Best first test prints

Question

Hello fellow Photon users, just got my photon yesterday and have been doing some major reserch since.

​

Looking to do some first test prints so i went to the classic Anycubic cube, also DL'd the ameralabs town, benchy and the elegoo rook.

​

Ran the lot through the photon file validator and found out that both the town and the cube have some islands when printed flat. I've ditched the two and just going with the good old benchy and the rook for my first print.

​

What does everybody else use to test the printer calibration ?

Also wondering why these two highly recomended prints have islands ?

​

thanks for the feedback

Posted Apr 30, 2020, 1:58 PM UTC

10
itszak90210Photon•

I used the lattice cube that came with the photon scaled down by 50% as my first print. My suggestion is to do prints that take a short amount of time as your first test prints. I feel like I learned more trying to do consecutive shorter prints and having failures, than trying to print a 3-5 hour print and having one failure.

1
starbugstoneOPPhoton•

after a half failed print on a 4 hour print time, I realy see your point.

Time to downscale while testing. thanks for the great advice :-D

2
Shadow8136Photon S•

The models aren't perfect but they work. Some islands can print as long as they aren't integral to the print's structure, but the rook works just as well. It's mostly up to personal preference. I use Ameralabs, and some benchies.

1
starbugstoneOPPhoton•

Thanks for the tips,

My benchie ripped off the plate half way through (hull finished but ripped off when it came to the deck), rook came out fine though so too much suction somewhere.

Searching how to fix of if to just ignore since my actual prints shall be angled and will have less suction.

​

i'll try the ameralabs to see how the fine details come out.

1
FreynirPhoton•

What I regularly use to find out if the base needs releveling is simple hexagonal mini base (which for all intents and purposes is a little hexagonal bowl). I would recommend printing a little mini with a lot of detail to polish the settings. As others said, something small and quick to print.

1
starbugstoneOPPhoton•

Thanks,

i like the small simple hexa idea. Going to give that a try ;-).

Not got all the way into suppots yet so th Minis will be for this weekend. unless my thingiverse searching comes up with a self supported mini.

1
pangolinestPhoton S•

Islands are a tricky issue. See, islands remain on the FEP (and cure like a flat projection aka sum of the layers) until there comes a layer that is connected with them enough to "pick up" them. If you browse the subbreddit, one of the recuring themes is "why part of my print if flat". It is just that. People dont give enough supports or accidentaly leave islands so parts printing flat untill they connect with the rest of the print at some layer. Therefore, small islands that would be picked up 1-5 layers later isnt that much of a hassle if your standarts are not extremely high and would not impact much neither final print not vat cleaning procedure.

1
starbugstoneOPPhoton•

Thanks for the precice deatils about islands. I was under the impression that all islands wer bad and could damage the FEP (or worse). Now I see that they can fix themselves in certan situations but will impact details.

Still got to finaly get my brain around the printing logic !

1
pangolinestPhoton S•

Its quite simple, really. MSLA printers use not very durable and quite expensive for its kind FEP film instead of some sort of gorilla glass because they rely on its UV resistance (opposed to most plastic films), resinphobic properties and ability to elasticly deform. During exposure of each layer it sticks both to the build plate and FEP film to a certain degree. After that build plate starts to rise and FEP is gradualy peels off the layer, like a duct tape. That audiable periodic thonk you hear during printing is your FEP slapping the LCD after unsticking completely.

Of course, that process has its drawbacks. Low exposure resin is more detailed but less rigid and prone to peel and break in various ways under tension, high exposure is more rigid, but has worse details, prone to bloating and hole closing due to UV light bleed (cause resin is obviously UV-transparent and lower layers still get some UV when curing current one) and other reasons, and moreover sticks more (which is a good thing when you want your layer to really stick, like a base layer, but creates greater tension forces everywhere while unsticking). So you need to choose a proper exposure for your resin and needs. Usually you print R_E_R_F model. For photon S it is a test file that consists of 8 instances of the same model, each one with its own exposure time. So you can compare the how different details came out and what is acceptible for your goals.

As for the islands, your model dont always pick up them - in certain cases bridges can be too thin or exposure time too low and you will end up with parts of your model on the bottom of the VAT. You have to do the same what printer does - gently deform it upwards so the resin part just pops, simple as that. Trying to shift it may require quite amount of force and you can accidently damage the film. I would recommend to filter your resin each time you have islands on your model, even if you're sure they were picked up or left it the VAT (i do it every print regardless). You buy regular paint filters in bulk, because they are exactly what is shipped with your printer.

1
starbugstoneOPPhoton•

Wow thanks for the realy detailed reply. that has demisitified a load of things.

didn't know about the R_E_R_F but that sounds just like what I'm after to finish dialing in my resin settings (I did check on the google sheet but there is a wide range for anycubic grey).

Big thanks for taking the time to help out a Noob ;-)

1