Me (27f) and my housemate/bestfriend (27f) of 9 years - are they lies or misunderstandings?

Non-Romantic

I'm lucky enough to live with my bestfriend of 9 years. She's a good person, very beautiful, intelligent and supportive in personal matters.

However, there have been a few incidents which combined make me wonder if they are deliberate or not.

A few years ago I was very poor. I still paid my half of the house on time but could not afford a good winter coat and I have a disability that vastly reduces my mobility in cold temperatures. My friend, kind soul that she is, lent me hers.

My dad heard about me needing a coat and said that he wanted to get me one for Christmas. I asked for the same one as my housemate had as it had kept me very warm and sent him the link where she got it from. He responded that it was a fake, that he had found the real manufacturer and bought one from there.

When my housemate saw the coat she commented that they were slightly different. I noted to myself that mine had buttons of a different material and a label on the inside that said the brand name.

Recently she has claimed that my coat is actually hers and that we've been wearing the wrong ones for a while. This is feasible because they're next to eachother on the coat rack and outwardly look the same and are the same size. However mine has the different label in and I was sure I was wearing the right one. She insisted it was hers though.

Later on I asked her to stop using my cutelry and buy her own, as she was leaving it to go mouldy in her room and I was having to buy new dishware every few months. I bought myself a set and so did she. Her set looked similair to mine. Recently her set has gone mouldy and she's begun using mine again. She's keeping it in her room.

This week we both started a diet based around protein shakes. She took one of my glasses from my cupboard and said it was hers and that it had been a gift from her sister. It is exactly the same as the rest of the glasses in the set that I bought and now I only have 3 glasses when I know I bought 4.

I don't know if these are misunderstandings or what. I don't begrudge her a £2 glass, or a cheap cutlery set (though I've moved my coat to my room because I know my dad paid a lot for it). But I'm getting frustrated that she seems to be lying in order to obtain these things. Or maybe it's just all a mistake? Maybe it's me getting mixed up and not her. I'm not sure.

Tl;dr: My housemate keeps claiming that my things are actually hers. Is this a mix-up, lying or am I in the wrong?

Posted Apr 30, 2020, 5:32 AM UTC

10
AsILayTyping•

Sounds like she's taking advantage of you. You know these things are yours. Don't let her gaslight you. You must stand up for yourself.

110
[deleted]•

[deleted]

15
lotus138•

Get a label maker. Problem solved.

52
[deleted]•

[deleted]

15
Smokedeggs•

Make sure you write your name in the coat that is actually yours. Don’t let her gaslight you into believing the real one is hers.

26
TheCuriosity•

This kind of person will continue even if you label things.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
TheCuriosity•

I really hope it helps. Stay strong. I've had shitty people like her do the same in my life when I was younger and they can be relentless. I doubted myself in response,and wish I stood up. Don't stand down!

5
Anseranas•

A cheap engraver $10 from a hardware store will be permanent. I suspect she'll just scrub the sharpie off and use that as 'proof' that it's hers.

3
Evie_St_Clair•

Nail polish is also a good option. If you put things in the dishwasher you might want to buy a pen specifically for porcelain etc so it doesn't wash off.

2
gulwver•

Start getting things that are distinctly different from hers. If it’s a different color or size or shape she can’t claim that it got mixed up and if she does then you know she’s purposefully doing it

9
MrsMeteor•

Ask your dad where he bought the coat, and compare the link to your coat. She absolutely is trying to pull a fast one on you and take your coat.

5
BenneB23•

I'll bet she will remove them.

3

Man, this is why I don't often recommend living with friends. I've had friends of friends who have lost friendships because living together has revealed the other person to be a horrid, inconsiderate person who hasn't cared much for boundaries, a standard of cleanliness or that you shouldn't take what's not yours.

She may be your best friend for now but she is not a good roommate. Moldy cutlery? That's a level of disgusting I wouldn't deal with in a partner or a roommate.

