How long should a 105 drivetrain last?

I've been riding my 2018 Specialized Diverge for 2 years now, at about 200kms a month on average. Lots of gravel riding. I clean and lube the drivetrain about once a month, and make sure the derailleurs are indexed properly and whatnot each time. But in the last couple months I've been having lots of issues shifting, the chain occasionally comes off the front chainrings, and it just sounds nasty. It's like it just won't "hold" for very long after I make adjustments... Also missing a few teeth on the large front chainring.

Is it coming time to replace my drivetrain? Or maybe just cables, and the chainring? How much life should you get out of a 105 drivetrain, when you ride it pretty hard? (Or is there additional maintenance I should be doing / getting done at the shop?)

Thanks in advance for your insight, r/bikewrench!

Posted May 6, 2020, 2:51 PM UTC

222
willstew1848•

Have you ever changed your chain? A drivetrain usually lasts 2-6 chains in my experience.

If you've never changed your chain you may have done some damage to your cassette....

5
IseeMORONS•

A drivetrain usually lasts 2-6 chains in my experience.

By drivetrain, you mean the just the chain, cassette, chainrings, and cables/housing, right? The shifters, derailleurs, crankarms, and bottom bracket should last many years, sometimes decades.

Edit: This applies to Shimano drivetrains.

8
willstew1848•

Ehhh.... sorta depends IMO. I've found the switch to 1x chainrings are great for simplicity and function but I seem to wear through the soft aluminum rings by the time I'm on 2K miles.

But yeah, I agree a lot of those components will last way longer than the chain, cassette, or chainring. All of this depends on riding conditions, propensity for crashing, and how well maintenance is performed.

1
TronTimeOP•

I guess I'm talking about chain, cassette, chainrings, cables, AND derailleurs. The crank arms and shifters I'm not too worried about. The new-ish design of the 105 front derailleur sorta baffles me, it's not as simple as the older models it seems. It seems to eff up a lot.

1
IseeMORONS•

The new-ish design of the 105 front derailleur sorta baffles me

The R7000 front derailleur design is nothing like the designs before it. But there's no reason to think it won't last 10+ years if it's cared for.

1
TronTimeOP•

I have never changed my chain no. What sorta damage can it do to the cassette?

2
willstew1848•

Do a quick google. Fairly common issue folks encounter.

2
TronTimeOP•

Will do, thanks!

2
vanwhistlestein•

You have very likely worn out your chain, if not your cassette as well.

3
msgr_flaught•

Chain replacement is important, as others are saying. But you should replace your cables and housing if you haven’t already. When your cables and housing get old, shifting tends to be less precise and maybe slower too. It’s one of those things that degrades gradually so you may not notice the change. And then when you replace them it’s like a new bike.

If you don’t have these parts on hand, I recommend buying in bulk so you have the parts on hand. But a few meters of housing, a 10 pack of cables and a bottle of cable ends.

3
TronTimeOP•

Thanks! Will do the chain as well as the cables. The shifting is definitely slower than it used to be

1
jh_12345•

Have you replaced the chain? It sounds like that may be all you need, and maybe an adjustment, at this point. In general, if you replace the chain when you should, a cassette will last through 3 chains, and chainrings through 9 chains. And I get about 3,000 miles per chain. So that would be 27,000 miles before having to replace the chainrings, give or take a few thousand miles.

2
TronTimeOP•

Thanks, I have not, must be new chain time!

My big chain ring is missing a couple teeth - is that a big deal? I would think one or two is fine?

2
semyorka7•

if you took a brand new chainring and ripped off a few teeth, it would work fine. But teeth don't go missing all on their own. Missing teeth is usually a sign of damage or truly excessive drivetrain wear.

2
TronTimeOP•

Ya it's likely from hitting the ground, the bottom bracket is kinda low for some terrain. I checked while changing my chain today and it's just missing one tooth, and a few of the rest are looking a little shark finny, but not that bad

2
UniqueVegetable•

I've had the same symptoms on a much older bike. I tried to change a few parts, but it always seemed like the indexing would be off after a very short time.

I first changed the chain, then the cassette, then cleaned and lubricated the STI levers and changed all cables. Only after also getting new front chainrings shifting was good again.

Usually, chains and cables are replaced most often, so that's where I would start.

As for regular maintenance:

  • wash off sweat and sports drinks after long rides, they cause corrosion
  • make sure to keep your chain clean and lubricated. Once every month might not be enough if you do a lot of gravel riding. Maybe wipe it down with a rag between rides to get rid of the worst, or try a wax-based lubricant? Wax is supposed to shed dirt, but needs regular reapplication
  • regularly check whether the chain is worn out using a chain checker tool. Riding with a worn-out chain is really bad for the rest of the drivetrain.
  • cables don't last forever, replace them before they snap (see "thanksshimano" on Instagram). It's possible to replace just the inner cables without removing bar tape, but better to get new housings and tape as well. I'd probably do that every 1-2 years on my own bikes.
2
TronTimeOP•

Thank you!

1
IseeMORONS•

On a pure road bike, I'd expect 105 shifters, crankarms (not the rings), and derailleurs to last 10 years or more. With you riding only 200km/month, I'd expect the same.

  1. I've been having lots of issues shifting, the chain occasionally comes off the front chainrings.

Make sure your limit screws are properly set. If so, the next thing is to ensure your chainrings are true: Drop your chain to the bottom bracket and turn your cranks; using the front derailleur cage as your baseline, see if the chainrings are bent. Bent chainrings can drop chains or at the very least cause front derailleur rub.

Is it coming time to replace my drivetrain? Or maybe just cables, and the chainring?

Definitely clean and/or replace your cables and housing regularly. Changing the housing is more important than changing the cables.

1
semyorka7•

How long should a 105 drivetrain last?

The derailleurs and shifters should last 10-25 years. The cables should be replaced every 1-2 years, the housing should be replaced every 2-3 cables. The chain should be regularly measured for wear and proactively replaced. The cassette and chainrings should last 2-4 chains, depending on how early the chain is replaced.

Also missing a few teeth on the large front chainring

Is it coming time to replace my drivetrain?

It is waaaaay past time to replace the chainring, certainly the chain as well, and if you've let it get this far without ever replacing the chain, the cassette is gone as well. Definitely replace the cables as well.

1
TronTimeOP•

Thanks! How could I assess the health of the cassette? What sort of wear and tear am I looking for?

1
semyorka7•

As the rollers and pins on the chain wear and the chain "stretches", it stopped meshing properly with the cogs. If you continue to ride like that, it wears away at the teeth on the cogs. Eventually they will assume a "shark fin" shape, but they're effectively worn out well before then.

If you keep a worn cassette and swap a new chain onto it, the chain will not mesh perfectly with the worn teeth, which will cause the chain to prematurely wear. In the extreme case, the new chain will not mesh properly at all and will skip over the tops of the teeth - usually at the worst possible moment, when you stand up on the pedals and apply peak power.

It can be hard to visually assess wear on the cassette. ~4500kms of gravel riding on one chain (esp when the front rings are so worn they're shedding teeth) means it's almost certainly toast. I usually go a fair amount further than that on a cassette, but I also rarely go more than 2000km to a chain on my bikes that regularly ride in the dirt and muck.

1
TronTimeOP•

Thanks again, I did replace the chain today. Talked to a buddy who knows his stuff, he says the cassette looks ok for now, but the large chainring is toast. I'll replace that too, and heck maybe the cassette while I'm at it, or at least sometime this year

1