"Are they natural??" Cross post from r/parentsofmultiples

Hi everyone,

So I'm 12 weeks pregnant with twins and as such, I've started telling a much wider audience about my pregnancy.

I'm a pretty private person and we actually struggled to get pregnant. We needed some intervention by way of hormonal treatment to make me ovulate. My husband and I would then do the deed on the necessary days once the fertility clinic confirmed they could make me ovulate.

Already, with the few that I've told, people keep asking if the twins are "natural". I'm really not comfortable saying "I guess not as we were going to a fertility clinic, but we did have sex to make them so is that what you define as natural? What exactly do you mean?". It makes me feel like I'm not carrying "real" twins because we required medical help to conceive.

I've thought about replying with something to make them uncomfortable/realize what they are asking but that would make the conversation uncomfortable for both of us and I don't do well in awkward situations. I wanted to just innocently ask, "what do you mean?" so that they would realize they are asking a very personal question.

I guess I'm looking for experiences from other people who needed intervention (whether it was hormonal treatment, IUI, IVF, whatever) and how they dealt with or responded to comments like that. I also just want to not feel inadequate because my twins aren't technically "natural". Unfortunately, it seems that being pregnant with twins opens you up to that prying question a lot more than a singleton (as I'm assuming people's minds automatically go to fertility treatments when talking about multiples) but I suspect other pregnant women here have had related stories even if they are not pregnant with multiples.

Thank you!

Posted May 2, 2020, 12:24 AM UTC

3122
dental_work•

"are they natural?"

"No dumbass they're robot twins."

Wtf are they even trying to ask? They're babies not fruit gummies

46
nacfme•

What ate you comfortable saying? "I had some help to ovulate and it worked really well"?

"I hope so. I don't react well to colours and preservatives. If they aren't natural this pregnancy is going to suck"?

"We got them the old fashioned way with lots of sex"?

"Yeah they aren't GMO, they are free range organic"?

"I'm really hoping at least one is a dinosaur or something equally as cool"?

"My husband and I made them, I guess that makes them man-made?"?

"Does sacrificing a goat on the third night of the new moon while chanting count as natural?"

"One is, the other started out as their imaginary friend but somehow became real".

Just answer however you like.

People are probably just trying to make conversation without realising how nosey they are being. I think with fertility treatments being more common and more likely to result in multiples that's most people's experience with multiples. They're probably just curious.

35
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Well these are hilarious! I particularly enjoy the imaginary friend one!!! And yes, I agree people don't mean harm by it and don't realize its a super nosy question, which is why I know I'm going to continue to get the question. Will try out some of these next time! Hahab

9
newmomma2020•

Wow, these are amazing! I love the one about the imaginary friend šŸ˜‚

3
goosiebabyFTM EDD 7/19/18•

Rude and it's not their business if it took some shots or a pre bedtime jackhammer because the opk was blue. Stare and respond with "Are your boobs natural?"

17
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

I would love to say that lol

3
Kwinners1120•

I’ve been thinking about this a lot (not pregnant yet but fresh transfer Monday!! It’s like Christmas!!)- so our route to pregnancy is/was not ā€œnaturalā€ but with out science, we wouldn’t be able to celebrate this miracle. This embryo is 100% our DNA and as natural as he or she can get. Then I get this weird guilty feeling about wanting things more ā€œnaturalā€ with our pregnancy and subsequent delivery but I also want to be safe.

I hate the meaning around ā€œnaturalā€ and anything childbearing, as if doing anything less than natural doesn’t qualify that women for true motherhood. we’ve gone through enough for this, and I don’t want the natural police to rain on my parade.

But honestly, for me it is going to depend on context. (if Twins or just nosey probing into our sex life) Stranger at the coffee shop? None of your damn business, no it’s actually a robot. i amazon prime’d it. But friends and family we haven’t told? Full disclosure. Because we are badass women for going through this to carry such amazing miracles.

Congratulations, on your natural, wonderful, and amazing twins. They were naturally your eggs, your partners sperm, and are 100% real.

10
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Yes that's exactly it. I know they are well-meaning and just curious, and have no idea that it could bring up negative feelings for me if my response is "no, they are not natural". I'm thinking maybe the response will be "if you mean did we do fertility treatment to conceive, then no, they aren't natural.". That's gotta make them uncomfortable. It's just an imposition. You're asking me basically point-blank a question that I do not want to answer to you on.

I agree I also hate the word "natural". There's this implication that natural is better so suddenly my twins aren't as good as "natural" twins. It honestly irks me even when people say they had a "natural" birth for that reason when really they mean it was unmedicated.

And thank you for the congrats on my REAL twins.

