Dear Mozilla, I love Firefox, but recently I have stopped using it. Here's my most missed and most wanted features.
These are all my raw opinions about Firefox formed since it being my default from version 4 to 72.
Most Missed:
- Firefox Sync is amazing. It is the best Sync ever. If you don't use this you should start.
- Keyword shortcuts and searches are revolutionary.
- Extensions on Android.
- Firefox services. I can still use these whatever browser I use, but I thought I should mention how much I love the Firefox Monitor and look forward to the email aliasing.
- Firefox Awesome Bar, yes even the new big one. I like it better
- The independent powerful nature of the browser
- Generally I kinda like Mozilla ;)
- The bookmark items being able to be moved to the tab bar for my 4k display. This is amazing. I don't need a lot of tabs.
- Containers. Profiles don't work as well. Cookie Auto Delete is good for matching the privacy, but lacks the nuance.
- The light theme. If I had to use any browser's light theme it would be Firefox. I love it on macOS and use nothing else theme wise.
- The look(mostly)
- Picture in Picture
With much love it is can't all sunshine and roses.
Most Wanted:
- Speed
I have to run Nightly to get good features like Linux acceleration. Only a few platforms support WebRender. Firefox is so close here. I want to see it catch up so bad.
Slow down the animations a little too. Stuff happens before you can even move your mouse it doesn't feel natural.
- Security(Elephant in the room)
Firefox Sandbox greatly improved stability and has made the Browser a lot less buggy. However, it is a little grimmer than that.
The Firefox sandbox is still not there yet 12 years after the first browsers started getting sandboxes. Firefox still has major security holes in it's implementation of the Chromium Browser. The most painful one to swallow is the lack of any effective sandbox on Linux. My platform of choice for most of my dev work. Here is the bugzilla for this critical 5 year old issue. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1129492
Looking over the Windows code there is virtually no win32k lockdown in comparison with Chromium. Mostly fairly risky stuff like GUI calls. It is way too many to count. I have seen a few get pruned in the past year, but seriously still? This is vastly behind competitors.
While we are complaining why has Control Flow Integrity not been added for the 11 years it has been on the radar? Why has there not been a better malloc implementation? mozjemalloc is not very impressive. https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/2019-August/013990.html Issues like this leave me scratching my head on why Mozilla pushes marketing so hard
Mobile. iOS Firefox is just bad fix that user agent issue. It should track version with normal Firefox. Android has no sandbox or even a functioning multiprocess in Firefox or Firefox Preview. Chromium already has site isolation and it works very well. The remote code execution is even pushing my phone rom away from implementing security features since it would break Firefox for Android. Thanks to it's dynamic native code execution.
A small one
- The new tab page.
Edge Chromium nails this. It is perfect it asks you how much you want to see. It doesn't push it's news to hard in your face if you don't want it. It feels so inviting. The wallpapers don't hurt, but mainly the question on startup how "focused" I want it. Edge Chromium shouldn't feel more personal out of the box than the most customizable browser. Take note
Following that lets get another big one out of the way
- Privacy
Privacy is one of Firefox's key marketing points. The final straw for me was when California passed that law that had Mozilla add the feature to have your telemetry data removed. This highlighted that the epsilon of the differential privacy was too high. The way the code is written in Chrome for example there is just not enough data to link it. Firefox telemetry(while I am sure handled well) is just not anonymous enough. It also can't be fully turned off without digging into the about:config which I shouldn't have to do on a privacy centric browser. The addon recommendations in the addons settings that page uses Google Analytics and it is a protected page so my ad blocker can't even protect me. At the risk of repeating myself I shouldn't have to go into about:config to disable all telemetry.
Mozilla rubbed with the wrong way with mistakes like the advertising tests and the plugins they would add. They are on thin ice with the new marketing on privacy I hoped there would be more change on how your data was collected not just on the web, but in the browser. We have telemetry that is hard to turn off, aggressive telemetry including a background service running even when the browser is closed now to check on my default browser, we have a non privacy respecting search engine by default. I am struggling as a user who wants to be able to get up and go how Mozilla is really protecting my privacy.
I have man in the middle attacked Firefox and I didn't like what I saw. With the history of Mozilla I can't help, but have valid concerns even as a Firefox user since version 4. I can't help, but worry that Mozilla plateaued back then
---Verdict
Firefox gets so much right 12/16 things I mentioned were amazing and possibly the best in class.
I find myself mainly going for ungoogled chromium lately. I love the flag for the dark mode without an extension. I would love to go back to Firefox, but the issues especially in security are making this hard. I keep seeing a ton of 0 days for Firefox which shouldn't happen for a browser with 5% overall net market share. There is more than on Chrome and Chrome has better protections if it did run into one. Productivity and Security are my number 1 killer features. Even over privacy.
My honest opinion is that the trackers that report my market share and the telemetry that reports my market share is all off by my privacy setup. The browser I pick does not matter to me for political reasons.
Thanks for reading this far. Thanks for the great community.
Posted Apr 29, 2020, 6:59 AM UTC