I'm finally getting a better set-up and need some advice :)

My 18th birthday is coming up and I was going to get a new amp and speakers. But yesterday I had the idea to buy some good second hand speakers from a second hand Hi-fi shop nearby, I would still like to get a new amp as my current one makes the treble far to loud and almost hissy.

So my question is, would it be worth buying second hand speakers but having a new amp, or should I just buy new speakers too?

My budget is ~£400 and any input on which amp, speakers or sound-card (for my windows pc, internal or external) I should look into.

Thanks guys

Posted Mar 6, 2011, 10:00 PM UTC

28
KMFDM781•

It's always better to buy older speakers of high quality rather than buy new speakers of mediocre or low quality because that's all you can afford new....same goes for amps or integrated receivers. I picked up a 1969 model Realistic STA-120 (60 watts p/ch) receiver today for $50. It's in absolutely spotless condition inside and out...this thing sold for $350 new back in '69.
I'm a bit jaded, but I'd rather buy old stuff than new any day. They were just built better back then...unless you're talking ultra high end stuff.

4
looksfamiliar•

Music or Movies, ie Stereo amp or AV receiver?

Second hand can be good if the gear has been looked after and is in full working order. Check the foam around drive units for cracks.

3
FishStacksOP•

Thanks for the quick reply and advice, its for music.

2
looksfamiliar•

I'd say go with a stereo amp (less channels, better value for money, designed for music) although the DAC in an AV receiver can be handy. A good soundcard, or USB DAC obviates the need for this though.

3
Uncle_ErikDistinguished Service Award•

Go for the secondhand speakers. Speakers tend to be stable for years. Foam rot is the only thing to worry about, but anyone can spot it and it's relatively easy to fix. The only exception tends to be electrostats, like Quads and Martin Logan. The high voltage isn't kind and they often have to be rebuilt every ten years or so. My Quads hiss and spit a little, so I'm gearing up to give them a thorough teardown later this year. All new diaphragms, rebuild the HV supplies, new socks, and I'll probably refinish the wood while I'm at it. Anyhow, regular cone speakers won't be like that.

Also, your money goes much further with used speakers. You'll find breathless "day and night" reviews for newer models, but every new model gets breathless reviews. Most are just slightly tweaked reissues, so there isn't much difference from the old ones.

Amps aren't that critical. Something like a good Adcom or NAD is fine for just about everything. I'd only spend extra for something like a nifty DHT tube amp for horns or singledrivers. Or if you want something beautiful to put on your shelf. Otherwise, a well-made black box from a good manufacturer will soldier on for decades while sounding great.

Put more money into the speakers - that's where you get the maximum value. Only recording quality is more important.

For your budget, I'd hunt down a pair of used Magnepan MMGs. Or even new ones, since they're reasonable. I'm a fool for dipoles and the MMG is a steal - they position it as a gateway drug to their more expensive models. Still, it's awfully good. I'd pair them with a used NAD integrated.

3
FishStacksOP•

Thanks for the advice, but what are the advantages and disadvantages of those types of speakers (not sure what they are called, possibly ribbon?) over regular speakers? I am pretty new to all this :)

1
Uncle_ErikDistinguished Service Award•

Magnepans are mostly planars. They work sort of like an electrostat, with a large diaphragm that moves back and forth. In an electrostat, the diaphragm is moved back and forth by putting high voltage on the stators. In a planar, there's no high voltage because it uses magnets. Ribbons are a little different. You have parallel rows of magnets, and a strip of aluminum hangs in the magnetic gap between them. Some Magnepan models have planar panels for the bass as well as ribbons for the higher frequencies.

The advantage of these is that they radiate sound front and back, just the way sound is in real life. Set up correctly, a pair of dipoles will create a frighteningly realistic soundstage. It's not "you are there," it's more of a "they are here" experience. Also, ribbons are very fast. They often go well up to 40kHz or higher. Not that you can hear that, but they won't show the least bit of strain or distortion when you run them to 15kHz or better. Having a practically limitless top end adds a certain realistic "air" to things like cymbals and high pitched vocals.

The main disadvantages are size and placement. Large speaker panels tend not to be appreciated by women. Further, you often have to pull them three or four feet into the room to get them to reflect correctly. But if you have a little room and no other objections, you'll love them.

2
zeppoleon•

Good second hand speakers for sure. Hopefully you'll find them in such good condition they are practically new. I bought my B&W DM602 S2 speakers second hand, and there is no evidence to suggest they are second hand. The best thing about buying used speakers is that they should be already broken-in (if they were played modestly). I also bought a new Onkyo TX-8555 Stereo Receiver and couldn't be happier for the price! Before that I got a Pioneer SA-9100, but since it's vintage it's in need of a little tune up...

2