r/canada•
pythonpoole

My Take on UBB, a letter to the CRTC

I am a young Canadian entrepreneur who is actively pursuing a business venture that relies heavily on my ability to provide video streaming services to my customers, specifically Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) services that are accessed through the customer's existing Internet service.

Based on an industry average of 25 television viewing hours per person per week, I anticipate that the average customer of my IPTV service will consume at least 100 Gigabytes worth of content during a one month period, with multi-person household consumption averages expected to be even higher.

Nearly all developed nations in the world, including the United States, have readily affordable residential Internet services available to consumers that provide unlimited or nearly unlimited monthly data usage at no extra cost; unfortunately Canada is not one of them.

All major Internet Service Providers in Canada including Bell, Rogers, Shaw and Telus have implemented extremely limiting and punitive monthly data caps on their customers that, above all, are completely arbitrary and have no association with actual ISP costs.

Now those caps are being forcefully imposed on the customers of independent service providers, who until now, have been the only providers to offer market competition and provide unlimited (or nearly unlimited) services based on true ISP costs, like the United States and many European countries do.

If an Internet subscriber is limited to a data cap of 25 GB or even 100 GB per month, it will not be possible for me to conduct business in Canada. With extremely heavy $2 per GB overage fees (in some cases up to $5), my customers will be charged outrageously unaffordable penalty fees that will amount to potentially hundreds or thousands of dollars per year per customer, penalties which the incumbent providers will simply pocket and turn into virtually pure profit.

As it stands now, the only chance of making my business venture successful is either by entering foreign markets such as the United States, where punitive data usage penalties are of no issue; OR marketing my services locally in Canada to customers of independent ISPs that are able to consume large amounts of online video content without penalties, similar to most foreign markets.

If the CRTC allows incumbent providers to implement data caps on customers of independent service providers and charge the independent ISPs usage-based-billing penalties, I am simply unable to market my services to Canadian consumers and will be forced to market my services only in foreign markets.

As a proud and true Canadian, it is very upsetting to me that we have come to the point where government policy and regulation is stifling innovation and preventing Canada from embracing the ever-growing digital economy that is such a core and fundamental component of the digital information age we live in today.

I find it very embarrassing that I am in the process of developing a new and revolutionary product and service that is truly innovative, one that has global implications, and gives us the chance to push Canada forward into the next generation of the digital economy, and yet I have to sit-back and apologize to my fellow Canadian friends and neighbours, for I am unable to bring this amazing product and service to their doorsteps as I can do for people in the United States, France, Sweden, Poland, Norway, The Netherlands and even the Czech Republic, just to name a few.

I also believe it's worth mentioning that the usage meter on which incumbent providers are basing these per GB charges is not at all regulated or independently tested or audited, and there is no mechanism for consumers or independent ISPs to dispute usage charges from incumbent providers! Clearly it is not fair to overcharge consumers with heavy penalties unassociated to cost, and charge those users based on approximate measurements that are not verified in accuracy.

Bell has very recently (as of February 2011) issued an official statement to their customers in which Bell admits its usage meter is faulty and has overstated customers' monthly usage in many cases; the same usage meter intended for use to monitor and penalize independent ISPs for their customer's over-usage.

How can a company be allowed to artificially create a measurement of intangible substance that has no intrinsic value and then charge customers outrageous fees based on a measurement claim, a claim that is not in any way verifiable or disputable by others?

Data have no value in and by themselves, they are just a collection of 0s and 1s, electrical pulses or light waves that form information that the consumer may perceive has having some value, such as the sentimental value of a family photograph. To argue that average users are somehow subsidizing the heavy users because they are consuming more data over a monthly period is quite frankly a very ridiculous notion.

It is important to remember that data is not a finite resource, it is truly unlimited in nature and the data can be produced and copied endlessly at zero cost. This is far different from a public utility model like gas or electricity where there is an enormous cost associated with the generation, production, processing and delivery of the resource, a cost that can be accurately measured and assessed. With the Internet, data is being freely generated and provided by third-parties who have no affiliation whatsoever with the ISPs and in turn, the ISPs are delivering copies of that data to customers at virtually no cost to them, or at a very tiny (almost negligible) cost that is substantially lower than any proposed usage charges. Once again, the argument that Internet data traffic should somehow be charged like a public utility holds very little water, no pun intended.

There is one argument that Bell routinely presents during the ongoing wholesale usage-based-billing debate which strikes me as particularly poor. I have no doubt that it is intended to confuse CRTC members and political leaders, and I feel I have a responsibility to clear-up some of that confusion.