The jacket thing is weird, some people have a real problem admitting they don't have the latest and greatest or that what they use is actually a cheap knockoff of something legitimately expensive. I think the bigger thing is her uncleanliness when it comes to dishes, no respect for your property. The fact you are hiding the coat right now means you subsconsciously no longer trust her with your stuff.

Sometimes good friends don't make great roommates. You can confront her but I think ultimately this may mean you both need to find somebody else to live with.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
butactuallywhytho•

It’s not loopy it’s the impact of cumulative manipulation.

Also.. you guys plan to stay together until you’re precisely 32? Is that what you want?

12
ScytheTheHero•

You shouldn't be having to clean up after someone who isn't your literal child.

3
parthizo•

When I was a sophomore in college, I moved in with my best friend that I had from 7th grade up until when we graduated together.

It was the worst decision I have ever made and we no longer speak

3
facinationstreet•

JC you know what the truth is. Stop being a door mat for her

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

She's a pathological liar, using you, gaslighting you and making you think that you're wrong.

I've been through this myself, learned my lesson, Never live with your "best friends" Imo it's a bad idea.

I'm gonna give you a trick that my mom does, my mom has a few things in the kitchen that she has marked with an unwashable nail polish, a lot of my relatives have dishes and pots similar to ours, and my mom doesn't want hers to get mixed up in family gatherings, she usually paints the nail polish on the underside of the kitchen cutlery. Or do what Monica does, she puts numbers on her cups, to know which one is missing.

9
ladyp92858•

Get a new room mate problem solved and see your initials in your coat she knows yours is the real deal

6
youvegotpride•

I definitely agree with the others, she might be the jealous/envious type and is gaslighting you, thinking only of herself.

I just don't get this part

Later on I asked her to stop using my cutelry and buy her own, as she was leaving it to go mouldy in her room and I was having to buy new dishware every few months.

You couldn't just wash it?

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kevthekereru•

Is this new behaviour or has she always been like this and you've just recently noticed? They're not misunderstandings, but a 9-year friendship may mean gentle gloves to handle it.

Could it be a case of you simply needing to be more assertive?

"This is my coat"
"I bought that"
"It's part of a set"

You don't need to argue, just state facts and move on like it doesn't bother you, but keep repeating the truth.

Oh and write your name in the coat. The good one.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Bookaholicforever•

Your housemate sounds like an opportunistic thief. If she has taken your jacket, get your dad to send you the receipt and tell her that she either gives it back or you will tell all of your friends exactly what she’s been doing to you. She’s taken your stuff and is fucking with your head Until you don’t know what’s up and what’s down. Start buying things that are super distinctive. With the cutlery you could get those little engraving tools and make a distinctive mark on all your stuff.

2
NotWithstandingNickOP•

Thankyou everyone for the comments, on both sides. A good reminder to be firm but calm. Thankyou.

1
angryangrycrickett•

Yeah write your name on stuff...but also stop buying stuff that looks exactly like her stuff...? Like, did you need the exact same coat in the exact same color? I guess there isn't enough variation in cutlery to make it easy there lol but after being best friends with someone for 9 years, you've probably shared lots of clothes, and share hobbies and friends etc. so it's easy to be like, "we have the same coat, no big deal, I'd be borrowing hers all the time anyway"...but actually these small things can be important in maintaining a sense of individual identity within a close relationship, especially when you live together and the lines start to get blurred.

I don't agree with the people jumping to the fact that she's a manipulative thief lol. My husband has a terrible memory, and he's likely to hear a funny story and then recount it to someone else a few days later as if it happened to him--and legit not realize it didn't happen to him, because he just forgot who told him the story in the first place and his mind filled in the blanks. The first time it happened I was like wtf, but then I told him and he apologized and now all our friends know and whenever he does it we all yell at him, "Hey, that's MY story!" and he turns red. We both have navy blue hoodies that are identical except for the fabric weight and the color of the string on the hoodie and it legit took him six months to learn whose was whose.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1