Opinion | Joe Biden: My Plan to Safely Reopen America
nytimes.com/2020/04/12/opinion/joe-biden-coro...Posted Apr 12, 2020, 4:23 PM UTC
Posted Apr 12, 2020, 4:23 PM UTC
Here is the text for those who dont want to click the link
People across America are stepping up to the plate. Millions are performing essential services at great personal risk, and millions more are staying at home, away from friends and extended family. In return, they want the answer to a simple question: What is the plan to safely reopen America?
So far, the Trump administration hasn’t supplied an answer.
The plan has to start with responding effectively to the immediate medical crisis and ultimately lead to the widespread availability and administration of a vaccine. But we can’t stay home and just wait for the vaccine to arrive. As others have noted, we need to build a bridge from here to there. Here’s what our national strategy should look like.
First, we have to get the number of new cases of the disease down significantly. That means social distancing has to continue and the people on the front lines have to get the supplies and equipment they need. President Trump needs to use his full powers under the Defense Production Act to fight the disease with every tool at our disposal. He needs to get the federal response organized and stop making excuses. For more Americans to go back to their jobs, the president needs to do better at his job.
Second, there needs to be widespread, easily available and prompt testing — and a contact tracing strategy that protects privacy. A recent report from Mr. Trump’s Department of Health and Human Services made clear that we are far from achieving this goal.
We should be running multiple times the number of diagnostic tests we’re performing right now. And we should be ready to scale up a second form of testing: rapid serology tests to tell who has already been infected with the coronavirus and has antibodies. This isn’t rocket science; it’s about investment and execution. We are now several months into this crisis, and still this administration has not squarely faced up to the “original sin” in its failed response — the failure to test.
Third, we have to make sure that our hospitals and health care system are ready for flare-ups of the disease that may occur when economic activity expands again. Reopening the right way will still not be completely safe. Public health officials will need to conduct effective disease surveillance. Hospitals need to have the staff and equipment necessary to handle any local outbreaks, and we need an improved federal system to get help to these places as needed.
Make no mistake: An effective plan to beat the virus is the ultimate answer to how we get our economy back on track. So we should stop thinking of the health and economic responses as separate. They are not.
Once we have taken these steps, we can begin to reopen more businesses and put more people back to work. Things will not go back to “normal” right away. As public health experts have said, we should expect activity to return gradually, with sites like offices and stores reopening before arenas and theaters.
That’s why we need to be working right now on the conditions under which our economy will operate as America gets back to work, and ensuring that the financial support our families and small businesses will need is fully in place.
As long as there is a significant risk that the virus can start spreading again, we are going to have to do some things differently. And the federal government should be leading the effort to figure that out.
If I were president, I would convene top experts from the private sector, industry by industry, to come up with new ideas on how to operate more safely. Perhaps offices and factories will need to space out workers and pursue other solutions to lessen risk of spread of the virus on the job. Restaurants may need new layouts, with diners farther apart.
From my talks with some industry leaders, I know that many are already at work on these questions. Mr. Trump needs to accelerate this thinking and make sure it is available to all businesses — including small businesses, not just the largest companies.
Likewise, I would direct the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, working with organized labor and employee groups, to figure out what protections workers need on the job during this period.
Getting protective gear to our health care workers and emergency medical workers is the top priority — and one where we are still lagging. But once that need is met, I’d ask the experts to figure out what delivery workers, waiters, clerks and so many other professionals need to be safe. And I would focus like a laser on the racial disparities in Covid-19 cases.
Safe and effective treatment can help manage the risk of the coronavirus. But of course, the only complete solution is finding a vaccine to extinguish the threat it poses. Scientists are making great strides on this, but discovering and testing a vaccine is only the first step: Manufacturing sufficient doses and distributing it to reach everyone is a huge challenge. The Trump administration should already be reporting to the American people on its efforts.
As we prepare to reopen America, we have to remember what this crisis has taught us: The administration’s failure to plan, to prepare, to honestly assess and communicate the threat to the nation led to catastrophic results. We cannot repeat those mistakes.
We know what we have to do. We have the tools, expertise and, now, hard-won experience. The American people have already paid too high a price in illness, death and economic loss. This time, the White House has to get it right.
What if I want to click the link but there's a paywall? Can you post the text for people like me?
This is a good read that lays out the tasks to be done in broad strokes. The workplace, business, and OSHA points are pretty forward thinking.
That said, the enormity of the testing challenge and contact tracing problem isn't conveyed here. These are problems of the scale our government has not had to solve for many decades.
