r/OOTP•
primeclock

Just got fired in 5 years, what’s the fastest you’ve been fired as a GM?

Beyond shocked and contemplating deleting this save because of it. I was the White Sox in 1991, doing a sim where I don’t trade Sammy Sosa. Won 90+ games in 91, 92, 93, and 94, but only made the playoffs in 94. I extended my core long term (Thomas, Sosa, McDowell, Ventura locked in until 2000 season). I started the 95 season and had owner goals that weren’t feasible because I had no money for free agents or extensions. We only won 70 games and I was promptly fired. Has this ever happened to anyone? I feel like the game would give me some leeway because of my initial success.

Posted Apr 14, 2020, 3:08 PM UTC

2331
[deleted]•

Virtual owners don't care about your problems, even if it's their fault. Here's a tiny budget, but you better give an extension to the 32 year-old wanting 20+ million a season for 10 years.

37
ThePillowmaster•

Don't forget, he's wrecked, which only drives his value up further.

13
jakewoodburn•

Oh, and he’s outspoken/selfish? Well not my problem he’s ruining your clubhouse! Go win 100 games or you’re fired!

7
victorwithclass•

You really should turn owner goals off, they are a sloppy and terribly designed part of the game that make no sense

2
chr3lthorp•

Idk they seem like real life owners lol. Make unreasonable demands and won’t chalk up any more cash until you go 162-0 for fifty years in a row with 50 rings

2
victorwithclass•

I mean no real life owner cares that much about steals or upgrading certain position

-3
metatron207•

First of all, it sucks and I feel your pain, but it's not too unrealistic. Expectations are expectations. The Red Sox did collapse at the end of 2011, but they still won 90 games and finished one game out of the postseason. Their HoF executive and manager (Theo and Tito) had led them to two championships and vanquished the Curse of the Bambino, and in Epstein's nine-year tenure (Francona came in one year later) they had six seasons of 95+ wins, with the others being 90, 89, and 86. They finished 1st or 2nd six times, and made the playoffs six times. And then the Sox let both of them go.

As for OOTP, my record is having been cut after one season of a Mariners rebuild. This was in OOTP 17 or 18. I traded Cano and managed to get some decent prospects while getting rid of a good chunk of his contract. Traded most of the big contracts away and, with a good draft, some IFA luck, and a couple of good scouting finds, managed to stock up the farm to the point it was an easy Top 3 farm. Met most of the owner's goals, and the yearly performance one was "don't suck completely." I had made a couple of decent veteran signings and the team vastly overperformed for two months, taking a division lead into June before everyone regressed. The owner was thrilled at midyear, and the team finished with a respectable ~70 wins.

Then, just as the regular season wrapped up and I was looking at arb decisions, I got the call that I was gone. And somehow all that work hadn't translated to a good enough rep to be a GM with another major-league team, so I ended up in Korea for the next season, watching all those prospects kill it. The kicker is that the team traded several of them away and continued being the Mariners. I could have taken pleasure in watching them fail, but it gutted me to not see what could have been.

29
jakewoodburn•

Think I got fired in 3 or 4 with a marlins sim. Didn’t improve much year over year and kept losing top prospects to injuries.

I was going to delete it and restart anyway, so it was more of a relief than anything. Put me out of my misery, so to speak lol

5
BougieFruitLoops•

I think I went 2 or 3 (decent, improving) seasons with the As in OOTP18 before I got fired. Immediately got a job with the AL-leading Twins, who had a much larger budget.

4
FriarFriary•

Got fired a quarter of the way thru my second year with the expansion '77-'78 Mariners in OOTP 16. Brutal.

3
better_off_red•

Not exactly the same, but I've seen managers coming off multiple consecutive championships not have their contracts renewed. OOTP owners can be brutal.

2
haunthorror•

Honestly sounds realistic. Sounds like you used up all your budget. Signed vets to long extensions and so when you should you be contending only win 70 games.

2
MMAPhreak21OOTP 17•

All around me are familiar computer voices reasons to turn can’t be fired on...

2
wollam11•

I turned the owner's ability to do that off.

Poof! The pressure is gone.