Bell argues that a variety of plans are available with usage caps of various sizes that can meet the needs of customers. What Bell consistently neglects to mention is that Bell does not make these plans available through their wholesale offering to independent service providers. In other words, the independent ISPs are being artificially crippled by Bell who is choosing to limit third-party ISPs to plans that are equivalent only to some of Bell's lowest plan offerings for their customers.

In effect what Bell is saying is that Bell customers have the option of purchasing a cost-effective plan that provides 25 Mbps of bandwidth and 75 GB of monthly data usage, however Independent service providers are restricted to only 5 or 6 Mbps of bandwidth and are forced to accept a 25 GB data cap for each of their subscribers with heavy overage fees. If anything, Bell's argument that many flexible plans are available is actually working against them, clearly demonstrating how unfair the marketplace is, and how Bell's own subscribers are very clearly favoured over those of independent providers, to a ridiculous degree.

Lastly, I would like to briefly discuss ADSL co-location, or colo for short. Allowing independent service providers to participate in colo operated services would resolve many of the problems regarding usage-based-billing. It would allow third-party service providers to connect their own equipment and develop their own independent network infrastructure that would bring Internet service directly to a customer's home using only the subscriber's dedicated last-mile connection. This would allow independent service providers to offer their own unique and differentiated Internet services that completely bypass all shared portions of the Bell network, preventing any form of congestion and ruling out any possibility that Bell could somehow have to pay the cost of the subscriber's data usage. Unfortunately, as it stands now, Bell is making it very difficult or impossible for independent service providers to offer such colo services, and I would very much like to see this changed.

Thank you for your time, and I hope you will consider my comments in the process of making your decision.

Posted Mar 4, 2011, 3:23 AM UTC

177
McDrawrHumperdink•

Thank you for your reply, <sucker_recipient_field>

The CRTC does not regulate the rates, quality of service or business practices for Internet service providers. So we can’t pursue complaints about these services for you.

Problem?

Sincerely, Lord Finckelstein of the glorious Big Three fiefdoms

2
elementalist467New Brunswick•

The best part of your letter is :

Lastly, I would like to briefly discuss ADSL co-location, or colo for short. Allowing independent service providers to participate in colo operated services would resolve many of the problems regarding usage-based-billing. It would allow third-party service providers to connect their own equipment and develop their own independent network infrastructure that would bring Internet service directly to a customer's home using only the subscriber's dedicated last-mile connection. This would allow independent service providers to offer their own unique and differentiated Internet services that completely bypass all shared portions of the Bell network, preventing any form of congestion and ruling out any possibility that Bell could somehow have to pay the cost of the subscriber's data usage. Unfortunately, as it stands now, Bell is making it very difficult or impossible for independent service providers to offer such colo services, and I would very much like to see this changed.

UBB isn't as much the issue as Bell's ability to use UBB to stifle services that threaten their traditional profit centers of phone service and express view. I would suggest splitting Bell into two entities a whole sale line leaser that manages the network and media company that uses uses that network for distribution. As separate entities Bell Network Management would have no anticompetitive basis to implement UBB.

2
arcanereborn•

It was strange arriving to Canada from the Caribbean and experiencing bandwidth limits. It reminded me of my days of dial-up when i got charged per hour of usage, then came dsl and all was fixed. Then when the dsl went from 256k and then 500k and stagnated, captain competition came to the party. the cable company joined in and offered Cable internet and at a much faster speed. This is my country now After Breaking the Monopoly

Flow U-click Trinidad rates are VAT inclusive and in TTD (Trinidad and Tobago Dollars)

This is company that had the monopoly on the internet and how they still currently price

TSTT Blink

Breaking it down and converted to CAN from TTD

Trinidad & Tobago

Flow Link - better of the 2 broadband providers so will use only that one

  • $69.99 TTD / $10.67 CAN ~ 5 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 20 hours and $5.75 TTD per hour after/ $23 per 5 additional hours = $10.67 CAN, $0.87 CAN per hour/ $3.50 CAN per 5 hours

  • $199.99 TTD / $30.49 CAN ~ 5 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ unlimited bandwidth

  • $399.99 TTD / $60.98 CAN ~ 25 mbs DOWN 1.5 mbs UP ~ unlimited bandwidth

  • $599.99 TTD / $91.48 CAN ~ 50 mbs DOWN 2 mbs UP ~ unlimited bandwidth

  • $799.99 TTD / $121.97 CAN ~ 100 mbs DOWN 3 mbs UP~ unlimited bandwidth

All prices in Trinidad are always tax inclusive, so you always pay for what you see.

