r/thinkpad•
y2jer

New thinkpad T490 | a super happy noob with some questions

Discussion / Information

Hey guys, Finally I pulled the trigger on a thinkpad T490 (i5 8265U | 8GB RAM | 256GB SSD | under warranty 3 years onsite support). I am based out of Netherlands BTW.

After using dell inspiron for 2.5 years (i7 7th gen, 16GB ram and 512GB SSD), I finally got the Thinkpad after lurking so long around here.

Typing is such a breeze on this, I used to think that the fans were really exaggerating about it. I am happy to be so wrong!!

I got few questions:

  1. Can I upgrade RAM and SSD by myself (32 GB RAM on the free slot and 1TB SSD), this configuration would be optimum?
  2. I am a programmer, so wondering if to upgrade free slot to 16GB or 32GB to make it future proof.
  3. Is crucial website good ( https://eu.crucial.com/compatible-upgrade-for/lenovo/thinkpad-t490 ) or you guys would recommend something else?
  4. How is the Accidental damage on Lenovo, is it worth the money? (150 euros for 3 years or 318 for 5 years).

I cannot explain on how happy I am with my new computer. Thank you guys for all your help so far.

Posted Apr 1, 2020, 2:32 PM UTC

518
jonjennings•

Hi there! Another T490-equipped programmer here. I went for the i5 16GB 1440p.

  1. Yes you can upgrade both of those. I put a 32GB SODIMM and a 1TB SSD in mine. 48GB of RAM is rather over the top for me but it's nice to know I'll never have to worry about RAM (haha - check in with me in 5 years time!)

  2. I say go for the 32GB. Especially as you've only got 8GB on the system board... if you're thinking of holding onto this for 3-5 years then I can foresee a time when you'd regret it if you only had 24GB and you'd have to throw away the 16GB to upgrade. It depends what type of programming you're doing I think. I'm building websites so not doing much compiling but I DO need to run several virtual machines and they eat up 2-3GB each. Plus hundreds of Chrome tabs lol... that soaks up every GB I throw at it!

  3. I bought Crucial RAM... but I bought it via Amazon. I've used their RAM and SSDs before and never had any problems.

  4. I can't comment on this. I bought the onsite extended warranty but skipped the accidental coverage.

PS One thing that made me make the T490 decision over a T490s or X1C7 was the user-replaceable keyboard. I find programmers are tough on keyboards and the keyboard on my last laptop (Asus UX32VD) didn't survive well. You can buy replacement T490 keyboards on Ebay for about $40 and fit them in 5 minutes. I've done that myself already - bought a non-backlit T490 because it was available off-the-shelf and ordered a backlit keyboard separately. It turned out the trackpoint on my original keyboard was faulty so this change fixed that too. I think I'm going to be keeping this laptop for a long time!

5
y2jerOPT490•

Great my friend thank you for the insights. this is a relief and sounds like I/we made a right decision. :)

I was confused between this and x1 carbon but it was bit out of budget and not user upgradable. :-/

Thanks for your time and patience for writing an extensive answer. I am a jack of all mainly working on Salesforce CRM and front end, I fail hard to learn different programming languages but I keep trying. :)

​

Plus hundreds of Chrome tabs lol

haha I feel you

It turned out the trackpoint on my original keyboard was faulty so this change fixed that too.

Killing 2 birds with singlt shot, amazing!

I think I'm going to be keeping this laptop for a long time!

I too think the same, good luck to both of us! :)

1
jonjennings•

Happy to help. A couple more notes:

For me, comparing it against the T490s & X1C7, I realized my laptop spends 95% of its time either on my home office desk or the living room coffee table and will leave the house (and hence need to be portable) about 3-4 times a year max. So the sacrifices required for a little less weight weren't worth it for me. I valued memory and user-replaceable keyboard more.

Battery life isn't great (max 4hrs in Ubuntu) but the 1440p screen is SO BRIGHT that I'm running it below 1/4 brightness most of the time. I bought the Lenovo 14000mAh USB-C battery pack in case I find myself out and away from a power socket. In theory that should almost double battery life but have only had to use it once so far.

