As I start my second week of meditation twice daily I have noticed something odd.

Typically I wake up and meditate within an hour of laying in bed on my phone. I try to do at least 10minutes but I regularly aim for, and complete, 20 minutes of meditation.

Now I wanted to wait a bit longer before asking about this but it continues to happen during my sessions and I wonder how I should approach this situation.

I practice focus meditation and recite the words “in, out” in accordance with my breathing. I practice good posture and general relaxation while letting my thoughts flow but always returning and keeping my prime focus on the breath

Now my issue comes from when I feel deep in thought but there is no thought. There is no thinking, my mind is blank and I find that I wasn’t even thinking about my breath at that point.

I’m not sure how to approach it because my mind truly feels empty until the moment I become aware and start “thinking” again. In the moments leading up to that I don’t know what is going through my mind, if anything. Like I said, at that point it feels like my mantra (the “in, out”) isn’t even being recited or focused on.

So yeah, am I losing focus? Is a completely empty mind detrimental to a session just like ruminations would be?

I feel like in general I should continue practicing and honing my focus to the breath.

I have just found it very odd that now sometimes I’m not fighting my thoughts trying to drown out the mantra. Sometimes now, I feel like I am fighting or maybe ‘competing’? Against a void, a lack of thought.

Again, this happens very briefly and I have no idea how long this “blank” time period lasts but it’s not incredibly long stretches of time either.

Posted Apr 14, 2020, 9:27 PM UTC

317
BenIsProbablyAngry•

I think you are one of many people who makes meditation into something it is not, something that is far more complicated than it needs to be.

The hardest thing about meditation, especially for westerners, is to not try and "do it right". There is no goal or objective in meditation; it is moving from trying to "solve problems" into simply "being".

When you let yourself simply "be", you may find there are a rush of thoughts in your mind. You may find that there are no thoughts. You may find a myriad of things. But none of these are correct and none of these are wrong; the awareness of that which you'd not normally be aware is the meditation.

A lot of this comes from the fact most people are very reticent to learn from a book, and instead simply start "meditating" without really having understood what they are doing. Much like somebody who starts trying to play the violin having never taken a lesson, the result is less than harmonious.

I recommend choosing a book and taking a course that spans weeks or months (usually weeks). I personally think you've quite deeply misunderstood the point of meditation and have perhaps dragged a lot of the problems you are trying to solve with meditation into your "practice".

5
MK-KF•

Yes I have to agree with your reply. The OP is making meditation something it is not.

I learned how to Meditate from Headspace which has a basic 30 day course to learn the fundamentals of meditation. The metaphor that Headspace uses is that meditation is like us sitting at the side of the road, watching the traffic go past. Each car represents a thought. Some days the traffic will be busy and others it will be quiet. The point is not to get caught up in the traffic but to allow it to come and go. If you get distracted, acknowledge that you're distracted and come back into the present.

The focus should always be 'being' in the present. If that involves focusing on the breath and your mind is completely empty then that is fine.

Meditation works around you. Not the other way around.

3
BenIsProbablyAngry•

Hopefully he takes the suggestion of the app better than the book.

Though I have a feeling the true aversion is to learning, not just books or apps.

2
DarkHa1eOP•

I’m not sure if I agree with your line of thinking. It is true, I have not picked up a book or heavily researched or studied a specific type of meditation. As I’ve been going along and committing to it I try to learn more and more. I think some aspects of meditation are extremely confusing to westerners but that isn’t wrong. That’s not because I’m trying to project my problems into my meditation.

The way you describe meditation sounds closer to vipassana. Which again, I have no deeper knowledge but vipassana was more about letting go and growing. Allowing yourself to simply “be”.

From my understanding, focus meditation is the other side of the coin. Called Samatha meditation I guess? I’m meditating to bring focus and discipline into my life. I have heard it can help with anxiety, depression, and adhd.

While I’m not opposed to reading books on meditation; I wanted to practice and get comfortable with it first. Essentially, in my mind, narrowing my focus, and becoming more disciplined would be beneficial only after I’ve established a routine and settled on the type of meditation to practice. Buying a book about vipassana meditation while I practice Samatha wouldn’t be as beneficial if I had just bought a Samatha book instead.

So again, during my meditation sessions: I focus on my breathing and I find lapses of time where there are no thoughts flowing and there is no conscious focus on the breathing/mantra. Whether or not it is good or bad I am just looking for guidance on how to approach this situation.

Everything I have gathered from focus meditation informs me to bring all my focus to the point of breathing and reciting that mantra. Acknowledge thoughts and allow them to pass always returning to the breath

My question is specifically about what I’m supposed to do when I encounter a complete lack of thought. When all train of thought disappears and I come back to consciousness I have been returning to the breath. Because that’s what I was told to do when a thought interrupted my mantra.

My broader question might be if anyone else experienced or experiences this during their focus meditation sessions?

2
BenIsProbablyAngry•

Like I said, a person who tries to meditate having not learned it is like a person who tries to play the violin without taking a lesson.

A lot of what you wrote looks to me like misunderstanding, and I think you should note the fact I was able to state with confidence that you'd never read a book even though you've never told me that.

If you feel it is helping then great. But to me, that looks far chaotic.

2
DarkHa1eOP•

I don’t feel chaotic. But after weeks of acknowledging thoughts and returning to my breathing it feels weird. Complete blanks in thought / memory feels peaceful but again I wonder if that is helpful or detrimental for focus meditation.

It’s just something I haven’t encountered and I can’t find any information on “blank minds” except for the common saying “empty your mind”.

2
BenIsProbablyAngry•

See that is what worries me. Acknowledging thoughts and returning to them is a good first step in mindfulness but in the course I followed ("Mindfulness" by Mark Williams and Danny Penman) what you are describing is just one of the fundamental meditations in just one of the weeks and by now you'd have advanced far beyond that, all the way slowly building an understanding of the practice and expanding into new types of awareness.

Along the way of this steady build up I think you'd have had your question answered in such a way that you'd never have had to ask it like you have here. I think your question is more "error in how you are thinking about mindfulness as a whole" then true issue with meditation.

I strongly recommend that book. I don't mean to be insulting but I think you are quite far away into a place you'd never have gone with expert guidance

2
LostInNew•

How early have you been getting up and meditating? Just curious

1
DarkHa1eOP•

Between 8 and 12pm. I try to meditate before 12 so that I can consider it a “morning” meditation haha.

1
LostInNew•

Haha oh man that’s relatable.

I’m not perfect at this but I’ve been shifting my schedule around to do it really early and ive noticed a Huge difference. I’ve been going to bed around 9:30Pm and been waking up around 4:30am-5 then meditating. It’s hard to put into words but the effects are worth it.

2
Pieraos•

is a completely empty mind detrimental to a session

Not at all, transcending is one of the goals of meditation - if it comes about easily and naturally. You should read more widely :-) In your case I especially suggest good instruction in Hong-Sau meditation.

1
DarkHa1eOP•

What is Hong Sau?

And yes it happens naturally. The moment I realize that I wasn’t “thinking” about anything I return all my focus to my breath.

1
Pieraos•

What is Hong Sau?

Google it. Also this page might be of interest.

1