Best Mustard shadows

What are your favourite mustard eye shadows? Singles or in palettes.

I'm looking for the perfect mustard to pair with olive greens. I'm leaning towards Lime Crime venus 2, but am interested in any suggestions before I go ahead.

Posted Apr 19, 2020, 9:05 PM UTC

514
BoneGnawerGirl•

I personally love the Venus 2, I also have ABH Subculture but prefer the Venus 2.

6
DaisyDoesNotOP•

Thank you, that's good to know. I have the xl2 and love it, but some of the shimmers get hard pan really easily. Are the shimmers good in it?

2
BoneGnawerGirl•

They are okay. The matte shades are really the stars, but with a pigment primer the shimmers apply well.

3
DaisyDoesNotOP•

Sounds pretty similar. The mattes are so good. I'm definitely going to pick it up. Thanks for your help

2
oopsirippedmypants•

Venus 2 is one of my favorite palettes! I recommend it. But check out paper tiger by colourpop, it’s a great single mustard yellow.

5
caylasaurus•

Was going to suggest paper tiger! It's not too intense, so it blends really nicely with other shades and brings out their mustardy tones.

3
BoneGnawerGirl•

Oh I forgot about Paper Tiger. I have it in a magnetic palette that I don't use nearly enough

3
DaisyDoesNotOP•

Thank you for the suggestions. I'm pretty sold on the venus 2. It's good to know so many people love it.

2
mamalab483•

GIVE ME GLOW COSMETICS MOTD !

$7, I love all of her shadows.

​

Also Klarity Cosmetics!

3
DaisyDoesNotOP•

I have Juicy Olive and I love it, but I'm in the UK and the shipping is a lot. Hopefully in the future I can make a huge order. Thank you

1
yesimthatlisa•

MAKE Cosmetics Satin Finish Eye Shadow in “Acid”, I found it on Amazon. At the time I bought it, it was half price. It’s a gorgeous Mustard shade.

2
DaisyDoesNotOP•

I can't find it on Amazon UK, might just be because they've removed a load of items for the time being. I'll keep an eye out. Thank you!

1
yesimthatlisa•

I definitely ordered from US Amazon - I’m sorry I didn’t realize you were from UK. I wonder if you could order online direct from Make Cosmetics. Not sure the cost difference - full price the shadow is $25 USD.

2
DaisyDoesNotOP•

I'm sure I've seen the brand on Amazon UK before. Most stuff you can get in the US is available in the UK somewhere, just have to hunt it down! It really is a lovely mustard shade.

2