for novels, longer arcs, and side-plots).

Sell them to magazines or anthologies first, and then sell them on KDP later after the exclusivity expires (usually 6 months to a year). Not only do you get paid twice, but the initial acceptance acts as a quality control, and you will get free edits on top. You also get to say something in your product description like, "first published in X, it is now available as a standalone short story". Don't bother trying to traditionally publish a short story collection as a debut author; your chances of selling it are nil. Go with self-publishing for short stories. You can either release them individually at a .99 price point, or as a collection. Just be forewarned that you won't sell many.

Here is a guide to short story submissions: https://davidfshultz.com/2018/02/04/guide-to-submissions-short-fiction-and-poetry/

Good luck!

2
TriggerYappyOP•

Thanks for the advice!

2
Terrimeth•

A lot of my professors started their publication journey with short story collections. That's all a lot of authors write too. I don't see it being an issue at all! Best of luck :)

1