DH is broken but it is really fun to play

Gameplay

Hear me ou! I know that the class is bat sh*t broken right now but it is what Hearthstone gameplay always should have been for me. Your decisions actually matter now.

You win by playing cards in the right order, keeping keycards or not if they are in the wrong order. Every mulligan is different. You don't just look for your strong 1/2 drops and hope for topdecks. You have to plan a few turns ahead, you have to decide can I survive another turn and face tank the minion or do I have to use my removal now and can't lethal next turn.

This is not your average aggro paladin or secret mage garbage where you play the green card with the highest number and hit face or your other tier 1 deck from the past where you draw THAT card on turn x and win on the spot. I know people might disagree but the design of the class and the cards are amazing and I love the outcast mechanic because it adds so much variety.

It is the first time I actually watch my replays and see how I could have won a game if I had done something different and even with 74 % WR against other demonhunters I still make a ton of small mistakes.

It is also the first time since "Old gods" that I can't stop playing because I'm having so much fun.

Posted Apr 8, 2020, 6:01 PM UTC

015
Joemanji84•

Absolutely, the Outcast mechanic and the power level of DH cards are two separate issues. If they tone down some (a lot) of cards I can see DH being a really rewarding class to play. Almost like Patron Warrior as a class.

3
chaoslorduk•

card choices actually matter. you mean get them to outcast and win it never a case of playing them at the right time just playing them in correct order its just like exodia mage where instead of freezing you just keep face until you get your victory cards and win. AS with EM all your opponant gets to to is hope to hyper aggro you.

The deck loses to aggro does not justify the dwcks op existence.

0
EpicSabretooth•

I mean whatever floats your boat I guess. I don't like exploiting clearly broken things personally.

-2
EfficiencyVIOP•

What is broken in a mirror match?

2
EpicSabretooth•

It's broken against other classes.

0
EfficiencyVIOP•

Maybe you should read the posts you answer ...

1
EpicSabretooth•

"I know the class is batshit broken right now", I'm responding to that.

1
Batfan54•

Honest question; why do you have so much fun accomplishing so little?

-3
vtomal•

Because fun isn't about accomplishing anything. If you want to feel accomplished you would study something or do something more productive than play a children's card game.

The act of play is by design meaningless, so there is no right way to have fun.

4
Batfan54•

Disagree, if I dunk on a 5' hoop over a 4 year old toddler, the amount of fun I'm having in comparison to dunking on a 10' hoop over a grown man my size should not be measured equally. Same actions, different circumstances, and one of them is very clearly pathetic and unaccomplished.

So, the question becomes; why is dunking on a half sized hoop over a child fun for you? Wouldn't be fun for me, since I didn't do anything. Anybody who would find joy or accomplishment in that deserves to be looked down on, as we can all reasonably say that's a ridiculous thing to feel accomplished about.

-2
vtomal•

False equivalence fallacy.

You are treating the act of playing a DH as an automatic I win button, when probably it would not push more than a 60 percent win rate on the hands of a regular player (and there are mirrors). Therefore there is still challenges for those involved, even if they would stomp on unoptimized decks that would be stomped anyway by other refined decks.

There are obvious differences between those examples, and you could not bring them in good faith expecting them to make sense in context.

3
OscarMiner•

Preach!

2
Batfan54•

It's not a false equivalency fallacy. It's an actual comparison between two children's games that have varying degrees of "success" measured by the effort put in.

You are treating the act of playing a DH as an automatic I win button,

For our intents and purposes here, correct. Obviously it doesn't win every time, but it has a significant advantage over everything else for seemingly no effort or reason.

There are obvious differences between those examples, and you could not bring them in good faith expecting them to make sense in context.

I absolutely can. I'll even define it for you.

Basketball is a children's play game that means nothing. It has arbitrary rules and win conditions for no reason other than to beat your opponent or goof off. There are degrees of skill that are required to play the game, depending on how you play it and who you play against.

You can play Basketball on a 5' hoop and against a toddler - that would be a very easy way to play the game. Normally I'd leave this up to people to just gather on their own, but since you need the help - this is the Demon Hunter.

Or you could play on the 10' hoop against someone your age, and that would be what I would call a reasonable way of playing the game. This is (for the most part) every other class and deck in the game. There are outliers.

Both options are valid ways to play. The rules are arbitrary and you can choose whichever you want. But one has a reasonable standard of challenge that would give a reasonable sense of accomplishment, and the other is dunking on a fucking 5 year old because you wanted to be able to dunk in the game of Basketball.

You still don't get it, I know, but I'm just going to tell you that calling everything relative and citing fallacies that dont apply or even exist doesn't bolster an argument.

0