Re tabs: Ubuntu has a lovely multi-workspace feature so I'm often running with 4-5 workspaces... each workspace containing at least one Chrome window with a dozen tabs in each and probably virtual machines on half those workspaces as well. I think max memory in use has been about 20GB but then my desktop machine has 24GB and is constantly maxed out... so I'm obviously not trying hard enough on the Thinkpad.

Re keyboard: I've not really got comfortable with using the trackpoint so, even though its trackpoint is faulty, I've kinda got an emergency spare keyboard in the drawer now. Handy to have!

As others have hinted, be careful taking the base off. It's held on with half a dozen plastic clips and it feels rather more fragile than I would have expected both coming off and going back on. A guitar pick or one of those plastic pry tools they use for smartphone maintenance would be very helpful. Another reason to go for 32GB and a big SSD in one go... take the base off once and never again!

The Asus lasted me 7 years... although the last 2yrs it didn't get much use (thanks to the misbehaving keyboard and a Chromebook bought to tide me over for light work). I'm expecting the same 5-7 out of the Thinkpad and so far it feels like that won't be a challenge for it.

Problems: only two that I can think of so far and they're both Linux-specific I think:

  1. I had to disable the built-in Nvidia GPU in order to get it to reliably suspend/resume. Not a great problem... I don't need any graphics performance

  2. very rarely (maybe twice in 4 months) the wifi hasn't worked after waking-up and I've had to resort to a reboot. Rather annoying given the 100 tabs mentioned earlier :)

2
y2jerOPT490•

Great, I'm gonna buy the RAM and SSD today, thanks for additional thoughts mate! The function and control key on the left are in weird position, wished they were swapped.

1
jonjennings•

There's a setting in the BIOS where you can swap them over. I'm not risking trying to swap the keytops themselves but it's definitely helpful having their functionally reversed.

2
mhhkb•

Crucial is a great memory maker. I buy exclusively from them.

3
y2jerOPT490•

Thanks mate, I will buy it!

1
bettlebroxT400 T490•

I just got a T490 about 3 weeks ago! I upgraded the free RAM slot with a 32GB for RAM, I got OLOy DDR4 RAM 32GB for $114 USD at amazon.com and that worked fine for the past two weeks.

I plan to install a 2TB Intel 665p NVME from Newegg.com for $224 which was on sale. I haven't installed the NVME yet as I've trying to figure out the best way to clone Windows to the new drive and then I'll dual-boot Debian & Windows. I've done this before but remember it was a hassle and taking the back off the T490 requires a lot of care.

Here's the disk:

Intel 665p Series M.2 2280 2TB PCIe NVMe 3.0 x4 3D3, QLC Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) SSDPEKNW020T9X1

Here's the RAM:

OLOy DDR4 RAM 32GB (1x32GB) 2400 MHz CL17 1.2V 260-Pin Laptop SODIMM Upgrade for 2017 iMac 27-inch with Retina 5K Display (MD4S322417MZSC)

One big thing to remember about the SSD, it must be single-sided as it appears that a double-sided SSD won't fit properly without having to slightly bend it. Also, many of the double-sided can run hot and may not be designed for laptops.

Also, make sure its a "M.2 2280 PCIe NVMe 3.0" form factor. I'll post what I did once I installed the SSD/NVME.

These videos will help:

https://support.lenovo.com/us/en/solutions/ht508135

Make sure to disable the batter before you remove the back cover.

PS: Crucial makes good RAM, it just costs more.

3
jonjennings•

I've trying to figure out the best way to clone Windows to the new drive and then I'll dual-boot Debian & Windows.

I did a SSD upgrade on my T490 so I could dual-boot Ubuntu & Windows. It wasn't as scary as last time I tried to do it. I should have taken better notes though lol

I think I used a 32GB USB stick to make a Windows recovery drive. Then swapped the SSDs over. Then used the USB stick to reinstall Windows onto the fresh SSD, then let Windows run all its updates (and update the Thinkpad firmware at the same time - you need to fix the Thunderbolt firmware bug), then resized the Windows partition down to leave space. Then booted off an Ubuntu live USB stick and installed that to the new space. At this point you can experiment - it doesn't matter if you break anything because you've still got a Windows recovery image on the 1st USB stick (and if the worst comes to the worst, the original SSD is untouched with Windows on it)

The news to me was that Windows no longer worries about licence keys. Apparently they're burnt into the Thinkpad ROM.

