Sport vs FX4

I have been keeping an eye on the local market for the last 6 months. Mostly at 2009-2011 Rangers in the 100000km or less range.

I will mostly be driving forest service roads when I am not highway driving to forest service roads. So gravel roads with water bars in various states of maintenance. For the purpose of back country access.

I want a Ranger. Other trucks are just too big to park in my downtown condo parking garage.

I plan on making this a bit of a project vehicle. I should have bought the 2011 FX4 with 40000 km on it, but, the pandemic got in the way.

I recently saw a much cheaper sport version.

My question is: Is it worth paying $2000-$5000 dollars more for a FX4 over a sport? That is typically the price difference between these two models in my community.

Posted May 9, 2020, 6:15 PM UTC

37
HumboldtChewbacca•

It is a different differential and better shocks. Plus I don't know if the sport has skid plates or recovery hooks. You should be fine with a sport as long as there are not any demanding offroad situations. Plus you can upgrade to billsteins if ride quality is an issue.

Personally, I'd get the fx4 just because I like it. But it may not be worth the price difference.

2
beginagainagainbeginOP•

That was my initial thought. I was just second guessing myself because a sport with low kilometres come on to the market.

The sport does not have hooks or skid plate. I would get someone to do that for me. For $4000 you can get a few upgrades.

Thanks for weighing in.

1
HumboldtChewbacca•

And skid plates only get used in some rough terrain. I don't know what kind of water bars you're going over but it may not be necessary. I just like the extra peace of mind

2
beginagainagainbeginOP•

Steep and mountainous terrain. They vary from “the type you can fit a small truck in” to “I hope you remembered to remove your tow hitch because some asshole dug a narrow deep V that has rendered the concept of clearance useless”

2
HumboldtChewbacca•

Sounds like fx4 might be the choice

1
codepoet82'11 XLT 4.0L 4x4 M5OD-R1HD•

For what it's worth, I believe the 2009 was the last true FX4 with the 31 spline Torsen axle. In '10 and '11 the "FX4" branding was only a trim package on the Sport. Though these models do have a fancier traction control system that applies brakes on the slipping wheel in all trim levels. I'm not a huge fan, a real LS is better, and you can't completely disable the traction control system on the late models, it's always there waiting to step in.

You should be able to find the skid plate and tow hook as factory options on anything XLT and up as well if you keep an eye out. Mine has them as an XLT model, and without the plastic fenders which I don't really like the look of.

2
beginagainagainbeginOP•

Thank you.

I have done a ton of reading and have test driven a few Rangers but this is just not my area of expertise.

I read about the 31 spline and how it became optional after a couple of years. I see you have a 2011? Did you trade the axle out?

And I am with you on plastic fenders. My Vibe had them and I am pretty sure Toyota/Pontiac made their entire fortune on those little plastic clips that held them in place.

1