Hypothetically, if Unlimited Atonement...

In theory, if (and I know it is a big IF) Jesus paid for everyone's sin... would that mean A. Universalism or B. Not believing in Jesus is what separates from God [edit: condemns] ?

Edit: Potential support for option B: (believe and be saved - R 6:23)(eternal life is knowing - John 17:3)(way, truth, life - John 14:6)

Curious what your thoughts are... Thanks!