This is actually a good argument to have universal health care vs insurance.

Posted Apr 4, 2020, 9:53 AM UTC

3437
krabbby•

It's a good argument not to have healthcare tied to your job. That's all.

36
jimmychimmy dude, My Dude•

Well if you lose your job but still have private insurance, most people are going to pretty rapidly lose the ability to pay for that insurance. Bit of a double whammy.

30
krabbby•

Having a form of public insurance does not mean you cant have private insurance

11
IonHawk•

What would be the purpose of private insurance though? Faster, better, healthcare? If this would trickle down with new research and the rich paying for better healthcare for the rest but I would deem this as unlikely. It's much more likely that you will have a multi-tier system for the different classes were the lower class system could possibly still suck.

If everyone has access to the same or at least similar system and govern it more by the principles of need rather than by greed(sorry for the hyperbolic language, couldn't resist the rhyme though) that would motivate all classes to work for a better healthcare system for everyone.

Like right now. Everyone benefits from giving lots of money to the now non-working population since it will allow more people to stay home and help stopping the spread... as well as helping the economy and not have people in the streets starving and rioting, but that's a different point.

8
krabbby•

Some people want to pay extra for more stuff. Happens in Germany and it's a fine system

10
JerfFoo•

I don't really care about what the goal of private insurance should be, all that matters is that virtually every single country tends to have a mixture of private and public insurance in some fashion and they all get way better results and way better costs then the US does. Even Canada, a single payer country, has privatized dental and opitical insurance. We don't need an overnight takeover of all healthcare to improve conditions in America, something as simple as a public option will dramatically improve things.

2
PascalLerouxOP•

Insurance companies also exist to make profit. I wonder how manageable that is when the demand for payouts increase? What's in place if they decide to start making some bullshit reasons not to pay certain people's claims out or deny them for x,y,z reason?

Like, upon closer inspection, private insurance was a galactically fucking stupid mistake.

11
helperfused•

So you’re saying

I bet those insurance firms didn’t expect there was a future where they’d have to payout so much.

Let’s see how they habdle this >:)

But that’s literally the point of an insurance company. Their singular job is to anticipate how much they can expect to payout based on the EX given by the risk factors. And as your n approaches the total population, the easier it gets.

I mean you know how if a coin flip is 50/50 then that means a neutral expected value for a game where a person offers 10 dollars if you win, would require you to pay 10 dollars if you lose.

Like, the idea of something similar to

15 cars suddenly piling up Q1

Is not an idea that’s just lost to insurance companies. Moreover, the sars virus still only affects a proportion of the population with debilitating symptoms. Like 95% of people are advised to just stay home and try to get better.

Mb I’m rambling, a sign of my impending dementia, but you can be damn sure that the cost premiums and lifetime value of covering you is going to be greater than the amount you incur.

Edit: point is it’s based solely on managing risk. They would be a bad idea if they couldn’t handle the sole thing they were designed to do.

2
PascalLerouxOP•

point is it’s based solely on managing risk. They would be a bad idea if they couldn’t handle the sole thing they were designed to do

Well, they weren't designed to do that. They were designed to operate with worse case scenarios, I'm confident of that. Like say, when a hurricane hits. A pandemic that's going to hospitalize 19% of people? That's like what, 60 million people? Scam.

What's going to happen to premiums in the aftermath if they do manage to stay solvent?

2
tiny_smile_bot•

:)

:)

1
helperfused•

Uhhhhh, intrinsic to the way insurance works is precisely the fact that they account for risk involved and adjust for it. Necessarily, this means the idea a LOT of people suddenly get sick at once is something they’re prepared for.

This is like a really really misinformed take, my dude.

-1
PascalLerouxOP•

intrinsic to the way insurance works is precisely the fact that they account for risk involved and adjust for it

Huh? Not sure I follow.

1
Arizonaftw•

What's in place if they decide to start making some bullshit reasons not to pay certain people's claims out or deny them for x,y,z reason?

A wave of lawsuits.

-3†
lizzowarren100% that b-word•

A wave of nothing happening

6
firebreathingluigi•

This is, like, THE argument for m4a. I find it odd that anyone would need it spelled out for them because it's the main reason people want m4a in the first place.

