How can I write a horror campaign set in modern times?
My players and I decided to play a horror campaign in 2022 in university and the town around it but I'm not sure how to write a horror/mystery campaign.
Posted May 1, 2020, 1:10 PM UTC
My players and I decided to play a horror campaign in 2022 in university and the town around it but I'm not sure how to write a horror/mystery campaign.
Posted May 1, 2020, 1:10 PM UTC
Easiest answer is watch some obscure horror movies or read old books (so your players don’t instantly think...”hey, this is Paranormal Activity”
Off the top of my head I’d be tempted to run a version of The Bay. People in a seaside town start acting...different. Disease? Aliens? Government experiments? Giant tongue eating marine lice? You choose. How can the party know who to trust? Can they trust each other?
This. Read and Watch. You need to learn the tropes of the game. Once you have that you can think about which system best fits those tropes and how to add them. You can't do this if you are familiar with the genre.
Thanks,and of course happy cake day good sir!
You may wish to look into to an alternative instead of D&D. Possibly Call of Cthulhu or Delta Green. Its good to research into possible alternatives though to see what works best for you and your group. That's not to say you couldn't run a horror game in D&D. I would recommend if so using film tropes as possible ideas to use within your campaign. Hope this was helpful.
I would like to run Call of Cthulhu but I've never run it and my players have never played it.
There is nothing wrong with learning a new system. It can offer a different narrative experience and so spending time learning how to play Call of Cthulhu will help when running different games. Also playing another system allows you to identify rules etc from different games and carry them over to other games. hope this made sense and helped.
I’m running to concurrent campaigns for my table, one in D&D and one in CoC. No one played Call of Cthulhu before (and I never ran it). My advice is to get the starter set and play the introduction adventure yourself. It’s basically a choose your own adventure story like Goosebumps, but with dice rolls. It helps you quickly learn the rules. Then, run your party through the same adventure. Part of the adventure is building your character step by step through narration (hey where’d you come from, what’s your job, etc). That way your focus can be on helping your players learn the game.
I also recommend reading some Lovecraft, Poe, Dunsany, and the other weird tales authors. Call of Cthulhu is definitely built for that cosmic horror. My group just started to lose Sanity points (one of my favorite mechanics in CoC) which signaled that the story is getting going.
The campaign is a sequel to Lovecraft’s At the Mountains of Madness, in which a group of explorers in Antarctica find an ancient alien city and discover the horrible truth about the humanity’s history. In my campaign, they’re part of a follow up expedition trying to find out the truth of what happened to the first expedition, since most of them died or went insane. The first act grounds the players in reality. There’s little risk and skill rolls are for stuff like checking the cargo manifest. There’s a B plot to keep things exciting and lay the foundation for later discovery but for the most part there’s little danger. For horror, you need to provide a reference point. In my opinion, that’s why D&D makes for poor horror; there’s already so many fantastic things happening, there’s little room for real scares.
Now the players are in Antarctica and they lost half their supplies in the first few encounters. And they began to lose sanity as they discover corpse-littered shipwrecks. Characters in Call of Cthulhu are fragile because the danger should be real.
I’d recommend listening to a few episodes of a podcast of Vampire: the Masquerade (a grimdark one, not a goofy one) and see how the Storyteller sets up situations to scare in a game about modern horror. The advantage with VTM is you can also get a sense of how your own creatures act- how do the vampires interact with mortals? How does that reflect in how your power dynamic is set up?
The modern setting part of your question is pretty straightforward—it can just be the real world. The question seems to be, What makes a horror?
According to the Save the Cat scriptwriting framework, the main tropes of horror are:
Goals for the people are to try to escape (which is futile), or to defeat the monster.
If you read and watch a lot of the genre, you’ll pick up some details and ways that movies have pushed the boundaries of these tropes or outright broken them.
E.g.: Final Destination - SPOILERS!!
So, you can see that there’s some big stretching of the tropes going on. Some other movies like Cabin in the Woods literally tell you the tropes as it goes along (like The Herald) so that may be useful to you, too.
Maybe you set it up like horrible eldritch abominations, and abberations have somehow leaked into the real world, and to incorporate dnd classes maybe some heroes spilt in with them. Like some kind of tear between realities.
When it comes to horror games, I try and work back from the source. Take a threat, something that will create that thrill/fear aspect whether its a killer, monster, or supernatural force. Come up with its abilities, then work out where this will happen (as you've mentioned its a university).
So, if something like (Insert Thing) came to this university, what would it do, what would it want, what could people see and what would it leave behind? Think of the characters who might have been killed, interacted with and how they might react to these stressors.
From those considerations you have basically wrote your into, just flesh out any strong clues and think of the game like a trail of breadcrumbs to the final event you want to happen.
Watch a bunch of horror/mystery movies and you'll see how you can break down the same process.
East Texas University for Savage Worlds has a plot point campaign called Degrees Of Horror. It's basically a modern supernatural horror. Think Buffy goes to college. If you're set on the DnD rules you could rip off the story and do some conversions.
If you're set on wanting to play DnD, look into D20 modern, it's by wizards of the coast
Maybe you set it up like horrible eldritch abominations, and abberations have somehow leaked into the real world, and to incorporate dnd classes maybe some heroes spilt in with them. Like some kind of tear between realities.
Maybe you set it up like horrible eldritch abominations, and abberations have somehow leaked into the real world, and to incorporate dnd classes maybe some heroes spilt in with them. Like some kind of tear between realities.
Maybe you set it up like horrible eldritch abominations, and abberations have somehow leaked into the real world, and to incorporate dnd classes maybe some heroes spilt in with them. Like some kind of tear between realities.
Take a look at the Call of Cthulhu(CoC) TTRPG. Even if you're running d&d, CoC is more modern and has some good templates for creating horror adventures. If I remember correctly it also has a section in the lore keepers guide about ways to narrate spooky stuff, as does the d&d DMs guide
Call of Cthulhu and the SCP foundation are both good references for modern horror.
The best horror campaign I ever ran was that the players were needing to enter an underground base for an organization that captured eldritch monsters.
Inside there were 2 monsters that were loose; one with mental manipulation powers that could force players to face their worst nightmares, even when it wasn't anywhere near them, and the other is an invulnerable dog that could teleport to anywhere (Hound of Tindalos). One mentally intimidating, one physically. And the best part? The players couldn't fight either of them. They could only run and desperately try to reach the end of the base before the two killed them.
They never knew what was real, never knew if they were making progress, all the while desperately trying to hide from an immortal dog that could find them anywhere.
Damn man, that's scary as hell. Perm-threats (like an immortal dog that can find you anywhere) are some of the best ways to incite horror. You gotta make sure your players never feel safe
I think you said something important for horror in D&D but it should be really pointed out. The player should never feel safe, but that's the key word, never FEEL safe. The players should have moments away from the action, lulls in the onslaught. But they should always feel like the enemy could be right around the corner.
Because you can have the players always under attack, and then the players are always in danger. But then it gets tiring and predictable. There needs to be an ebb and flow. Sometimes they are being attacked by the dog, other times the illusions, other times both, and even more importantly....sometimes neither. They never know what to expect, but they know they are ALWAYS in danger.
Yeah, you are exactly right! I didn't really say it explicitly but they should always feel like they're in peril, even if you, the DM, know that they aren't at the moment. The threat of danger at any moment is much more effective at creating horror than actually being in dangerous situations all the time. Like a lot of good horror movies or books, it's 90% suspense, buildup, and spooky music, and 10% epic scare to cap it off.