Upkeep is the least worst option

Discussion

There is an alternative to upkeep, one which would fit very nicely into the lore of the game, however I don't think you will want FDEV to implement it that way.

If you think about your carrier as a living breathing ship of people and services, those people need to eat, those services will require raw and manufactured goods to continue their servicing.

The alternative to a fixed fee upkeep is that you need to provide the food and other goods to your carrier - which is fine when you're in the bubble, you just set a buy price for those goods that's slightly higher than average & NPC's will happily truck in that food - sure you may need to top up your carrier every now and then so that it can afford to buy the goods, but that's probably going to come in at less than the current fixed fee.

However if you are out in the black, then you're going to need to be paying through the nose for those goods, and that's going to drain your account much faster than the current fixed fee.

I guess I'm just saying, be careful what you wish for.

Posted Apr 16, 2020, 9:31 AM UTC

010
Naddesh:thargint: Anti-Xeno Initiative Mentor•

Bullshit, upkeep is not the least worst option. Just store the carrier if person is inactive for more than 3 weeks for example...

2
dgvertz:trade: Trading•

Even using your analogy and staying in the lore of the game.

If you abandon your carrier and the crew needs to eat, they just leave the carrier when the food is gone and you have to rehire the crew when you come back.

There’s no need to take away the entire carrier and give me back only 2/3s of the money I spent on it.

2
Nettlecake•

Even worse, 1/3, or did I understand that wrong?

1
dgvertz:trade: Trading•

I thought people were getting back 3 billion? That’s 60%. I could be wrong though?

One of our biggest problems here is that too many people (like me) are commenting on it even though none of us have carriers ourselves.

1
Nettlecake•

I don't mind the upkeep, I mind that it forces me to play the game, don't care how much and that I can grind one day and be done for the year. It. Makes. Me. Need. To. Play. The. Game.

1
Naddesh:thargint: Anti-Xeno Initiative Mentor•

Ye, it is basically forcing players to play by threatening to take away their stuff.

0
oomwatOP•

But the alternative is to have fleet carriers either mostly without services all over the place, or them popping into and out of existance.

If your ship is on a fleet carrier that no longer exists, where do you appear when you log in?

If you appear and then launch, what happens to the carrier ... or do you appear floating in space ... what if you were mid-way through outfitting, logged out while you wait for a module to be transferred.

You HAVE to think about the other players, not just yourself.

-1†
Nettlecake•

The same can be said for the decommissioning of carriers, they already thought about that.

3
oomwatOP•

But decommissioned carriers are hauled back to the bubble - I imagine that when you come back to a decomissioned carrier you'd be inside the station where it was bought?

I guess that's something to test - it's not like Frontier are being transparent about it!

-2