I'm not sure how contact tracing can even work on a large scale at this point. Even when things slow down the long incubation period, long life of the virus on objects, and highly contagious nature of it make it so hard to track. Plus there's a ton of very mild cases that people won't get tested for and mistake their symptoms for allergies or the cold.
The apps certainly help but I highly doubt much more than half the US participates and self identifies as infected. Hell most conservatives still think the numbers are lies and the season flu is more of a problem. You aren't going to get them to willingly let cell phone companies and the government track them.
People will use the apps if their state governments say their data is safe and if employers, restaurants, and retail venues require proof of usage to use their services.
Private sector coercion and public guarantees of regulated privacy get us to a large degree of usage.
I think you might pretty quickly run into legal issues with requiring use of a smart phone app. 19% of American adults do not own a smartphone and that is likely strongly covariate with membership in a protected class, age in particular.
I'm not a conservative, I just don't want the phone company listening in while I use the toilet or follow me as I move from bedroom to... bedroom....
Don't judge.
Ceiling cat Verizon is watching you masturbate.
Your phone already does that, sort of, unless you turn off location services, turn off any of the "ok Google" or "hey Siri" always-listening triggers, and make sure you have no untrustworthy apps.
It's just that right now, generally, Google and Apple and co keep inadvertent recordings and location data stored safely and internally.
Same for the general US intelligence apparatus - they inadvertently collect a whole lot of domestic information on Americans they aren't allowed to use under the current laws, so they claim they toss away stuff they can't use.
Phone GPS units aren't accurate enough to track moving from one room to another within a building.
You can do contact tracing without location data using Bluetooth. Not as good, but it sorta works. I think some countries have issued apps to do this, can't remember exactly who.
A lot of the writing on this does seem to assume a majority of Americans will willingly download an app that constantly tracks who they are near which seems... really unlikely. Google and Apple are already preparing for that future: https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/4/10/21216675/apple-google-covid-coronavirus-contact-tracing-app and it seems predicated off of what has worked in various asian countries. I'm not holding my breath though.
Go to Google Maps -> Profile menu -> Your timeline
Realize Google Maps has been tracking your every move for years if you haven’t changed your location permissions.
A bunch of apps collect a GPS "heartbeat" every couple of minutes.
This is what letting"location permissions" on for apps do.
They already do? Most phones already track location data, lots of untrustworthy apps track and sell location data, etc...
This information is already out there. Personal privacy is dead under the current laws. Might as well do something beneficial with it.
I'd love to see significantly stricter laws on this stuff to enforce privacy, but I can't see it happening anytime soon.
I worked for FB as a software engineer, definitely familiar with the degree to which users are tracked. I’d still maintain that if you told the american public that the US govt is asking them to voluntarily download a tracking app, you’re gonna struggle.
If you told them to hit accept on a lengthy terms and conditions and enable location sharing, mic and video sharing and access to your contact book so that you can take photos and videos with cute filters and share them with your friends, that’s a different story
As stated in the article, the apps are gonna be developed by third party non profits because health data is sensitive and subject to extra regulation. Google and Apple are just providing APIs for those apps to access. Getting any app to 150 million downloads in the US is no joke, even in super hot, crazy funded Silicon Valley start ups
!ping Biden
Pinged members of BIDEN group.
user_pinger | [Request to be added to this group](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=groupbot&subject=Add yourself to group BIDEN&message=addtogroup BIDEN) | [Unsubscribe from this group](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=groupbot&subject=Unsubscribe from group BIDEN&message=unsubscribe BIDEN) | [Unsubscribe from all pings](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=groupbot&subject=Unsubscribe from all groups&message=unsubscribe )
Sounds good.
This is... not very good? Sure, its not terrible, but this article is the barest minimum plan and is possibly the coldest take cold takes could ever cold. this is practically bernie levels of "i'll just do it" with 0 explanation of how things will happen or what it'll look like.
People across America are stepping up to the plate. Millions are performing essential services at great personal risk, and millions more are staying at home, away from friends and extended family. In return, they want the answer to a simple question: What is the plan to safely reopen America?
So far, the Trump administration hasn’t supplied an answer.
intro
The plan has to start with responding effectively to the immediate medical crisis and ultimately lead to the widespread availability and administration of a vaccine. But we can’t stay home and just wait for the vaccine to arrive. As others have noted, we need to build a bridge from here to there. Here’s what our national strategy should look like.
good that he recognizes that the vaccine is the only true solution, and that we can't wait forever. this was obvious.
