Buildings with high social value but low economic value

Hi! Learning about LVT and curious as to what people think about buildings/land that help society but don't generate a lot of money.

For example, historic buildings like Grand Central Terminal, icons like the Space Needle, museums, public greenspace owned by private companies, universities, etc. All these things definitely raise land values around them and create massive benefits to the city, but not economic benefits to themselves.

I worry that a LVT world would incentivize the destruction of these places despite them benefiting the cities they're in. New York would not be the same without Grand Central and Seattle without the Space Needle. From a government point of view, destroying these buildings would also lower land values around them, reducing revenue. Not to mention the reduction in tourism.

For a university, many are privately owned and their campuses de facto parks open to the public. Additionally, they generate a lot of economic development to the surrounding area, despite not reaping all the benefits of that development themselves.

Posted Apr 2, 2020, 4:32 PM UTC

2036
DesertRose922•

land that is for the public use is generally exempt from LVT proposals. This usually includes public open space, schools, and similar services.

14
DesertRose922•

To add to this the goal of LVT is to eliminate rent-seeking or landowners extracting money beyond the cost of upkeep of the land use. LVT in theory should match the rent available on land and move that money from the landowner to the public/government. Basically by definition, if a landowner is putting their land into use for the public good below market value they are forgoing rent-seeking on that land which is why that land is exempt from the tax.

13
haestrodgeolibertarian•

We should bear in mind the government doesn't represent all citizens. It's an involuntary and coercive institution that claims control over landed resources

-2
TimePromotionOP•

So how do you decide what is exempt? The Space Needle is privately owned, Grand Central was until this year. Additionally, some neighborhoods are just plain old historic. It's really nice to have cute townhomes in Manhattan, but they would surely be gone with this, no?

8
DesertRose922•

Its tax code for sure so understandably it's a political process to figure out how that works. As so few places actually use an LVT and I'm not sure anyone uses it as a single tax there's not a clear answer to that.
However I would counter as a hub Grand Central likely generates a lot of revenue via fares and rent of shops etc in the station. Historical neighborhoods often have increased demand and thus increased land value by their very nature. The Space Needle sells tickets and sits one larger piece of land with museums, galleries, gardens, and stadiums. For that matter Grand Central effectively sits below the Metlife building and Penn station is under MSG. Even w/o LVT these owners have found ways to maximize the use of their land as land in a place like Manhatten is highly valuable.

4
TimePromotionOP•

In a rather famous Supreme Court case, NYC blocked the owners of grand central from tearing it down because the owners would make more money with it as an office tower on top, similar to penn station. LVT would have made their financial situation worse.

That move would have raised revenues for the owners of grand central, but would have lowered land values around it and lowered societal value in New York.

3
haestrodgeolibertarian•

Why would land values lower? There is the option for endowed social organizations to buy up historic properties to preserve them. Alternatively a large percentage of the local population can forego their citizens dividend for a particular location effectively making the lvt free

2
SelectionMechanism•

The answer is not to give anyone any sort of exemption from the LVT. You can’t do that, you open a Pandora’s box that unravels the whole thing. The whole point of the LVT is to subject all land to the market pressure to produce value. The moment you start carving out exemptions you’ll realize everyone everywhere starts finding reasons why their laundromat is a public treasure, why their brownstone is a historic monument, etc

The answer is to:

  1. Find ways to make money from the site (museums, parks, and other similar places already do this).

  2. Setup various charities which will help pay for the tax on historic sites using money that residents donate.

7
TimePromotionOP•

I agree that exemptions are bad. It adds a ton of red tape to get exemptions and can become really arbitrary.

For your answers, use the 1968 Grand Central case: the owners wanted to tear it down and build an office tower because the land is really valuable and wasn't making money. I don't think there was money for a charity to cover the rent and they surely weren't making enough from the building. LVT would have furthered the incentive to redevelop, but would have destroyed a building with very high historical and societal value.

2
SelectionMechanism•

I would advocate for a federal level LVT, but if a city wanted to preserve some building by paying the LVT bill for some historical site, that would be up to them. Cities can certainly collect money from all the residents however they see fit and then use those funds to pay for an LVT for a specific plot of land (like Grand Central example).

This would solve the implicit freeloader problem whereby some city residents pay for the historical site’s tax but all residents get to enjoy the benefits.

In other words, if the historic site is worth value X to each resident of the city, the city would collect X from each resident and funnel that X towards paying for the historic site’s LVT, under the condition that the site is maintained in the preserved state (or for a specific purpose).

I’d still advocate for answer 1 or answer 2 from above as the best ways to deal with the problem, since I don’t like the collectivist politics of having cities make judgements about the value of things... but I know I’m in the minority on this.