2
joeysportsfan98•

I got fired in 2 years with the White Sox after putting up seasons of 82-80 in 2020 and then 76-85 in 2021 (I was fired with one game left). Luckily for me, I won the 2022 Japan Series with Hokkaido, so it ended up working out pretty well.

2
smiles134•

I got fired two years into my Brewers sim in 2015 once

1
EskettiMySpaghetti•

I said in another thread on this subreddit that there’s virtually no use for owner goals because they are completely unreasonable, et cetera

Turn them off, and don’t turn them back on

1
pjokinen•

Smh, how could they fire you after locking down Jessie “The Body” Ventura? /s

For real though that does suck

1
hetubirdGM extraordinaire •

I was fired four years into a rebuild of the Red Sox. Shedded all the contracts of Mookie, Xander and Sale and such to try and build a league leading farm system and team built around Devers, Chavis and Jay Groome.

In four years the FA market was nearly nonexistent, at least within my budget. Groome flamed out and Chavis was really really poor. I think I finished dead last three of the four years and they got restless because I couldn’t hit the goals despite doing whatever I could.

I did, however, built a top-3 minors system that put the team in the playoffs two years after I was canned. Four years removed, they won the AL pennant with a rotation of guys I drafted.

Go figure.

1
jord362•

That's how it be sometimes. Honestly feels crazy realistic.

1
REMFan87•

I just got fired after 6 with the Tigers. Promoted Matt Manning, Casey Mize, Daz Cameron, and Koby Clemens, who all did very well for me. Drafted Emerson Hancock first overall in 2020, and he turned into an absolute stud. Also traded for Xavier Fernandez (C) and Brian McAuliffe (3B/DH), and tons of other minor leagues that panned out at least temporarily, giving up next to nothing in return (because, hey....I'm GM of the Tigers...what the hell did I even have to give?).

We won 70+ each year from 2020 to 2025, but that wasn't good enough for Ilitch. Instantly had four or five job offers and decided Arizona was the best one (fewest cumbersome future contracts, good draft position, most years guaranteed). But I'm missing my kitties too much, so now I'm prepping to just scratch it and start over with a new save with Pittsburgh.

1
cit96•

What year did Miggy retire? For me, luckily, he did after the first year, and so I had nearly $50 million to spend in FA, and spent it on good but not great veterans, and finished with 79 wins, 4 games out of the wild card.

The following year we missed out again due to losing to the Angels in Game 163, and so finished 85-77. By this point many of the veterans were gone, but I had a decent core with Manning having developed to the point of being a true ace, but Mize wasn't there yet.

The next year we finally made it in as 90 win AL Central champs, and Mize stepped up, at least when he wasn't injured. We lost 3-2 to the reigning champion Rays in the DS, who had made it to back to back Fall Classics and went on to make it three in a row, only to lose to the Dodgers who finally broke their 45 year drought!

Going into next season I just signed my third ace-calibre pitcher in Lucas Giolito to an incredibly team friendly contract (22m a year for four years and he's only turning 30 next season), but I am a bit concerned that I still don't have the offensive firepower, as Alex Kiriloff was our best by a decent margin in that department last year with 32 HRs, 111 RBIs, 4.7 WAR and a joint AL best 198 hits. I managed to trade for some top prospects on the verge of the bigs last year, the best of which being Isaiah Henry, an outfielder who starts off with a 2 star potential, but developed to the point of being the no. 1 overall prospect with elite speed, power, and RF defense. I got him at 2.5/4.5 CA/PA, and by Spring Training the following year he's now 3.5/5.0, so hopefully he'll take the lead for me with the bat especially, as I haven't been able to afford any free agent bats, as the market is weak as it always seems to be in OOTP21.

1
REMFan87•

Not until after 2022, unfortunately. And only then because I released him mid-season. I felt bad, but he was just taking up a roster spot at that point....he went 0 for 7 his last year...there was literally no worse way I could be spending $30 million and no way at all I could trade him.