First, we have to get the number of new cases of the disease down significantly. That means social distancing has to continue and the people on the front lines have to get the supplies and equipment they need. President Trump needs to use his full powers under the Defense Production Act to fight the disease with every tool at our disposal. He needs to get the federal response organized and stop making excuses. For more Americans to go back to their jobs, the president needs to do better at his job.
yes, we can't reopen while there's huge amounts of cases. d'uh. beyond that, "every tool at our disposal", "organize the federal response", "do a good job" is the ends yes, but where's the means? what does this look like? how would the DPA be enacted? as we've seen, doing so blindly gets us expensive shit months too late.
Second, there needs to be widespread, easily available and prompt testing — and a contact tracing strategy that protects privacy. A recent report from Mr. Trump’s Department of Health and Human Services made clear that we are far from achieving this goal.
testing is d'uh. contact tracing strategy that protects privacy is not as simple as it sounds, and yet again biden shirks explaining what specifically this would look like.
We should be running multiple times the number of diagnostic tests we’re performing right now. And we should be ready to scale up a second form of testing: rapid serology tests to tell who has already been infected with the coronavirus and has antibodies. This isn’t rocket science; it’s about investment and execution. We are now several months into this crisis, and still this administration has not squarely faced up to the “original sin” in its failed response — the failure to test.
testing is still d'uh. immunity tests is also important, and props for joe to proposing that. not sure if it's mainstream or not, but its not the literal bare minimum, so i'll give him credit for this.
Third, we have to make sure that our hospitals and health care system are ready for flare-ups of the disease that may occur when economic activity expands again. Reopening the right way will still not be completely safe. Public health officials will need to conduct effective disease surveillance. Hospitals need to have the staff and equipment necessary to handle any local outbreaks, and we need an improved federal system to get help to these places as needed.
d'uh, when we re-open it'll come back. d'uh we can't just shut down every hospital and send the workers to bermuda.
Make no mistake: An effective plan to beat the virus is the ultimate answer to how we get our economy back on track. So we should stop thinking of the health and economic responses as separate. They are not.
d'uh
Once we have taken these steps, we can begin to reopen more businesses and put more people back to work. Things will not go back to “normal” right away. As public health experts have said, we should expect activity to return gradually, with sites like offices and stores reopening before arenas and theaters.
d'uh
That’s why we need to be working right now on the conditions under which our economy will operate as America gets back to work, and ensuring that the financial support our families and small businesses will need is fully in place.
conditions i don't feel like explaining
As long as there is a significant risk that the virus can start spreading again, we are going to have to do some things differently. And the federal government should be leading the effort to figure that out.
yes, "figure it out", a revolutionary idea that only a top mind like joe could think of
If I were president, I would convene top experts from the private sector, industry by industry, to come up with new ideas on how to operate more safely. Perhaps offices and factories will need to space out workers and pursue other solutions to lessen risk of spread of the virus on the job. Restaurants may need new layouts, with diners farther apart.
convening experts, truly groundbreaking stuff. (joe could name some experts, but he won't bother, which makes me question exactly who he's been consulting) also seating people farther apart to encourage distancing? he should give his consultants a raise
From my talks with some industry leaders, I know that many are already at work on these questions. Mr. Trump needs to accelerate this thinking and make sure it is available to all businesses — including small businesses, not just the largest companies.
make what available... the idea to sit people farther apart? sorry joe, i don't think you need a crack team of experts to ponder that idea
Likewise, I would direct the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, working with organized labor and employee groups, to figure out what protections workers need on the job during this period.
more 'figuring things out'
Getting protective gear to our health care workers and emergency medical workers is the top priority — and one where we are still lagging. But once that need is met, I’d ask the experts to figure out what delivery workers, waiters, clerks and so many other professionals need to be safe. And I would focus like a laser on the racial disparities in Covid-19 cases.
nominally caring about the minorities by vaguely mentioning their issues for one otherwise irrelevant sentence in a paragraph 3/4ths of the way through.
getting protective gear, d'uh. "figuring out who to keep safe", easy to say, hard to do. joe yet again just claims he will do things yet offers no concrete ideas on what that'll look like
Safe and effective treatment can help manage the risk of the coronavirus. But of course, the only complete solution is finding a vaccine to extinguish the threat it poses. Scientists are making great strides on this, but discovering and testing a vaccine is only the first step: Manufacturing sufficient doses and distributing it to reach everyone is a huge challenge. The Trump administration should already be reporting to the American people on its efforts.