2
thundrbbx0geolibertarian•

If private musuems, parks, university's, etc are a net benefit to society and development in the area, LVT doesnt harm any of those incentives. LVT has no impact on supply, demand, price or profit signals, as long as the tax is not higher than the rental.

In terms of government providing public civic works like schools, statues, historic locations etc, the geoist argument is that these things out to be funded by the higher land value they generate in the vicinity. If they are not generating higher land value, then we know people dont find those services desirable, and funding those services would be inefficient.

6
TimePromotionOP•

LVT has no impact on supply, demand, price or profit signals

For the owners of Grand Central in Manhattan, their best economic move is to tear down the building to make it economically more productive because land value is so high.

4
thundrbbx0geolibertarian•

Indeed, for something that might have sentimental value or historic value, etc, those things can be preserved by the local government by democratic choice. I was only saying such things that are being governmentally provided or upkept should be funded through revenue from land rent. From what I'm seeing, the space needle gets millions of visitors and a lot of use. People seem to value it, so it would be raising land value in the area accordingly. If it's not raising land value in the area then it's supposedly not desired by the NY public so then what's the need to keep it around?

We should still try not to carve out too many exceptions.

2
haestrodgeolibertarian•

Not necessarily. Grand central could bring in a lot of income. Local businesses might own it as a coop because of how much more profitable their companies are

0
TimePromotionOP•

I don’t think this would happen. Case study: Penn Station being destroyed.

3
haestrodgeolibertarian•

You are right that Penn Station may be an example of a building of historic significance being torn down when it cannot keep up with demand. To be fair, I am not familiar with the story. However, GCS apparently serves 66 million per year, so social benefit and profit aren't mutually exclusive. Madison Square Garden and Penn Plaza were built in place of Penn Station which might bring in more money and raise land values more than Penn Plaza. I am not sure.

Penn Station may have been a historic site but it was still occupying real estate. Suggesting it should be forcibly kept around and others may not use the site for some other use is rent seeking, even if it feels right.

If there is so much social benefit then the public should have no problem raising enough money to pay for the sites LVT. One factor to consider is the public would largely be paying itself so the burden for maintaining the site is reduced somewhat. This could be said for a number of services which are open to the public/community. Such sites wouldn't have to pay as much LVT because everyone is free to use them. LVT is meant for when some use of some landed resource is rejected, so opening a site for public use reduces how much obligation is actually being created.

Another factor is subjective value. Many people may have felt Penn Station was valuable enough to keep but apparently it wasn't enough. There is also the possibility of moving the structure itself brick by brick which also apparently didn't happen.

If anything Penn Station could be a cautionary tale to make steps to preserve historic sites in any one of the ways mentioned which are sustainable under geoist property norms.

1
green_meklargeolibertarian•

curious as to what people think about buildings/land that help society but don't generate a lot of money.

'Generate money' is pretty misleading here. Money is created by governments and by banks, but the creation of money is not particularly productive, and it's not what we're getting at with the notions of profit and rent.

If a building has enough cultural value that people want to keep it around, then it has enough cultural value that somebody will pay to keep it around, and therefore it has economic value as well. In many cases its presence raises the land value around it, so it may be efficient for the government to subsidize its existence and maintenance with the aim of recouping that cost in LVT revenue. (For instance, people are willing to pay more to live near the Eiffel Tower than in an otherwise equivalent city that lacks the Eiffel Tower or any other interesting landmarks.)

2
TimePromotionOP•

somebody will pay to keep it around.

I don’t think anyone would’ve saved penn station. Tragedy of the commons: not in one persons self interest to pay for it but in everyone’s collective interest to keep it around.

1
green_meklargeolibertarian•

Like I say, if it's in everyone's interest, then it tends to be something that increases land value, so the government would have an incentive to ensure that it's preserved. Or people could get together and crowdfund its preservation. (I mean, government is basically a giant crowdfunding scheme anyway.)

1
EvidenceBasedOnly•

Truly publicly owned land like national parks should be exempt.

If it's privately owned then there is already an opportunity cost for keeping it as is, so quite likely an LVT wouldn't change the equation.

If it did for whatever reason and the private organization wanted to take it down, but the community didn't want that to happen. Then the voters/politicians would work out a contract with the private organization for direct payment to keep the building up to offset the land value tax.

I think it's best to have direct payment rather than waiving the LVT to minimize distortionary effects. The company should be paid in proportion to how much the public benefits from the building, not in proportion to how much the land underneath it is worth.