Canada (Prices are Not Tax inclusive, so you will be paying more than advertised)

Rogers Link

  • $99.99 CAN ~ 50 mbs DOWN 2mbs UP ~ 175Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $69.99 CAN ~ 25 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 125Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $59.99 CAN ~ 15 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 80Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $46.99 CAN ~ 10 mbs DOWN 0.512 mbs UP ~ 60Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $35.99 CAN ~ 3 mbs DOWN mbs 0.256 UP ~ 15Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $27.99 CAN ~ 0.5 mbs DOWN mbs 0.256 UP ~ 2Gb BANDWIDTH

Bell Link

  • $55.95 CAN ~ 25 mbs DOWN 7 mbs UP ~ 75Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $49.95 CAN ~ 16 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 75Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $39.95 CAN ~ 12 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 50Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $34.95 CAN ~ 6 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 25Gb BANDWIDTH (Fibe 6)

  • $34.95 CAN ~ 6 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 25Gb BANDWIDTH (Performance)

  • $24.95 CAN ~ 2 mbs DOWN 0.8 mbs UP ~ 2Gb BANDWIDTH

Shaw Link

  • $150 CAN ~ 100 mbs DOWN 5 mbs UP ~ 350Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $97 CAN ~ 50 mbs DOWN 3 mbs UP ~ 175Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $29.95 CAN ~ 15 mbs DOWN 1 mbs UP ~ 100Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $37 CAN ~ 7.5 mbs DOWN 0.512 mbs UP ~ 60Gb BANDWIDTH

  • $25 CAN ~ 1 mbs DOWN 0.256 mbs UP ~ 15Gb BANDWIDTH

1
darkp22•

I believe the best kind of competition allowable in a natural monopoly like broadband infrastructure is for the government to own the cables and private ISPs to lease them and compete on price. Best of both worlds.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Access_Network

There would be too low of a return on investment for a traditional company to lay down a national high-speed network in Canada due to its low density (much like Australia). These are the exact conditions where an open access network will thrive.

A country like Korea is much more dense, making it much easier for it to be profitable for a company to lay down fibre. This would be much more difficult to apply to a significant portion of Canada without significant compromises. With a government-owned system, the infrastructure would be understood to serve a social purpose rather than a purely monetary one.

Canada is a big country. My hometown, Thunder Bay, just got 3G in December. The fastest Internet you can get there is 5 Mb/s. It is the only significant population center for 8 hours in every direction. Rogers ended up selling its service to a municipal-owned utility because it was not profitable enough to provide 3G access in such a low density area. There are plenty of areas in Canada in similar situations and they deserve world-class internet just as much as Toronto and Vancouver.

Fibre is a fixed cost. One company will not be able to build a fibre network cheaper than another. Having multiple redundant networks to promote "competition" will cost the economy more than just having one installation. Look at Wind in Toronto. Wouldn't its signal be better if it could just use all the 3G towers in Toronto instead of just the ones belonging to its network?

Competition between private ISPs through service and efficiency can still be obtained through every carrier sharing the same government-owned infrastructure. It honestly would be very similar to the local ISPs in the dial-up days.

1
Kronecker_D•

Good letter, but there is a part that I think is partly incorrect. Specifically, where you say that Independent ISPs can only offer plans with 25 GB caps. In an e-mail to subscribers from Teksavvy where they announced the impact of the UBB decision on their servicies, they specifically say that subscribers can purchase "insurance blocks" to get higher bandwidth caps.

It's not the same as Bell's higher speed plans, but the point is independent ISP subscribers would have been able to buy higher caps.

1
pythonpooleOP•

Yes, it is true that independent ISPs could buy insurance blocks, however this would incur extra monthly charges for each customer regardless of whether the customer actually used any of the extra data allowance, and ultimately the insurance fee would have to be passed down to the customers. An insurance policy still does not equate to having access to the higher performance plans that include extra data usage as part of the monthly fee.

Basically it would be very difficult for ISPs to offer more than a 25 GB cap without 1) charging several dollars more per month (to cover the cost of insurance) which would make it very difficult to compete, or 2) using a 25 GB cap and offering the insurance as an extra option for users to purchase. So it pretty much forces ISPs to adopt a 25 GB base plan.

1
Kronecker_D•

Yes, that's all true. I just think in the letter it sounds like you're saying "Bell subscribers can buy plans with higher caps, third-party ISP's subscribers can only get 25 GB."

1