"give a report on progress", yes, good idea.
As we prepare to reopen America, we have to remember what this crisis has taught us: The administration’s failure to plan, to prepare, to honestly assess and communicate the threat to the nation led to catastrophic results. We cannot repeat those mistakes.
yes, planning is important
We know what we have to do. We have the tools, expertise and, now, hard-won experience. The American people have already paid too high a price in illness, death and economic loss. This time, the White House has to get it right.
we know what we have to do
we very clearly don't, as is shown by how fucking vague and obvious everything in this op-ed is. i hope to god that his back end plan has any level of specifics beyond "seat people further apart at work"
That is a valid critique, but you have to consider the context.
You dismissed a lot of the article as “d'uh“ and common sense steps, but that is exactly what most people are looking for. Sure, this sub and others would like detailed and wonky proposals, but the average American mostly wants a leader that will listen to experts and take responsibility. A lot of people feel like Trump won’t take common sense actions if they don’t benefit him politically, and one of Biden’s greatest opportunities is to use that to draw a contrast.
Joe's got a plan for that
In this article he links to Bill Gates' Op-Ed and Elizabeth Warren's. It's not big, but it's a nice bit of outreach. Bring Elizabeth into the tent!
For those only reading the text pasted above, it's in the quote:
But we can’t stay home and just wait for the vaccine to arrive. As others have noted, we need to build a bridge from here to there. Here’s what our national strategy should look like.
Joe should probably have stayed quiet during this crisis. Now if doesn't go as poorly as experts expect he's on the hook as a "scaremonger" while "Trump was right" (he wasn't). Meanwhile the benefit is pretty minimal as most people won't read his plan. Unnecessary risk.
Stay quiet until the general really kicks off Joe.
Real leaders need to lead sometimes, even if it's risky.
If you think most people won't read it anyway, there's really no reason not to release a statement like this.
I like it, as it demonstrates how Joe will operate as a president. I'm also not surprised that he's talking a bit about what a president should and should not do, as 10-20% of Obama's workload was given to Joe to complete while Joe was VP.
I also think the advice was not given with political divides in mind. It was put there so that the people who did read it would take it (and perhaps some ideas from it) and see the path out of this mess.
Havent 10,000 people died
21,698 deaths so far in the US. 113,672 worldwide.
Predictions were 100k to 200k early (with outliers as high as 2mio) and are now down to 20-30k.
President Trump needs to use his full powers under the Defense Production Act to fight the disease with every tool at our disposal.
🤢🤢🤢
Explain your reaction pls
Firstly, Trump has indeed been using the DPA to ruinous effect.
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/03/the-defense-production-act.html
"But... If $OURGUY was in charge, he'd do the right thing!" That's not how this works, the efficacy of institutions should not be dependent on saints being in charge. If you want to give the government a power when your guy is in charge but not when the other guy is in charge, it's a bad idea.
It would be much better to let the markets work and reduce regulatory barriers to producing and importing masks.
If the DPA has any role at all, it is in guaranteed purchase agreements through title III - but almost nobody clamoring for the DPA ever mentions this, they just want nationalized production.
Sour guy?
$ is a symbol denoting a variable in many computing languages
It's three sad green emojis.
I agree, the Defense Powers Act is unnecessary and has caused this country more harm than good. 3M and GM were already making masks and ventilators the sole use of the DPA was to prevent exports (hurting the global poor and destroying our relations with other countries) and to put Trumpists in "oversight" positions at private companies.
Meanwhile disrupting actually valuable work.
“My plan to safely cover up my sexual assault defenses and feebly lose the 2020 election”
He's the most lucid man with dementia on the planet. /s
An infinite number of dementia victims on typewriters would eventually produce a coherent disaster response plan?
I doubt biden wrote this. That's not a slight against him, but this isn't proof of anything (and I also think this article is super weak)
What makes you doubt Biden wrote this?
Candidates and politicians rarely write their own op-eds. It comes from their staff, whether it’s the campaign staff or official office staff. Depending on the level of office, a member of Congress might give the final go-ahead to publish a piece and make edits. In a presidential campaign, especially one for the former Vice President, he will have upper level staff who can give final approval on their own.
There are a litany or reasons why the “dementia” theory is absolute BS. Still, in this case, the reality is that there’s pretty much no chance that Biden took pen to paper and wrote this. This is still his plan, but the communications side is handled by an entire team dedicated to making consistent and clear messaging
Source: have worked/interned on campaigns and in Congress, and I drafted letters/articles like this myself
[removed]