1
ben-jai•

In order best allocate resources, thus maximising the aggregated rental value of land, we give permissions regarding what does and doesn't get developed. The rental value, thus the tax upon it, depends on best use within those permissions. So if developmental permission for Grand Central Terminal is only for a rail terminus, the tax will be based on that and nothing else.

So don;t worry.

1
Ecredes•

Zoning would take care of most the issues that might arise related to this. Zoning of historic districts for example are subject to entirely different market forces in terms of development, yet could still be subject to an LVT.

Monuments could also be legally protected from demolition, as a result the ground rents under these monuments would naturally be lower.

Zoning for parks and open space strictly take land out of the development market except for things that they're zoned for.

Generally, when you slap zoning requirements on certain plots of land, the rent associated with that land changes accordingly and therefore the LVT is still not a problem.

0
SelectionMechanism•

This is not a good idea...

Say you own a golf course, a car dealership, or some other type of business that is generally found in areas with high land value - but where the business itself is low productivity / acre.

Suddenly, an LVT is passed. You realize you're going to have to pay a lot for your high-value-low-productivity land.

The answer? Go to the zoning commission and have them "zone your land" as "Golf Course" or "Car Dealership" or similar equivalents. Afterwards, do what you can to make it virtually impossible to re-zone the land again by creating huge amounts of red tape, regulation, and bureaucracy around the process once you're done. This should involve stories about how your car dealership / golf course / brownstone / whatever is of great social, aesthetic, or historical value to the community.

Congratulations, you've managed to keep the land away from a higher-valued use by forcefully zoning it into a lower-valued use and making it very hard to change the new status quo. The land-value remains low, since it can't really be used more effectively once it's been zoned and entrenched, so your LVT remains low. You're effectively enriching yourself at the expense of your neighbors and society as a whole.

This is what the LVT is meant to address, and why zoning is a bad idea. In fact, we may want to have the LVT be calculated from a zoning-neutral perspective.

3
Ecredes•

I agree that zoning requirements are only as good as the entities and processes that create and enforce them for the good of the community as a whole.

In a corrupt system like you described zoning requirements are not serving the greater economic and social interests of the community.

1
SelectionMechanism•

The areas where LVT would be most valuable in addressing broken land-use patterns (San Francisco Bay Area, NYC, LA, etc) are also the ones with the most broken/corrupt zoning environments. This is why a zoning-neutral LVT is important (then have other mechanisms whereby residents can funnel money towards covering the cost of an actual historic site's LVT).

1
Ecredes•

I agree, in an ideological sense. In reality, I dont think it's feasible to do away with all zoning requirements in the current system. It's more realistic to make the system less corrupt and work LVT into a system with zoning reqs.

1
TimePromotionOP•

Zoning would take care of most the issues

How do you justify that? Charge people high taxes because their land is valuable then stop them from making it productive. Wouldn't that just raise rents here and make it even harder to afford historic neighborhoods?

2
Ecredes•

When buying land that is zoned a certain way, the people buying into that know the ramifications of the zoning requirements, and the market price is reflected appropriately.

Since historic districts are fairly limited, it's always going to be expensive to afford them, (they're a high demand location), people should have to pay high rent back to society for the protected historic status of their homes/neighborhoods. This would ensure that the entire community benefits from the value of historic neighborhoods, not just those who happen to own a home in them.

1
bloouupgeosocialist•

LVT is only for land that is being hoarded by private interests who seek to profit at the expense of the community that surrounds the land (unearned increment). There is no reason to collect LVT on land that is expressly being used solely to benefit the public already.

Also, private universities are not "privately owned". Some are (pretty much only scam colleges are though lmao), but if they are a nonprofit institution, like most are, then they aren't "owned" by anyone at all. They are only "private" in the sense of "not state run" but they are not "private" in the sense of "private property", and as such should be exempted from things like LVT.

-1
Ecredes•

I disagree on private universities being exempt. Most of these universities have major land endowments that they collect massive amounts of economic rents and from. Keeping them subject to LVT ensures efficient use of the land resources in college towns. Otherwise you have massive university sprawl.

3
bloouupgeosocialist•

Well, yeah, but part of the whole point of an LVT in the first place is so there could be no such thing as land endowments. I just meant that a university should not have to pay tax on the land its campus resides on.

1
Ecredes•

Why should they be exempt? There's too many distortionary effects by exempting land use such as universities that generate revenue.

3
bloouupgeosocialist•

I think I've changed my mind.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
2ndbestsnever•

this is a good reason to charge the same amount of tax for each acre, no matter what the value of the land is.

​

you're meat and produce now cost 10 times as much. this is how land tax should work. too much room for corruption if you go off the actual value of the land.

-1