Complete Limited Set Review [Community Content]

Hello LR listeners. I'm sure some of you are like me and you read/listen to multiple reviews during release season to get several opinions on the set. I just finished up my personal reviews for the set. If you're interested, please take a look!

WHITE: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review-white.html

BLUE: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review-blue.html

BLACK: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review-black.html

RED: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review-red.html

GREEN: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review-green.html

MULTICOLOR/COLORLESS/ARTIFACT/LANDS: https://www.vanisarisgaming.com/2020/04/ikoria-limited-set-review.html

Thanks for any views and feedback. I appreciate it and I look forward to discussing what I may have gotten right or wrong in the future.

Posted Apr 15, 2020, 9:39 PM UTC

310
Kargoth3•

Disagree on void beckoner being unplayable. You won't cast the creature often but the cycle ability is good. More expensive than blade brand but it has multiple upsides compared to it. Oppenent cant deny the draw by killing the creature and if you don't have a play you can just give something death touch and cycle it. It's also very strong with any first strike creatures.

It's also good with reanimate effects especially the black/green fight one.

7
SampleScreenNameOP•

That's a good point. I hope I'm wrong about that one since it is a really cool card.

1
super_fluous•

As everyone has said Void Beckoner isn't unplayable. Probably a D. But what sticks out to me is the next card, Whisper Squad, you have a D. That card is really unplayable. I wouldn't want any number of 1 mana 1/1s in my deck that can't mutate even if I could get a 'free' 1/1 for 2 mana

4
Crystal__•

I don't think Squad is unplayable, you just need to be the only one drafting them in the table. Few decks will want it, so if the former happens, it's also very likely that the bread and butter BW human archetype cards like Seargeant, Deadeye, Commando, Patagia Tiger are showing up late. But especially if you can pickup 1-2 Sanctuary Lockdown. Or perhaps BR sacrifice with Poacher/Weaponize/Mutual/Bastion, etc. I think it will be common for exactly one player to be looking for them, and nobody else. 3-4 in the deck is the sweet spot probably.

3
super_fluous•

Possibly. I’m not sure how strong the go wide deck will be. But is 2 mana to get a tapped 1/1 where the deck wants to be? It’s a lot worse than squadron hawk for example

2
SampleScreenNameOP•

Void Beckoner would likely be a D if I were to regrade it, yeah. It's still clunky but it does have a use. Once I thought of it more like Bladebrand I could see that it has some potential. Especially since you can bring it back to the Battlefield with a few effects. However, there are better options for resurrection effects too.

As for Whisper Squad, I have it as a D since I could see potential use for it in a go-wide or sacrifice deck. By that metric I maybe should have just given it an F and then a D synergy grade though. It's definitely not a good card so I wouldn't be against it just being an F in most people's books.

1
tomscud•

Nice! I think you're wrong on Void Beckoner, and it's in the C to C+ range - a 3 mana cantrip to give a dude deathtouch is pretty good, and randomly occasionally getting to cast a humongous monster in the very late game or use a reanimation spell on it is a bonus. I also think Unbreakable Oath is a C or so, because there are a fair amount of fatties with cycling, so it will be somewhat more likely that you'll be able to use it on curve to get something good.

2
SampleScreenNameOP•

Yeah I think I agree with you and Kargoth on Void Beckoner. I wasn't thinking correctly about how it really worked as a combat trick I guess. I somehow blanked out that you would still be getting a card back so it's basically like a trade that you had to pay 3 mana to make happen.

2
iSmartMan•

In other Limited environments, I might agree with you that Light of Hope is a sideboard card. However, when you consider that the premium common removal in White is Pacifism and the premium common removal in Blue is Capture Sphere*, then enchantment removal that can double as a mediocre combat trick starts looking more appealing in the main deck.

Also, I think you're placing too much value on 2-drop creatures, especially ones that have the Human subtype or which don't aid Mutate in some way. The average creature CMC in the set is 3.4, and none of the cheap creatures have impressive stats, so they're probably going to be quickly outclassed unless either they have a relevant ability or you're playing a go-wide deck.

Finally, I think you're undervaluing the White and Black Mentors. Vigilance and Lifelink aren't impressive at face value, but when you consider how many black cards give Lifelink counters and that Vigilance appears on more creatures than any other evergreen ability in the set, a pseudo-tribal synergy becomes a real possibility with them (especially Vigilance, if you can pick up a couple copies of Solid Footing). I also believe you're undervaluing the Green Mentor, though not as much as the Black and White Mentors. You stated that trample doesn't help win combat, but you failed to mention that the Mentor's activated ability DOES let the creatures they buff win combat. Green has the most big creatures, and not all of them have trample, so the Green Mentor makes one of your big guys into a larger threat and buffs every creature you have that can't be chump-blocked.

*Yes, an argument can be made for counting Essence Scatter as premium common removal, but Capture Sphere will still be a high pick for blue decks, so my point still stands

2
SampleScreenNameOP•

Thanks for the feedback.

I’d personally disagree with Light of Hope. You are right that it has some upside since it removes several pieces of removal but I don’t really put any bonus in the combat trick portion. I’d still consider this a sideboard card primarily unless you are in best-of-1. That doesn’t mean it’s unplayable in the sideboard though. It’s just my take on the card right now.

I do think that 2 and 3 mana creatures are very important. For the human decks you will want to get on the board so that you can support whatever your deck is trying to do. The Human decks all care about having humans in play so you need to get them down early. For the Mutate decks you just need Mutate targets. Even if they aren’t that amazing. Most of the Mutates are going to end up trumping the bottom Creature anyway and we can’t really be too picky since we may not see the best options in our draft. I know I talked about 2-drops in particular a lot but most of what I said can be said for 3-drops as well since most Mutates start at 4 mana.

As for the Mentors, I maybe could have bumped the Lifelink to a C but I don’t think that either one is much better than that grade. They do offer a lot of value because you can add some additional counters to certain Creatures. But there are also times where you won’t be able to invest that mana or you have no other Creatures in play at all. I can’t really give a B level grade to any Creature that fails to function in a vacuum and a C+ grade would mean that I think they are close to being a B so I can’t justify that grade either.

I hope that helps to clarify where I was coming from with those grades. If you still disagree I’d be glad to know some more specifics. It’s possible I missed something.

1