3
bettlebroxT400 T490•

Thanks for that! That's pretty much what I ended up doing today. First I tried Clonezilla and it failed to write the image to the new disk. I'm thinking some Windows encryption caused the problem. On my 2nd try, I used the Windows Recovery Drive to fix it.

Next thing to do is to install Debian over the weekend.

2
y2jerOPT490•

Hows your experience with Ubuntu and Windows, if I may ask which one you like most? I would want to have same configuration as well. In previous post you mentioned about multiple workspaces, I need to look into that, sounds like that could increase productivity.

1
jonjennings•

I was a Windows user from Windows 3 (actually Windows 1... but it was just a toy then) all the way to Vista but have been a full-time Ubuntu user since 6.06.

I used to know Windows inside-and-out but now feel totally lost in there lol. I'd tried various Linux distributions before Ubuntu but the community and the software weren't really mature enough to make it a simple task. Fine if you're excited by tweaking system settings in config files to make anything work but not really suitable for getting actual work done.

All Linux, even the user-friendly distributions like Ubuntu, still requires a lot more command line work than Windows. If you're not used to it then it's definitely a big learning curve. But the resources out there are excellent and Google will easily find you a solution for most things.

So I can't really answer the first question - I'm 100% Ubuntu all the way. The only reason I kept Windows was because I've apparently been made to pay for a licence so I might as well keep it... plus I've got some Steam games I've accumulated over the years that are Windows-only... might actually get a chance to play them now (although Steam's Photon library apparently does a pretty good job of supporting Windows games inside Linux)

I will say, I think you really need to make a 100% leap in order to get comfortable. I had Ubuntu on a 2nd machine on my desk for a couple of years, just playing with it. I wouldn't say that was a bad thing but I never really got comfortable because I didn't have to. It was only when I switched to using that machine as my main machine, email & all, that I had to solve my config & productivity issues and really get setup on it.

Most developer-related software exists cross-platform. I'm using atom as a code editor, GitKraken for git, Virtualbox for cross-platform testing, Local for local website development, FileZilla, Slack etc.

Now that Ubuntu uses Gnome 3 as its desktop environment you get all the benefits of that, including workspaces - here's a video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bRHAio98n-g

I see that Windows now has something similar but it's been a core part of how I work in single-screen Linux since I started - invaluable on a laptop. For actual debugging it's hard to beat visible pixels... you need to keep a browser, a debug/inspection window and a code editor in view at the same time - but it's nice to have other windows, email, other projects etc moved out of the way.

2
bettlebroxT400 T490•

I realised I didn't directly answer youR questions:

  1. Can I upgrade RAM and SSD by myself (32 GB RAM on the free slot and 1TB SSD), this configuration would be optimum?

Yes, it's not too hard, the trickiest part is removing the back panel. Make sure to disable the battery in the BIOS first, then see the link to the videos that I posted above. Lenovo put together this nice video and this video.

  1. I am a programmer, so wondering if to upgrade free slot to 16GB or 32GB to make it future proof.

I guess it depends on what type of programing you do, but I suggest getting 32GB, RAM will almost always get used. I plan to run VM's, docker containers, and other stuff, more RAM is almost always good! :)

  1. Is crucial website good ( https://eu.crucial.com/compatible-upgrade-for/lenovo/thinkpad-t490 ) or you guys would recommend something else?

Crucial makes great RAM, I got OLOy RAM as I was trying to save money.

1
y2jerOPT490•

Great my friend, thanks for your patience and time to answer the questions. It made me quite of relief, will order the RAM/SSD from crucial soon. :)

And really appreciate the link of videos you shared they look easy and doable, 2TB SSD you got is indeed a great deal.

​

Make sure to disable the battery in the BIOS first

Awesome tip!

2

Download the maintenance manual from the Lenovo support web site. It will have complete instructions on how to change various parts.

2
y2jerOPT490•

That sounds a good advice thanks!

1