21
PascalLerouxOP•

Funny, I hadn't seen it manifest during this time. Like I said, hindsight 2020

4
firebreathingluigi•

You've never heard anyone say that your ability to get healthcare shouldn't be tied to your job? Were you paying attention to the arguments for m4a the past 5 years?

12
ozo_perezozo•

Why would anyone look at the arguments for the other side? If the other side can't effectively convey their argument it's not up to me to get educated on policies I vote against. /s

6
PascalLerouxOP•

The argument for that always revolved around people not having access to benefits in certain jobs, one. Two, nobody ever framed it in relation to a crisis. So no.

4
quagmirecentral•

I do want m4a. Everyone deserves McDonald's. Reason why I do not suppport a nationalized McDonald's system is because it is very affordable and accessible to the vast majority of Americans. If McDonald's was too expensive for the majority of American people and gets priced into jobs, I would like the price to become affordable. However jobs would offer these opportunities if McDonald's wasn't so affordable.

-3
PascalLerouxOP•

Pandemics and epidemics are, unfortunately, as we discovered, a fact of life. If the solution, when faced with this kind of a problem, is to self-isolate and, as a result this leads to unemployment + layoffs, that safety net is no longer there. It doesn't matter how long your union chose to fight for these benefits. In fact, if they're quite lucrative for you and your co-workers, this might lead to more layoffs to offset the total cost of having such programs n'est-ce pas?

What's the solution? Force companies to keep people on the payroll, so they keep their benefits and the cost isn't dumped into their lap? What does this do to a company's liquidity and overall trust in the company in the eyes of investors? I'm trying to think of policy solutions that might help in this particular situation but it's difficult to isolate something that makes any sense. Maybe I'm just not seeing it.

Could there be a temporary solution, paying medical bills for the duration of the crisis that could be implemented? This is an unprecedented situation but, having one's ability to pay for crucial health care services as a result of a health-related crisis seems like a really dumb thing to leave structured as is. LARPey dumb dumbs might have been right on this one, they just weren't able to come up with this as an example without hindsight. Then again, neither was I being ultimately in favour for universal health care but being pragmatic about how one gets there.

9
helperfused•

Honestly, emergency loans that track inflation is a good idea. You put caps on tbe amount that can be borrowed depending on the itemization given for the firm so overhead can be calculated. Really we’re just trying to cover some loan payments to the banks and we’re not trying to refinance the cost of the loan.

When that’s done you stimulus spend with UBI or lowering rates like usual.

Also, something you forgot to consider is that health care pandemics like this scale how communicable they are inversely with how lethal they are. You don’t need to prepare for 300million or even the percent of 300million that’d get gravely ill since rate it’s passed on is based on population density.

You only have to worry about big cities. Like, I had corona virus when I was in the philippines in January. Since I’m a shut in neet, nobody got sick. Also it’s hotter so there’s that too.

Edit: nah my first idea sucks take it back

1
misantropecapitalist welfare states are OP•

What's the solution? Force companies to keep people on the payroll, so they keep their benefits and the cost isn't dumped into their lap?

Many European countries are paying wage subsidies to companies to keep their workforce. That way the employees retain any benefits they have, don't have to file for unemployment, and have a lot more certainty about returning to work when the crisis oasses.

1
StaleTaste•

Of course. Universal healthcare is the moderate position and all others are the radical position. I like capitalism but allowing people to make transactions where the alternative to them making the transaction is the death of themselves or their family is clearly not in the best interest of the society because the supplier can literally charge whatever the person has because a persons life is priceless to them.

6
krabbby•

Universal healthcare is not the same as single payer. Most universal systems are not.

3†
mcdonaldowner•

listen man i dont care what it's called, i just want everyone to have some gosh darn healthcare :)

6
JimmyKeyz•

"UHC vs insurance"

These aren't mutually exclusive entities. You can have a multi-payer system with a universality mandate. It already exists in several high ranked countries on the commonwealth healthcare rankings.

6
KaelNukem•

Wouldn't it be cheaper to have one big nationalized healthcare system though?

health insurance companies make a lot of money, what if that money instead went directly into the government?

Besides the amount of money it generates, if the entire population is insured by one ''company'' wouldn't they be able to get better deal from pharmaceutical companies since they have to buy medicine for their entire population?

2
JimmyKeyz•

The single payer systems and multi-payer systems of the commonwealth rankings all seem to have the same cost per capita, or at least in the ballpark.

1