First print - 3/4 failed to print

Troubleshooting

Hi, new to 3D printing. My Mars arrived today, with washable Elegoo resin. I decided I wanted to try and print my current DnD player's miniatures instead of the demo prints, but something went wrong.

Out of 4 miniatures, only 3 printed - the other 3 left solid chunks at the bottom of the vat. My question is, any idea why this happened? They all had the same raft/pad size and curve, all were put 5mm above the bed and all had supports.

This is what it looked like in Chitubox (after adding raft/supports in PrusaSlicer)

This is what printed.

This is what the vat now looks like. Can anyone also give me advice on how to get this off, it seems stuck tight and I don't want to scratch it? (I do have 2 extra vats just in case, but obviously being the first print I don't want it to be out of use immediately).

I've also heard putting a bit of RainX on the inside of the vat is a good idea to help stop it from sticking. Can anyone recommend this, or know it's a bad idea?

Thanks for the help.

Posted Apr 16, 2020, 8:40 PM UTC

220
CrimmsonWind•

Before you start doing any of the little tricks, what are your settings? Incorrect settings seems like the most likely culprit, I'm not seeing anything obviously wrong with the models.

Edit: the one thing I will say is if you're going to use chitubox's supports, use medium or heavy, don't use light. It looks like you might be using the light supports. They aren't very strong and parts seem to break away and fail easily.

To get them off, fill the vat with water since you're using the water washable, it should help loosen them up as you (carefully) pick at it with a gloved fingernail. If you can get under one edge it should pop off pretty easily. You can also gently push from the other side of the film to help loosen it.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

I'm using the default grey resin Chitubox settings, which do fit in with the water-washable settings (60s first layer, 8s after that). The recommended is 20-60s first, 5-15s second.

For the support, I'm using PrusaSlicer at 74% density (I've been told that 100% can be a bit too overbearing on smaller models). I didn't change any other settings with the supports, but did add the raft/pad with a 45 degree angled wall to make it easier to pop those off.

1
CrimmsonWind•

To be honest I'm not sure where you heard prusaslicer can go overboard on supports. Chitubox goes nuts with the amount of supports it autogenerates but everyone I've seen who recommends prusaslicer gives it credit for not doing that, lol. I use the 100% supports in prusaslicer and print almost exclusively minis right now, the only issues I ever have are when people use notoriously difficult poses from heroforge, and it's just a matter of using some nippers so I don't snap a character's ankle. I also add more supports on that upper unsupported section of the base, because otherwise it flattens out. You may want to try 100% at some point although I don't feel confident saying that's the issue in this case because it looks like they didn't even start on the failed ones.

You're within the temperature range albeit on the bottom half of it but that's probably not the problem.

Wipe down the build plate so it's nice and clean before you start another print, to make sure there's no residue messing with the adhesion. Try re-leveling it with an empty vat (no resin in it). Make sure the screws and the top knob are tightened down. If they were loose then the plate could have been wiggling slightly which eventually caused the prints to break away from the plate.

It could be the FEP film just needed to kind of "break in" and if you want you can try printing it again, just pause it like 30 minutes in to check if it's staying on the plate or not.

I really don't like recommending that people start doing tricks and mods right away, there's almost always some root cause that's fixable and the printer should work as intended. There's no reason to introduce even more variables right at the start. Not to say factory issues don't happen, but I know a few regular users on here have never had to tricks like the tape and the PTFE oil. It almost always just comes down to a bit of trial and error. Once you get your settings dialed in for your particular environment, you should be golden. Try some of these and report back and we'll try to get you sorted.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

Yeah I don't think the supports are to blame, because it made it no further than the raft/pad, it's not like part of the miniature snapped off. That said, I will try 100% supports next time.

It's 11pm here now, so I won't be able to try again until tomorrow - but I definitely will try again tomorrow. Thank you.

1
CaptainTruelove•

Push the failed prints from behind. The FEP is flexible and it should raise them enough to get a finger underneath to peel OR pop off in its entirety.

As to why it failed that could be a multitude of reasons.

Have you done the rook test print yet?

