Is there a reason behind the inclusion of Valinor in Silver Ships of Andilar?
I've been getting into Townes recently, and since I first heard Silver Ships of Andilar I've been wondering if there was any story behind the inclusion of Valinor. This could also go for the Silver Ships, but I'm less sure if that was intentional or not. Valinor, in the Middle Earth canon is the land of the Valar (gods)to the west which no mortal can reach (the song has a rather... grim take on this part of the mythos). However, in the canon it's...basically heaven, not the lifeless waste ruled over by some dark lord figure like in the song, and the location (to the north) has been changed from the west. Andilar is also a completely new addition. I have some theories on the location of Andilar and the changes made to Valinor, but is there a known reason for it's inclusion?
Posted Apr 9, 2020, 1:02 AM UTC
I've heard some people speculate that TVZ read LOTR at some point and just threw a reference in there, but I haven't found anyone cute a source for that. Maybe he just thought the name sounded cool. Might just be coincidence, might not be. Great song, though.