It's my fault, though....Miggy I could have recovered from....but the damn Tigers were above or very near .500 through the first 100 games in each of like, my final three seasons, and I drank my own kool-aid. I brought in Soler, Abreu, Javier Baez and Josh Bell in deadline deals in the later years, plus lots of relievers that I can't remember (Brandon Workman was one...he ended up doing really well for me). Almost none of them performed up to their "pre-trade" levels. Plus, the game had a vendetta against my starting pitchers....it seemed like I could literally never have Manning, Mize, and Hancock all healthy and in the rotation at the same time, and if I did, one of them was guaranteed to be a diarrhea-bomb of under-performance....like, literally getting torched every start even after having been all-star caliber for their entire career beforehand. It was maddening.

Ah, well. I just finished simming year one of my Pirates save. 63-99, but managed to trade Polanco and some others and have already bumped my farm system from I think #11 before I started to #8 now. The owner wants top-6 (and a .500 season in 2021 lmfao), so he's happy with me....for now, at least...

1
cit96•

Yep I have the exact same issue with my starters, I should have the best rotation in the majors with some good young starters in the 4 and 5 spots, but both of them ended up being out for the season by July. Giolito missed the first two months of the season and has struggled since returning, but Mize and Manning have both been pretty good, though neither look like serious contenders for the Cy Young Award with 50 games to go.

I've tended to avoid making many trades, partly due to not wanting to upset the fans, and partly due to wanting players that were disappointing to correct their course and get to where they should be again. However, this season I decided to give up on Nate Lowe and Joe Jimenez, as Lowe had struggled to live up to his first season with me, and while Jimenez was great every other season, this year his ERA has been stuck around about 7.00. I got back Ronald Guzman for Lowe and Seranthony Dominguez for Jimenez, as both were performing better for their teams while being on the verge of free agency rather than on longer deals, and there was a decent prospect or two as well.

Other than that, the aforementioned two young SPs were obtained for a 23 year old Japanese starter who my scout assured me was only 3.0/3.0 CA/PA, even though other teams would take him for apparently better players. He has of course improved to 3.5/4.0 since leaving, but so long as the two guys I got don't regress I'll still be better for it. Last year I traded Spencer Torkelson, who I'd taken first overall in 2020, as despite being a 3.0/4.0 player he struggled to bat above .200 and OPS+ of around 60, and struckout like nobody's business. I got Henry in that deal and also Heston Kjerstad, who was batting like an all-star at KC, and although he struggled to live up to that level the rest of the year, he's been a worthy first time all-star this year.

Good luck with the Pirates! I've never managed them in OOTP, but I might try it at some point this year.

Update: My closer and Giolito have both gotten season ending injuries a day or so apart, this is too much at this point, the default level of injury regularity or severity really needs adjusting by the devs.

1
REMFan87•

The Pirates are treating me much better. I gave up Joe Musgrove and a no-named from the low minors (you know one of those half-star reliever types that the AI wants you to throw in to make a deal work?). I don't remember all of what I got back from the Phillies, but one was Adam Haseley, an outfielder who is currently leading the NL (and majors) with a .369 average (in 2021) and second to Bellinger in WAR. I also got Anthony DeSclafani, who has pitched out of his mind for my team, and Carl Edwards Jr. from the Mariners...he instantly took over as closer and has been really, really good.

All said and done, after a mediocre April and May I had gone 8-18 in June. Figured it was another crap pile I should burn up, but then we went on an absolute tear out of the break. At one point I looked and we were 31-12 post AS Break. It's not as good now, as we are currently in the midst of a late season swoon (crapping the bed at home against the Reds and Royals, two of the worst teams in the Majors), and will probably miss the wild card altogether (I'm in the middle of a series with the Brewers, who lead us by 2.5 games. We've already won one and lost the other, and now the game is deciding to do its obnoxious thing where it goes nonresponsive for six hours waiting to sim to the next day). We got win #81 yesterday, though, so it's a winning season. Will just be decision time in the offseason on whether I think we really are good enough to contend (in which case I'll try for some more free agents), or it was a fluke (in which case I'll stay the course of trading anybody and everybody I can).

1
REMFan87•

And yeah, the injury frequency setting-- while ostensibly accurate to real MLB-- is absolutely insane, in my opinion. I'm out Jameson Taillon this year, and won't bring him back because he's too expensive now and he hasn't even pitched enough for me to determine if he's actually good still or totally shot...

1