MTGA deck vs HS deck

Battle

A standard HS deck vs a standard MTG deck.

​

HS minions can choose who to attack and the sequence of attacks. MTG creatures can block if the attack is against the player or a planeswalker.

HS minions do not heal, while MTG's do. If a HS minion has taunt, MTG will have to assign enough damage to kill it before attacking face.

HS starts with 30 health, MTG with 20. HS does not have a max minion limit. If second, HS gets both the card and the coin, while mtg only the card.

​

weapons are considered artifacts. cards that affect weapons, affect artifacts or planeswalkers.

​

secrets are considered enchantments.

No milling strategies. ONLY STANDARD! Obviously a modern magic deck would wreck everything.

Posted Apr 2, 2020, 9:17 PM UTC

25
Chijinda•

Magic has considerably more busted cards than Hearthstone and removal is much easier and cheaper in MTG. It's been awhile since I played, but last I did, Hearthstone also has no way of interacting with enchantments or artifacts either.

​

As long as the MTG player doesn't get mana screwed they should be able to take HS pretty effectively. Mono green and burn might lose to HS, but otherwise most other standard decks should pick HS apart.

3
FallenJkillerOP•

as i said in the OP, cards that affect weapons, will affect planeswalkers or artifacts.
weapons and artifacts will be the same kind of permanent.

Also, HS has some very strong advantages. 10 more hp, and no lands means that every card has value. Top decking will always favor HS. There wont be any dead rounds, because heroes have abilities.

Comparing the two aggro decks, RDW and Face hunter, we can see face hunter has better minions.
blazing battlemage is a 2/2 for 1, MTG has no such creatures. Dwarven sharpshooter would stone wall early aggression from RDW.

1
Chijinda•

Also, HS has some very strong advantages. 10 more hp

Largely irrelevant to control decks, very problematic to red burn decks, which is why I pointed out red will have trouble. UBW will not have that difficulty, as by the time one of those decks arranged a board-winning gamestate, 10 life does not make a huge difference. MTG also has better token mechanics, which means that they can continually wall Hearthstone from going face. If you wanted to run face hunter against a white weenie lifegain deck, then good luck. (Actually I'd argue MTG has an advantage in Life as MTG you can go above your starting life, while in Hearthstone you cannot, outside of armor, and a small handful of cards that raise your life total to a static number).

and no lands means that every card has value

Yes, but as long as the MTG player doesn't get mana screwed/flooded they will still have an advantage, as MTG has redundancy-- iirc, Hearthstone you can only have two copies of a card in a deck, while MTG you can have four. MTG can be packing enough removal to clean out an entire Hearthstone player's deck.

Hearthstone has beefier minions, which is why Green will struggle, but very few Hearthstone creatures are particularly safe from removal. On top of that, MTG has plenty of ways of dealing with Deathrattle effects as well (namely Exile effects). MTG creatures will generally have more potent abilities.

​

Out of curiosity, how would MTG protection effects come into play. For example, if a Card has "Protection from White" how does that interact with HS? Does just every Paladin and Priest minion count as White?

1
FallenJkillerOP•

Out of curiosity, how would MTG protection effects come into play. For example, if a Card has "Protection from White" how does that interact with HS? Does just every Paladin and Priest minion count as White?

It probably wouldn't. Protection and color hosing is mostly sideboard stuff, so just ignoring it for now is not very problematic.

iirc, Hearthstone you can only have two copies of a card in a deck

i believed that the number of cards wouldnt really be a problem, considering most hs games end before turn 15, and mtg is faster than that. We could either increase HS decks to 40 (max 3) or make a "constructed limited" deck for MTG, with 40 cards.

However, you are most probably correct, and the versatility of MTG would make it a superior choice, even if we are confined in standard.

1
IllianTear•

I would say MtG on the sole basis that it can have more than 10 mana.

2