Why do people like Brawl’s multiplayer more than Smash 4, even after Ultimate’s release?

All

[removed]

Posted Apr 22, 2020, 7:16 PM UTC · locked

07
BoxCon1•

I remember being in 5th grade when Brawl came out.

I wanted that game so bad

2
bosuhrhow can arm intangibility be real if dk's up tilt isn't real•

Sometimes you just gotta chaingrab a motherfucker with Falco

2
NightKev•

What people?? Where?

2
woozy--Sheik (Melee)•

They don't?

Brawl pretty much died shortly after smash 4 was announced, and nobody really looked back unless it was to play pm. People might play it more than smash 4 today because it plays very different to ultimate, whereas smash 4 is pretty much obsolete, but it's far from the popular opinion that brawl was better than smash 4 competitively

2
DragodaDragonMODStrong pocket Sandbag•

Hi u/SwitchJoycon, your post was removed for the following reason(s):

2bii) Arguments over which Smash game is better are not allowed. Posts that only serve to attack a Smash game are not allowed.


For more information on the rules of the subreddit please check this link OR please contact the moderators if you believe this to be a mistake and or have any other questions.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FlameCannonThe one guy with the opinions•

I think when people say Brawl is a better game than Smash 4, I'm not sure they're going straight into the competitive multiplayer scene is better.

Infinite chain grabs are beyond boring, ledge camping is undeniably too slow, every viable character except Meta Knight is so boring to watch. Sure, Brawl had some advanced tech that made it more rewarding to learn, but I think most people agree Smash 4 competitive multiplayer had a better run through it's life than Brawl did.

When folks argue Brawl over Smash 4, I think it's an identity thing. Brawl was the first to expand the music to be such a huge playlist. Brawl's expansive single player (while not exactly executed well) made for an experience that a lot of players hold dear to their heart. Brawl also introduced the concept of "Newcomers" being this prestigious thing, that being apart of Smash was to be apart of something big, a grand crossover.

Melee, Brawl, and Smash 4 all kind of reinvented the game along the way, meaning at the time, they all had different mechanics and a unique flair to them to make playing each of them a varied experience.

Because Ultimate kinda took Smash 4 and updated instead of doing a whole reinvention to accommodate the large roster, Smash 4 sort of lost it's identity. Smash 4 doesn't have the luxury anymore that 64, Melee, and Brawl did of having unique physics and techniques that were wildly used, but no longer available in the newest game. It's kind of Ultimate Beta, if you will.

So when people say Brawl over Smash 4, I think it's likely that they have no reason to go back to Smash 4, while they have some reason to go back to Brawl.

1
pqrslqsxSheik (Brawl)•

Brawl has some of the most technical characters in Smash history and all of its viable characters play in really unique ways (which is definitely not true in Smash 4 and Ultimate).

You've got Meta Knight with the most viable options at any given moment, ICs handoffs and desyncs, double banana Diddy, Olimar with way too many pikmin, Falco double lasers, DACUS, and chaingrab, Marth (Brawl Marth is sick), Snake with C4, mine, grenade, and DACUS, ZSS and Wario with item gimmicks, Pikachu with quick attack cancels, etc.

You're not gonna get anything like this stuff in any other smash game. Meanwhile, Ultimate characters play mostly like their Smash 4 counterparts, so why go back?

1