5
_Winterlong_•

So I’m pregnant for the 6th time (5 miscarriages) via ivf with a singleton and I knew I would get this question because people knew we had been trying for years. Unfortunately, being polite does NOT work because people push for more info or have rude things to say (like ā€œwhat was wrong with you?ā€). I usually look them dead in the eyes and say ā€œwhat do you mean?/why would you say that?/I don’t understand why you are asking that questionā€. Overall it’s been good - it catches them off guard, they blush and apologize.

8
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Yes, would like to take the same approach!

1
Hurmetik•

Hey there, say whatever makes you comfortable, make a joke about your boobs, say yes, say 'its personal' it means way more to you then to them. People ask the damnedest questions, and they don't realize that they could be polking at a sensitive issue. Usually they are coming from their own experience 'was it planned' and or trying to connect. Twins pique curiosity, because they are pretty rare and exciting!

I'd come up with a planned response, and don't take it personally, the good thing is people like that don't take offense easily, so you whatever response you come up with will probably be cool with them either way.

5
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Thank you. Those are good ideas, I agree I need to come up with my canned response. I'm thinking I will just say "it was quite a surprise!" which doesn't answer the question at all and there's no way they are going to ask it again.

5
Hurmetik•

Silence is also an acceptable answer. That's what my husband does when people ask 'was it planned' we are very private people and being pregnant doesn't change that.

3
got-the-juiceTeam Both!•

We are pregnant after struggling to conceive and having to go in for treatment. Ended up being successful after an IUI and were astonished to find out we're having twins! Haven't gotten the question "Are they natural" but get a lot of "Oh! Do twins run in your family?" Which they don't. I usually respond with "Nope, waited for the BOGO promo at our fertility place." I don't mind talking about having to get help; it was a difficult process to go through, and sometimes it feels good to have that acknowledged. But it's up to you what you want to share.

I do find the "natural" question more obtrusive than the "family" question, though. I agree that flipping it on them is a good way to make them aware of what they're asking because it truly isn't any of their business. Maybe ask how they define "natural" and what difference it makes anyways? I mean, really-- are they implying your twins are subhuman? That's ridiculous. It's really a weird question to ask.

4
PurpleRoseGold•

Wow! Why would someone ask such a question is beyond me. Unless someone volunteers this information, it is absolutely no ones business how someone feeds their kid, how they deliver, how they conceive or how many kids (including zero) they choose to have.

I can borderline deal with people giving my belly attention but this just crosses a line!

3
witchwinds•

"Yes! He came right on my cervix and everything! It was so hot."

I've been asked if my pregnancy was accidental BY A MAN I DID NOT KNOW, you know cause I'm not married yet, and don't have a wedding band. Honestly, it wasn't accidental, and that would get more questions than saying it was... i just said "excuse me?" I think he realized he was being inappropriate and backtracked while a friend of mine (that knows him) shoo'd him away. I wish I'd had something clever to say to him.

The inappropriate comments will just keep coming. People are rude.

3
tunabuttons•

The logic that you were doing something that increased the likelihood of twins so they're not "natural" is so weird, like being pregnant at all would only be natural if you slipped and fell in a puddle of baby gravy out in the woods because if you tracked your ovulation or got fertility drugs, well that's cheating.

I think this attitude comes from the same place that calling unmedicated births "natural" comes from - you get any help involving medicine and you're downgraded to unnatural. Obnoxious.

3
lrngray•

I’d say you didn’t use IVF, but took some fertility meds. Most twins these days are not naturally occurring. It is a rude question to ask though.

2
cornflake_cakes•

"no, we made them"

2
kris10dub•

It’s possible the people asking might be considering fertility treatments for themselves or know someone close who is, and is looking for a connection, resource, help or even hope. I’m sorry you feel the stigma against it and ā€œnaturalā€ is not a good term, but I feel like a lot of that is because people aren’t educated and don’t talk about it enough to know how to talk about it. Depending on who it is and your comfort level, I would try to mentally give them the benefit of the doubt and be open. The more you embrace and normalize something the less negative connotations it will have. I always say if you can fake it that something is not awkward, it makes it less awkward in real life. But also you personally should not feel any guilt or remorse whatsoever. Frankly, you probably worked a lot harder and put a lot more effort, time, money and emotion into conceiving your baby than those without any help and you should take pride in that. And lastly science is awesome, not shameful. Just imagine infertility like any other medical ailment. You’d never think someone with cancer should be ashamed or feel guilt for having it!

1
PurpleRoseGold•

While I agree overall, I think people who go through infertilty should have the choice to speak up when they want to as opposed to random strangers triggering with obscene words. The stigma of infertility cannot be erased overnight until then we have to be careful.

1
carolinax•

What an obscene question!!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1