[META] Results and Policy Update / Rule 2 Clarification

PinnedMeta

The results are in for the poll on Raven's Matrices. 91 total ban votes to 64 allow votes. So, Raven's Matrices are now banned.

In the same vein, most pattern/sequence-finding posts will also be removed, for the same reasons, with exceptions (if there is clearly more to the puzzle than just finding a pattern.) In particular, "find the missing/next number in this sequence" are removed because there can be infinitely many possibilities (by constructing polynomials), and they can also sometimes directly be found on OEIS.

For reference, here is the previous post:

As the sub has received an influx of submissions due to the coronavirus pandemic, we have decided to change and clarify rules.

Low-effort posts will be removed from the sub. This mostly pertains to "algebra" puzzles where pictorial variables are operated on. These puzzles often boil down to math and trying to notice tiny details.

We would like to clarify what counts as a puzzle for this sub. Puzzles must have objective answers (so logic puzzles and wordplay/crossword puzzles are allowed, as well as puzzlehunt-style puzzles.) Mazes will still be allowed because they only have one intended valid answer. This decision was made mostly because "logic puzzles" is a very narrow category, generally only referring to grid puzzles like Sudoku and Star Battle, and because "logic-based" is a vague term.

Riddles and jigsaw puzzles are still not allowed. Rebuses will be more strictly enforced. Posts like "identify these movies/characters using emojis/colors" will be removed as they are most similar to rebuses.

Mechanical puzzles (e.g. separate the pieces) and twisty puzzles (e.g. Rubik's cubes) will also be removed.

What counts as self-promotion will be decided at the mods' discretion. Note that spam does not include posting many posts to the sub, as long as they are distinct, high-quality puzzles.

Also, there is a new rule on the sub.

  1. Credit puzzle creators: If you did not make the puzzle, please try your best to credit the original source. If you are not sure of it, or have personally received the puzzle from someone, please indicate that. This rule applies more to puzzles you found online.

One type of post that sometimes pops up on this sub are IQ test-style Raven's Matrices. They are generally low effort and are often subjective (having multiple solutions that seem equally valid), but are not really fit for any other sub. So, this post is a poll to decide what we should do with these posts. The results will be announced in a week. (Note: if the Allow option has a plurality, not a majority, the more popular of the Ban options will be implemented. Ideally, this would be two questions: ban or allow, and if so, make a new sub or not.)

If you have any questions, please ask in the comments below.

Edit: Because many forms of puzzle may be borderline rule-breaking, we will generally allow them. If there is a huge influx of a specific type (such as the recent influx of "guess the character from the color scheme"-type post) we may decide to temporarily ban them.

As always, if you have any questions or request for clarification, ask in the comments.

Posted Apr 30, 2020, 2:08 AM UTC

10
pmw57•

Discussion: For Raven's matricies there is the r/ravensmatricies subreddit just waiting to be filled.

5
ev3commanderOP•

No need to put "discussion" when commenting on a post with the Meta or Not seeking solutions flair

1
pmw57•

I get caught far too often with that. Thanks for the clarification.

1
-SKBE-•

Sadly the policy updates are useless, as people still don't read the rules before posting, and there's no incentive for them to follow the rules, as they go unnoticed for hours, and lots of people post so the OPs usually get their answers. Every time I check this sub, there are a lot of posts that don't belong here.

The only way to remedy this is for the moderators to actively monitor the sub, rather than just wait until posts are reported.

1
ev3commanderOP•

We are approving and removing all posts that come through the sub. The issue is that we are busy people who need sleep, so there are multiple hour stretches without moderators on.

Also, that doesn't excuse people from not reporting posts they know are rule breaking.

3
-SKBE-•

It is not our job to moderate this sub, it is your job as moderators, so yes, it does in fact excuse people. If you cannot do the job properly, as evidenced by the constant surge of rulebreaking posts, then "hire" more moderators so that those multiple hour stretches no longer exists.

And policy updates does nothing to change the fact that people DO. NOT. READ. THE. RULES. Perhaps it would be better to manually approve every post for a trial period, to get people to read the rules in the future.

1
ev3commanderOP•

There will always be people who do not read the rules on any sub. There is no way to fully solve that issue because of new traffic. People are still breaking the spoiler rule despite it being in the sidebar, the comments of every post, and the automod message when they don't spoiler it.

Even so, you clearly do not understand the rules, assuming that you are the one mass reporting rule-abiding posts. As just one example, the recent puzzle with the title "Plus Codes I" is completely rule-abiding and was manually approved by the mods. There is one clear objective answer attainable from and encoded within the image. Other answers simply do not make sense, in contrast to riddles where different answers can be argued. It is in fact a puzzle, and not a rebus, mechanical puzzle, twisty puzzle, or jigsaw puzzle.

Even the word ladder puzzle is valid because even though there may be multiple possible paths, they are all objectively verifiable, in contrast to riddles where different people may view connections as valid or strenuous.

Edit: In addition, because we do not have more info on the solutions of puzzles beforehand, we are simply unable to judge if a puzzle really is objective or not straight from the post. We tend to allow gray area posts. Trying to solve every puzzle posted to the sub to check validity is completely unproductive.

3
Clevermore_Puzzles•

As soon as I had voted to allow raven's matricies, I happened to see a couple of them posted here that were very poor. I immediately regretted my vote, so I'm glad others had better foresight than I did.

1