Has the Ten Club ever taken any action against merchandise exploitation?

So obviously, Pearl Jam is a massive brand by this point in time that draws the attention of exploitative product flippers, whether it be dealings with tickets, merchandise, or music bootlegs (CDs and vinyl in the days of old, with a current resurgence of vinyl bootlegging). I acknowledge and understand the free market arguments, but when it comes to eBay sellers utilizing Ten Club accounts to acquire and flip very limited edition merchandise, the most recent example of which being the Gigaton Image Viewer, it really puts a damper on my fan club pride/enthusiasm/etc... I don't know if the viewer mabob was put up for sale before the April newsletter release, but I do know that it was completely sold out 2 hours afterwards. Not that it's something I particularly wanted myself, but having them already listed as pre-sales on eBay for 3 times or more the original price simultaneous to that rapid sell out, it's pretty disgusting. It happens with literally every limited edition merchandise they put out, and as a band that once sued Ticketmaster and decided to release nearly every single live show in significant part to undercut illegal bootleg sales, I think it's safe to say those sorts of flipping tactics are not something they would appreciate their club being used for. For what it's worth, the instance where this legitimately kicked me in the nuts was that black flag previously released something like... two, three years ago? It was the most welcome surprise when they put out an additional release of that, but unfortunately the eBayers had already already gotten their share at that point. If demand on certain items allows those sort of price-gouged margins to exist on new, recently released merchandise, I would much rather the excess profits go towards the Vitalogy Foundation than some opportunistic human turd.

I know the Ten Club is willing and able to take at least some degree of enforcement on listings. If there isn't already any Ten Club policy against such merchandise resales, how could it be effectively and fairly implemented? I think something along the lines of a simple 90-180 day waiting period on specifucally limited edition resales could serve to discourage some of the flipping without overly impeding resales by fans who might fall on hard financial times and legitimately need to let go of some items. The longer the wait time, the more intrusive it becomes to the flipper (and fans, unfortunstely). Basic implementation could stick to simple listing removal, while simple serializing/numbering of product packaging could actually help to identify the actual Ten Club accounts being used for flipping. That sort of system might not be perfect, but I'm not one to bitch without offering solution.

Does anybody have other suggestions as to how the issue could be improved? Alternatively, are any of you not bothered by the use of Ten Club memberships for item flipping, and care to share why I should take a chill pill on the matter?

Apologies for random misspellings or auto corrected words, typing paragraphs on a smart phone sucks...

Posted Apr 17, 2020, 11:11 PM UTC

34
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
DerpsquireOP•

So... using a Ten Club membership to obtain their exclusive merchandise and putting it up immediately on an auction site at a 300-400% price increase, very likely to be purchased by another Ten Club, isn't exploitation? That's using their own fan service to rip off fans, I don't see how you couldn't consider that unethical, or at the very least, being a dick. This was just the latest in some very blatant price gouging on the secondary market for an item that had been out for only hours.

Please explain how this isn't exploitative without relying on an argument of "well, it's not stated against in any terms of service" technicality. I'm talking actual ethics here, something this band has in spades.

1
LoveBoatCaptain77•

Flipping sucks for people that miss out on having a piece of merch that they want but it certainly isn’t exploitation. While not everyone is on board, it’s not even legally questionable.

The flipping scene isn’t for me, but neither is lining up for three hours for a poster. I actually ran into multiple people at Fenway in 18 that missed the first half of the show to try and get merch. Imagine missing the actual band you’ve come to see play in order to have a t-shirt or poster that says you came to see them. Ridiculous. In all honestly,if you value you your own time at all you’re better off paying extra to a flipper to get a poster you desperately want after the show instead of waisting all your time.

Ten Club isn’t perfect by any stretch but I’m sure by now they know that most of our fan base are entitled whiners who are stuck in the past. They would never spend a minute of time on something like this. I don’t envy the crybaby bullshit they have to listen to all the time.

Think of all the stupid emails and calls they must get. The ticketing process isn’t fair (it is), tickets are too expensive (they aren’t), I’ve been a member since 19XX so I should get front row for every show I want for the rest of time (you shouldn’t), Flipping is wrong (it isn’t), there aren’t enough posters (there are), I had the losers on the forum answer my “official petition to play” insert Nowhereville town or unplayable song so the band should do it (they shouldn’t).

I love this band as much as anyone (when the tour finally takes place I’ll finish with my 39th show) but our fan base is exhausting to listen to. It’s like hearing Last Kiss at a show. You know as soon as it starts, it’s time to go take a piss.

1
DerpsquireOP•

I hadn't actually thought about it as a parallel to poster flipping, but that specific analogy helps me reconcile the issue pretty well. I quite intentionally refrained from waiting for merchandise at my first show because like hell was I going to risk missing a second of that experience to acquire anything I knew I'd probably be able to get later. Those Ten Club exclusive flippers do benefit people with a strong interest in the item who never had a hope of getting one in the first place due to other obligations on announcement day.

You made the point well enough without the condescension layered in, you don't have to be a dick about it. Besides, part of what I tried to convey at the end of my original post was that I'm open to whatever insight on the matter, rather than trying to muster a total call to arms. Myself nor any other fan should have to worry about outright ridicule for trying to discuss an issue that could be negatively affecting the fanbase.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1