DAE think CBCs "vote compass" should show aggregate and regional data? I'm very curious.
For those that haven't tried.
Posted Mar 27, 2011, 11:17 AM UTC
For those that haven't tried.
Posted Mar 27, 2011, 11:17 AM UTC
My professor designed and developed this tool - if anyone has any serious questions about it I'd be happy to speak to her about them or try to provide answers myself based on the class of hers that I'm currently taking.
That's one of my few regrets of going to a small university, my political science prof only gets interviewed by the local news outlets.
A bunch of my friends and I have been sharing our results, and the parties are never quite in the same position from one result to another. Can you or your professor explain why the parties seem to shift around?
Kind of linked to this question, almost every single one of my friends got "Green Party" even though none of us have voted Green despite being well aware of their policies and ideals. In fact, my friends were all scattered across the spectrum, generally voting Liberal with some NDPers and Conservatives...yet we all got the Green Party. The only connection we can find between all of our answers is that we disagreed with the tar sands and we were in favour of the carbon tax.
Is the compass perhaps skewing to Green for anyone who indicates the environment as an important issue?
I can provide a counter example: I was in favor of a Pigovian tax on negative environmental externalities, but the compass recommended Conservatives for me.
Do you think you could provide me with some screenshots?
What's the word, weaselbag?
Bird is the word, my friend.
My apologies, I've been swamped the last few days. I don't have class with her again until tomorrow, I'll answer all questions then!
I'm not surprised they placed me in the Green Party zone. However, I won't vote for them this time(the candidate in my area is not fit for politics),but I guess I'll donate a couple dollars instead.
No, but I had to chuckle when Duceppe came in second as my pick for PM. I live in BC.
I'm quite pleased by their privacy policy. Only a few paragraphs and very readable.
Edit: Did a little more digging...
[Q] What is the relationship between Vote Compass and CBC?
[A] CBC News is the Vote Compass media sponsor for the 2011 Canadian federal election. CBC News provides support and promotion for Vote Compass and, in return receives exclusive access to real-time analysis from the academic team...
I'd love to get access to that real time data. It would be a bookies dream.
It means some interesting CBC News articles coming up I think.
They should do this every election from now on and refine and upgrade it. This is brilliant and I think every Canadian should be required to use it before the vote.
I don't mean this as a flame or a troll, but I'd rather Canadians read about the parties, meet the candidates, and investigate their voting records rather than vote for the party an online tool tells them is the best match.
Not a flame or a troll. I agree with you, but we live in a world where the vast majority of people are completely politically apathetic. Maybe tools like this will start to get people aware of the issues and get people wake up to the political process.
I think they're planning on doing that in the future, but they have to collect a reasonable amount of data first.
[deleted]
Well according to this poll I am not a socially liberal as I thought and that my closest match is liberal.
I'm a bit surprised they don't, seeing as how they ask your province and riding. Maybe they're just waiting until enough people take the test.
If not riding-level, it'd be interesting to see province-level. I bet the great 'monoliths' in Canada (rural Alberta, West Montréal) aren't as monolithic in opinion as their voting trends would suggest.
[deleted]
You're probably right, though FWIW that wouldn't be valid polling data, since it's not a random sample.
No, I think it's fine. This is how one really should be deciding how to vote, based on how close the political parties are to one's own priorities and opinions. The only thing I don't like about the survey is that it is based too much on memes created by the politicians themselves.
The vote compass web app has highlighted something glaringly obvious.
If you look at the final map, the conservative party is down at the lower right, and the Greens, Liberals, and NDP form this nice little equilateral triangle at the top left. The BQ is in the middle of this triangle, right where my own marker appears to be, and I'm in BC.
So here I am, trying to figure out which "anything but conservative" vote I have to make, choosing between three parties who represent my interests equally well, and one party who would represent my views near perfectly if the weren't separatist and even then I couldn't vote for them.
Now isn't the right time to talk about it, but on May 3rd, these parties shouldn't be talking coalition, they should be talking merger. Hopefully it doesn't take them a Kim Campbell style loss to start talking about it.
"anything but conservative"
Or, "anything but harper". Either way, that is the situation we're in, isn't it? Neo-con esque harper or somebody else. Add to that: the bloc, making majority-left all that much harder. I'm sick of this deadlock!
My local Conservative MP is pretty dreadful - to the point where I'm not sure which would be worse: my local MP being booted out and a Conservative majority, or the Conservatives being booted out and my MP sticking around.
My riding once went 35% Conservative, 32% Liberal, 30% NDP. It gets pretty frustrating here.
If anyone is interested, I composited all of the party policy analysis at the end of the poll into a single image
Here's a link to the source reddit post
Not surprised they chose me as a Liberal as I usually vote Liberal or Green. I'm surprised that I was actually closer to the Bloc than the Greens though. Last election I couldn't stand the Liberal MP who was running, and it looks like she's running again (she lost last time in a tight race), so I went Green. I haven't made up my mind about how I'm voting yet as I'm not sure who all my local candidates are and I haven't read through any of the party platforms yet. But for those that won't do nearly that much work before they vote, a tool like this should be helpful.
Haven't we all learned that a voluntary survey does not produce reliable data????
No way, that's why a voluntary long form census is totally reliable.
[deleted]
I'm disappointed that arts and culture hasn't been included in votecompass; this is either an oversight, or it is a reflection of the possibility that arts and culture simply isn't a plank in anyone's platform. I was surprised to find myself in the Green Party area, but wonder whether I wouldn't have found myself in the Liberal zone if the arts had been part of the questionnaire.
artbar
Well I accidentally the thing, so I hope not.
Nah. Showing people the people who are likely to win in their riding may skew the results of the election.
"What? Conservative in my riding? I am switching to Liberal from NDP because they may have a better chance."
Sometimes it is better not to know.
I find strategic voting a really frustrating result of our parliamentary system. I'm not a huge drum-banger for electoral reform, but it would be really nice if the system worked in such a way that you vote for the candidate you prefer, and your vote always counts.
I agree that strategic voting is an unfortunate product of our current system. Frankly, I would welcome a change to a runoff system, it could produce some very interesting and hopefully accurately representative, results.
I really like the French Two-Round system. First they vote for all the candidates, then if none of them achieve more than 50% they have a second vote between the top two. Et voila, majority support.
It would obviously be more complicated and take longer in Canada, but we could have two-round voting for each riding.
Coline de bine that's a good idea!
Thank you, but what does "Coline de bine" mean?
FTFY. A parliamentary system is not relevant here. FFP has the same effect in a bicameral system like the US' constitutional republic.
... umm, I think you better re-read your intro poli sci textbook. Canada is also bicameral (meaning two houses form the legislative branch of government). However you are correct about First Past the Post.
You are right. And I knew that, it was just successive edits to my comment that left that cruft in there.
Agreed, but FWIW, he meant "result of our parliamentary system", not "result of our parliamentary system".
Leave it to Reddit to understand both what I said, and what I meant. ;)
It doesn't have to be by riding. It could be by CMA, or even by province.
But people do polling anyway.