Buildings with high social value but low economic value
Hi! Learning about LVT and curious as to what people think about buildings/land that help society but don't generate a lot of money.
For example, historic buildings like Grand Central Terminal, icons like the Space Needle, museums, public greenspace owned by private companies, universities, etc. All these things definitely raise land values around them and create massive benefits to the city, but not economic benefits to themselves.
I worry that a LVT world would incentivize the destruction of these places despite them benefiting the cities they're in. New York would not be the same without Grand Central and Seattle without the Space Needle. From a government point of view, destroying these buildings would also lower land values around them, reducing revenue. Not to mention the reduction in tourism.
For a university, many are privately owned and their campuses de facto parks open to the public. Additionally, they generate a lot of economic development to the surrounding area, despite not reaping all the benefits of that development themselves.
Posted Apr 2, 2020, 4:32 PM UTC
land that is for the public use is generally exempt from LVT proposals. This usually includes public open space, schools, and similar services.
To add to this the goal of LVT is to eliminate rent-seeking or landowners extracting money beyond the cost of upkeep of the land use. LVT in theory should match the rent available on land and move that money from the landowner to the public/government. Basically by definition, if a landowner is putting their land into use for the public good below market value they are forgoing rent-seeking on that land which is why that land is exempt from the tax.
We should bear in mind the government doesn't represent all citizens. It's an involuntary and coercive institution that claims control over landed resources
So how do you decide what is exempt? The Space Needle is privately owned, Grand Central was until this year. Additionally, some neighborhoods are just plain old historic. It's really nice to have cute townhomes in Manhattan, but they would surely be gone with this, no?
Its tax code for sure so understandably it's a political process to figure out how that works. As so few places actually use an LVT and I'm not sure anyone uses it as a single tax there's not a clear answer to that.
However I would counter as a hub Grand Central likely generates a lot of revenue via fares and rent of shops etc in the station. Historical neighborhoods often have increased demand and thus increased land value by their very nature. The Space Needle sells tickets and sits one larger piece of land with museums, galleries, gardens, and stadiums. For that matter Grand Central effectively sits below the Metlife building and Penn station is under MSG. Even w/o LVT these owners have found ways to maximize the use of their land as land in a place like Manhatten is highly valuable.
In a rather famous Supreme Court case, NYC blocked the owners of grand central from tearing it down because the owners would make more money with it as an office tower on top, similar to penn station. LVT would have made their financial situation worse.
That move would have raised revenues for the owners of grand central, but would have lowered land values around it and lowered societal value in New York.
Why would land values lower? There is the option for endowed social organizations to buy up historic properties to preserve them. Alternatively a large percentage of the local population can forego their citizens dividend for a particular location effectively making the lvt free