What print settings does the resin say to use.

Is your bed level?

Did you calibrate?

What’s the temperature of the space you are using?

Edit: now assuming all of that is kosher if I had to guess I would think your exposure times are too low to get consistent prints.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

To answer your questions;

  • Rook: No. I didn't want to waste time with printing something I'm just going to throw out, so I went for a fairly simple-ish miniature.

  • Resin: Elegoo Water-Washable Grey

  • Print Settings: I've gone with the default on Chitubox, which fits within the resin settings recommended for this resin. 60s first layer, 8s after that.

  • Bed: As far as I'm aware, yes. I definitely did that part of the setup.

  • Calibrate: Maybe? I followed the manual but there was nothing about calibration?

  • Temp: 20-21C

I'll have to try to get the stuff off the FEP tomorrow. I've got it back on the printer with the lid on. Or do I need to get it off now? (trying to save gloves for now..)

1
CaptainTruelove•

I know the rooks are boring but they are good for making sure you have everything set up correctly before wasting resin on more intricate models that fail to print. If you decide to print the rook just give it to a friend they’ll think it’s neat.

As for the failed prints you should be fine to leave them. If you rinsed the vat out with water then you should probably remove them so it doesn’t cure to the FEP creating a dead spot for printing (though it might pop off easier, I don’t use water washable resin).

20-21C should be fine though it is on the lower end of the operating temperature range. So it could be a part of the problem. So bumping up your bottom exposure to 65-70 might help mitigate the colder temperature.

Edit: spelling

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

I'll take a look at the inital time tomorrow. Thanks.

1
Hawkbass5•

The rooks are a waste of time and resin. I would up your initial layers to 65 seconds. It looks like they just came off the build plate.

0
ShadowReaperTOP•

I'll take a look at it tomorrow, thank you.

1
_ireadthings•

If part of them are adhering properly and another section isn't, it's a leveling issue most likely. I went through that exact same process at first until I got my leveling done properly. No more issues now.

1
ShadowReaperTOP•

Nah, it's literally the base clearly stuck to the FEP and so didn't print any further from there. The one miniature that did print was absolutely fine.

1
_ireadthings•

Yeah, that can be caused by improper leveling. What you described is exactly what I dealt with at first until I figured out how to level it properly. Edit: replied with a more detailed response.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

I followed the guide that came with the printer; piece of paper (A4 wouldn't fit so I cut it down a bit) loosen the 2 screws, bring it down to the bottom with the button, hold it still and then tighten the screws. It didn't seem central to the screen, but it was otherwise flat (as far as I'm aware).

If you say that you figured out how to do it "properly" - any advice?

1
_ireadthings•

How are you holding it still? The guides I watched said to press down on the big bolt holding the plate to the arm, which never worked for me. Then I saw a video where the person spread their left hand out across the plate itself, and pressed down firmly (with printer paper between the plate and screen) while tightening. I started doing that (and by firmly, I mean straining somewhat with my left hand, being careful to spread out the pressure), and after cranking down on the bolts, I would test by trying to pull the paper out.

The best results I get are when the paper won't pull out with light to moderate force, on either side. If one side is looser than the other, then you're not level. If it slides loosely out evenly, some people say that's fine, but it doesn't work reliably in my experience.

2
_ireadthings•

When you're dealing with fractions of millimeters, even the slightest offset will cause what you're experiencing. Having part of the print stick and part not can mean that the part of the plate not sticking is the tiniest bit higher than the part sticking. Thus, the cured resin doesn't get a chance to cure to the build plate on that side, while the side that's slightly closer absolutely will adhere to the plate. Result: what you're getting.

I've spent the last few weeks running my printer 24/7 and leveling was my biggest foe. I had a ton of multi-section prints where some of them would always stick and the others wouldn't. I went through literally every single possible solution, thinking my leveling was fine. I replaced the z-axis grease, replaced the FEP, tried various types of lube for the FEP, upped the temperature in the room, etc. That particular problem you're describing came down to one thing, in the end: leveling.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

In that case, besides for following the user guide with the paper, any advice on levelling it properly?

1