r/Breadit•
AffectedLine

In case anyone needs encouragement, these are attempts 2 and 3 at sandwich bread. Yikes. 🤣

In case anyone needs encouragement, these are attempts 2 and 3 at sandwich bread. Yikes. 🤣

Posted Apr 3, 2020, 2:06 PM UTC

28
AffectedLineOP•

Number 2 is the one that didn’t even make it out of the pan. 3 came out but was still extremely crumbly. I made all of 2 into croutons and bread crumbs. Husband and I are trying to very delicately eat 3 as toast. šŸ¤£šŸ¤¦šŸ¼ā€ā™€ļø

1
axtran•

I made a loaf last night that was similar. Tasted right, but so, so dense.

2
AffectedLineOP•

Mine haven’t even been that dense! They just ... fall apart. I suspect they are under-kneaded so the gluten hasn’t developed properly. My next attempt is cooling now, so fingers crossed!

1
mghemm437•

Mine have also turned out really crumbly. What have you been trying to fix that? Cause I need helpppp lol

1
AffectedLineOP•

I suspect they have been under-kneaded.

I have a lot of chronic wrist issues that prevent me from kneading by hand, so I have been doing the ā€œkneadingā€ in my kitchenaid. I accidentally ā€œkneadedā€ for the full time on the recipe for my first loaf. Then I read the instructions on the kitchenaid website which say that ā€œkneadingā€ in the kitchenaid is more powerful and should be done for much less time. That resulted in loaves 2-3 which were not that different (structurally) than my first. I began to suspect that doing one batch of dough at a time wasn’t providing enough substance for the kitchenaid to really ā€œknead.ā€ A lot was just sticking to the hook and not really getting smashed around.

On my latest 2 loaves which are in the oven now, I doubled the batch in the kitchenaid so there was twice as much dough. I think there was more agitation in there, but it’s kind of hard for me to say since I’m not sure what I’m doing.

The loaves rose much faster this time, and appeared to have a better prove when I put them in the oven (I was able to gently press a finger into the dough and have it mostly spring back, which the recipe said should happen and definitely didn’t on any of the first three.)

I will report back when I slice into them!

2
mghemm437•

I have a Pro Series KitchenAid, so it's a 5qt bowl and I only do single batches (I only have 2 loaf pans). So maybe that's part of the problem. Also after reading some other people's posts I think I am more than likely under-kneading and adding too much flour.

Good luck with this batch! Hope they turn out great!

2
AffectedLineOP•

Thanks! I am trying to persevere šŸ’ŖšŸ¼ They both came out of the pan (cooling on the rack now), so I am taking that as a small win haha!

2
AffectedLineOP•

The structure was muuuuch better on these two! They held up to being sliced and I don’t feel like I have to be so delicate with the slices haha. The rise was off I think (baby napping struggles > bread šŸ™ƒ) but it’s definitely progress.

1